Toomer: Romo better than Eli

[jobberone]

Hopefully that starts to change THIS year!!

Oh yeah!

 

[Kingsmith88]

:laugh1:
That's awesome I've been looking for a gif like that.

 

[wittenacious]

Caught your new avatar. Sorry about the quick off-topic question, but is Nash gonna wear 11 for the Lakers (his old Santa Clara U jersey number) because he can't stay with 13, Wilt's retired jersey number? Hadn't heard.

 

[wittenacious]

I know Amani. I used to prod him on this subject all the time and he would never concede that Romo was better.

I don't think he really believes what he's saying. He likes to generate a little controversy.

Since you know him... and this is a serious question... is Amani really the type who'd be willing to offend NY Giants fans... his fans... by saying what he said: "I'd choose Romo" ... just to generate a little controversy? I mean, he wouldn't be the 1st ex-NFLer to do that sorta thing, but... ???

 

[D29Murray]

I know Amani. I used to prod him on this subject all the time and he would never concede that Romo was better.

I don't think he really believes what he's saying. He likes to generate a little controversy.

If that's the real case, ask him if he's got any juice left in the tank... and ask him if he'd like to come play with Romo as his QB.

Tell him to place a call to Jerry... just for fun...

Honestly, I'd rather have Toomer over Owens.

Only one of those guys actually IS a tumor.

 

[Lonestar94]

And for the record, until Tony wins a SB, the correct answer is Eli.

You are right. I would also choose players like Trent Dilfer, Brad Johnson, and Doug Williams over the others like Warren Moon, Dan Marino, and Jim Kelly. I mean its obvious, Superbowl Rings tell all.

 

[Primetime42]

Since you know him... and this is a serious question... is Amani really the type who'd be willing to offend NY Giants fans... his fans... by saying what he said: "I'd choose Romo" ... just to generate a little controversy? I mean, he wouldn't be the 1st ex-NFLer to do that sorta thing, but... ???

He likes to have fun with listeners.

 

[jnday]

Why does anyone really care about Toomer and Bennetts's opinions?

 

[CowboyMike]

You are right. I would also choose players like Trent Dilfer, Brad Johnson, and Doug Williams over the others like Warren Moon, Dan Marino, and Jim Kelly. I mean its obvious, Superbowl Rings tell all.

What's funny is that the ring argument crowd never, NEVER respond to that point. They know you have them beat with that argument and therefore ignore it.

 

[Cowboys&LakersFan]

Caught your new avatar. Sorry about the quick off-topic question, but is Nash gonna wear 11 for the Lakers (his old Santa Clara U jersey number) because he can't stay with 13, Wilt's retired jersey number? Hadn't heard.

He wore 11 in college so I'm guessing he's wearing it because as you said Wilt's number is retired.

 

[wittenacious]

He wore 11 in college so I'm guessing he's wearing it because as you said Wilt's number is retired.

With his dark, fuller looking head of hair, I figured that was an old Steve Nash pic you had photoshopped with a Lakers no. 11 jersey for your avi, even though your sig shows Nash in a #13 jersey. Must've found your avatar pic already done that way.

No matter. Always doubted he'd be allowed to wear Wilt's number 13. Nash is a great player in any jersey.

 

[VACowboy]

Is Tim Ryan a New York Giants homer, or what? To read what you wrote, he "sounds" like a first class d*bag. Is he really that bad? LOL. Personally, I'd never listened to him before Tezz posted the podcast link. First time, so an extremely limited sampling.

Loved that, btw. Made me laugh.

He's not a Giants homer. He (and Kirwan too) just think they are the biggest brains in football. They have callers who they're buddy-buddy with. They spend an inordinate amount of time talking personal crap with them and telling inside jokes. The ridiculous way they act when they get a female caller is beyond laughable. If you aren't one of their buddies and you aren't female, and you have a different viewpoint than they do, they condescend so you can't get a word in edgewise and then cut you off. If I didn't know better, I'd think they were high school boys.

 

[Clove]

For once in my life, I'm staying out of it. I'd hate for people to run off crying tonight.

 

[kelc]

If rings don't matter only stats do then your saying Pennington, Brunell,McNabb Culpepper and a bunch of other QBs are better then Staubach and Aikman,right.Come on rings do matter.

 

[Cowboys&LakersFan]

With his dark, fuller looking head of hair, I figured that was an old Steve Nash pic you had photoshopped with a Lakers no. 11 jersey for your avi, even though your sig shows Nash in a #13 jersey. Must've found your avatar pic already done that way.

No matter. Always doubted he'd be allowed to wear Wilt's number 13. Nash is a great player in any jersey.

Yeah no doubt very excited for both my teams season to start.

 

[dez_for_prez]

what was clutch? the QB throwing one up for grabs or the WR making the difficult catch?

The helmet catch was a fluke but this year to Manningham was a beautifully thrown ball, with a nice catch.

I agree with the Jekyll and Hyde comment. That's why beside the 2 Super Bowl years he has lost the first playoff game each time.

 

[dez_for_prez]

Since you know him... and this is a serious question... is Amani really the type who'd be willing to offend NY Giants fans... his fans... by saying what he said: "I'd choose Romo" ... just to generate a little controversy? I mean, he wouldn't be the 1st ex-NFLer to do that sorta thing, but... ???

Is Toomer our Tony Dorsett.

 

[burmafrd]

If rings don't matter only stats do then your saying Pennington, Brunell,McNabb Culpepper and a bunch of other QBs are better then Staubach and Aikman,right.Come on rings do matter.

so does dilffer rate higher then romo? yes or no?

Then Eli is better than Marino was.

 

[kelc]

so does dilffer rate higher then romo? yes or no?

Then Eli is better than Marino was.

Was Pennington better than Staubach,Mcnabb better than Aikman?

 

[gimmesix]

Was Pennington better than Staubach,Mcnabb better than Aikman?

Both sides of this make faulty arguments.

It's easy to see there are some quarterbacks who won Super Bowls simply because they were on superior teams and there are some quarterbacks who won Super Bowls and were superior players, sometimes being one of the main reasons for their team's success.

Hall of Famers who won Super Bowls are simply in a different category than other Super Bowl-winning quarterbacks, just like Hall of Fame quarterbacks who didn't win Super Bowls are in a different category than others who didn't.