Creeper
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 15,563
- Reaction score
- 19,724
Yes, I am agreeing with you! I was referring to some comments about the Giants DTs, Williams and Lawrence. The Cowboys have not drafted a DT in the first round since 1991. But some of that was opportunity. The best DTs coming out of college usually go early in the draft. Lawrence was #17 in 2019, a year in which the Giants had 3 first round picks (and the Cowboys had 0), including #6 which they used on QB, Daniel Jones. My point was drafting that high that many times over a short period the Giants had much more opportunity than Dallas to find a stud DT. The Giants made a trade with Cleveland to get the pick they used to select Dexter Lawrence. It was the OBJ trade. The Giants got a 1st and 3rd, Kevin Zeitler, OG, and Jabrill Peppers, S, for OBJ and Olivier Vernon. This is why the Amari Cooper trade was a disaster for Dallas. OBJ was a good receiver for the Giants but he had baggage too which is why the Giants traded him. Olivier Vernon was almost done. I still find it hard to believe we could not have come up with a package to get more than a 5th for Cooper.I'm not sure what this has to do with the point of my post? My point is taking the Ridgeway's of the world in the 5th round is borderline meaningless, especially at DT. Lots of teams take DTs in the first round. And let's not forget the Cowboys have sacrificed 1st round picks......for glamour positions other than DT.
Updated - maybe you are agreeing with me? Apologies if I misunderstood your post.
I am not saying this is the only reason we don't have a stud like Lawrence. We could have moved up at any point in the draft and drafted a stud like the Eagles did to get Jordan Davis. Maybe the first round was too expensive, but we could have moved up for a guys Milton Williams or Davon Hamilton. Milton Williams can't crack the starting lineup for the Eagles but he would probably be the best DT on the Cowboys.
We could also find one in free agency. That's how the Giants got Leonard Williams. But you know how Jerry and Stephen feel about signing free agents from other teams.
But, yes, drafting in the DTs in the 5th and 6th rounds is unlikely to produce an impact DT. Not impossible but much harder than finding one in the 1st round. And you know the Cowboys feel the same way otherwise why expose Ridgeway in his rookie season to waivers where he could get picked up by another team.
The only conclusion we can draw is up to now the Cowboys simply do not value the position even though it is has been a weakness in the defense for years.