trade the Boys#1 for Carr?

[Paniolo22]

'

Why yes I do.

That 1-15 team won the superbowl three years later. What have the Texans with their 3-4 pro bowlers and nemerous extra draft picks accomplished?

That has nothing to do with the state of the 1-15 team. THAT team was horrible. It took good coaching, more draft picks and Charles Haley to take that team to the next level. If you asked anyone which team was better, Houstons first year or the 89 cowboys, you'd be a fool to think more than a handful would take the boys. Remember, Houston beat us in their innaugural game, and that team wasn't nearly as bad as the 89ers.

 

[kartr]

Kartr,

Maybe this offseason we can pull a trade for Quincy Carter. Which team does he play for again?

Carter, with all his problems is a better qb than Carr any day. Carter has proved that by guiding the Cowboys to the playoffs with Troy Hambrick as the featured back. Carter puts up better numbers against tough defenses and Carr only against weak defenses. Case in point. Carter beat the Browns on the road outplaying both Garcia and Holcomb while the Browns dogged the Texans in their home stadium. Carter overcame 5 sacks in the first half to throw the winning td in the final minutes while Carr was overwhelmed by sacks and crumbled in an embarrassing loss in his home stadium.

 

[BigDFan5]

Carter, with all his problems is a better qb than Carr any day. Carter has proved that by guiding the Cowboys to the playoffs with Troy Hambrick as the featured back. Carter puts up better numbers against tough defenses and Carr only against weak defenses. Case in point. Carter beat the Browns on the road outplaying both Garcia and Holcomb while the Browns dogged the Texans in their home stadium. Carter overcame 5 sacks in the first half to throw the winning td in the final minutes while Carr was overwhelmed by sacks and crumbled in an embarrassing loss in his home stadium.

carter sucks get over it. He didn't lead anybody to the playoffs, our #1 D and weak schedule got us 10 wins. Without Carter it may have been 12 wins. The Cowboys won in spite of Carter not because of him.

 

[Maikeru-sama]

What's behind the 'holds the ball too long' label for most qb's is an indicator that they don't see the field well enough to tell when it's time to go to their secondary reads. This comes from the locals there that watch him all the time. I've also seen him just panic and throw the ball up for grabs even when he's not pressured. He did that twice against the Jets last year in one half and the game was close.

You have probably seen him more then me...as when they opt to show Texans games on TV in Dallas...I just go to sleep or flip the tube over to MTV.

From what I have seen, I think he still has what it takes.

 

[NovaCowboy]

That has nothing to do with the state of the 1-15 team. THAT team was horrible. It took good coaching, more draft picks and Charles Haley to take that team to the next level. If you asked anyone which team was better, Houstons first year or the 89 cowboys, you'd be a fool to think more than a handful would take the boys. Remember, Houston beat us in their innaugural game, and that team wasn't nearly as bad as the 89ers.

Well Im one of the handful that doesnt buy that.

Those teams were alot more closer talent wise then youre recognizing.

There is no way an expansion team, composed entirely of players that havent played together before (zero chemistry) in their first year can be called better than any team in any state.

Those 89 Cowboys had already started assemblying the neucleus of a dynasty. Houston hasnt assembled jack.

 

[Hostile]

Carter, with all his problems is a better qb than Carr any day. Carter has proved that by guiding the Cowboys to the playoffs with Troy Hambrick as the featured back. Carter puts up better numbers against tough defenses and Carr only against weak defenses. Case in point. Carter beat the Browns on the road outplaying both Garcia and Holcomb while the Browns dogged the Texans in their home stadium. Carter overcame 5 sacks in the first half to throw the winning td in the final minutes while Carr was overwhelmed by sacks and crumbled in an embarrassing loss in his home stadium.

Tragic how no NFL Team, Head Coach, or GM realizes this and agrees with you.


kartr's Carter is the bomb theory :shoot3:

 

[joseephuss]

Tragic how no NFL Team, Head Coach, or GM realizes this and agrees with you.


kartr's Carter is the bomb theory :shoot3:

It is a grand conspiracy. I blame the Stonecutters.(Yes, I do watch The Simpons way too much)

 

[CowboyExpress]

I don't think that's crazy at all. In fact a coach like Parcells could be exactly what a qb like Carr needs. He's being asked to be the savior down there when he has no experiance of being a savior and no help whatsoever to do it. Up here he'd only be asked to drive the bus. A guy with his driving skills I wouldn't mind driving our bus. Not to mention he's young still. I'd much rather have a sceniero like this play out rather then the ludicris one of us trading up for a Vince Young in the draft. Bring him in and make it a TRUE (no BP unfairness) QB competition for the #1 spot with Bledsoe. May the best man then win.