Your first couple paragraphs are a pretty good read. Then you take a hard left into fantasy land. Let me point out some things a guy with questionable intellect has noticed. Dak's footwork improved noticably the first 5 or 6 games in 2019. Then he started to revert to form. He still has major issues directing scoring inside the 20. Not something an "elite" QB still has issues with going into his 5th year, and a big reason why their offense took endzone shots from the 50. He'll never have touch on passes like screens. He's a throw to an area and the receiver has to get to the ball rather than a put the ball in an area for the receiver to catch. Consistency escapes him.
His positives are he's durable and willing to run when required. Doesn't seem to let anything effect him negatively. I see these things but don't believe I have some weird affliction to notice them. But when they play a team this coming year with a winng record and that "elite" QB struggles to direct at least 1 scoring drive, like he did several times last year, I'm going to struggle to come up with someone else to blame. I mean who's left?
This is a good effort at a response and I appreciate it.
It's at least addressable.
Game 7 last year Dak completed 77.8% of his passes. Are you really suggesting his footwork abandoned him in weeks 5 or 6?
In weeks 10 and 11 he combined for 841 yards passing. Yes, 841.
Most likely you, like a lot of detractors are ignoring two injuries that he played through with dimishing results.
The first was a finger injury. It was visibly swollen and we will never know how serious and he shook it off and played.
The second was the shoulder injury we are aware of versus the Rams.
His deep passer accuracy last year was VERY good. And VERY frequent.
20 yards plus:
- Top-10 in pass yards per attempt.
- 7th in touchdowns (7), pass TD% (13.0), and interceptions (2).
- 6th in rating (107.6)
20 isn't that deep so let's go 30+
From 30+ yards,
Dak’s stats now look like the following:
- 5th in touchdowns (4).
- 7th in pass TD% (14.3).
- 1st in interceptions (0).
- 2nd in rating (118.8).
There is an entire nerd analysis project based just on deep ball passing. It covers every metric known to mankind.
It ranks Dak 6th best in the NFL for 2019. He has been surprising good every year.
https://brickwallblitz.com/2020/02/21/the-2019-20-deep-ball-project-part-3-3/
As to the Red Zone stuff, no offense but you are just wrong.
NFL.com offers situational stats.
Dak 2019 from opp 19-goaline.
16 TDs, 0 INT. Yes. 0.
16 passing TD was tied for 9th most among all QBs. Only 3 QBs had both more Red Zone TD passes and 0 INTs. --Lamar was the best.
A QB rating well over 100 for Dak in the Red Zone.
Then of course you have his rushing impact which is massive in the Red Zone.
Dallas as a team in 2019 ranked 16th in Red Zone scoring of TDs alone.
Largely because they could not run the ball well in the red zone but kept trying.
ZEKE LED THE LEAGUE IN RED ZONE RUSHES.
He finished tied for 5th in rushing TDs in the Red zone.
Dallas was again Right on the median line, 16th overall. But one more TD would have put them at 10 or 11.
What you ABSOLUTELY did see was a terrible, terrible special teams that actually blew FGs from inside the 20 at a league high rate. Yes, highest in the NFL.
The rather pathetic kicking game cost us points, field position and ensured we routinely started at our own 20.
The EPA analysis suggests league average special teams and we win 10.6 games last year. --yes it does weird math but it was a net of minus 2.6 games