Creeper
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 19,868
- Reaction score
- 25,702
Someone tweeted out the clip of the Frederick tripping play. Everyone should take a close look at it. It is not tripping because Frederick's leg never makes contact with the defender. The pass rusher went down because Collins was blocking him on one side and Frederick hit him with his hands and shoulder on the other.
Refs who react to the result of a play and not the actual play should be fired. In this case the ref saw the player go to the ground and ASSUMED he was tripped. He did not see tripping because there was no tripping.
I am not saying this call changed the outcome of the game. The Cowboys could have gone 4 and out on the next series or just came up short of a TD to lose as tie expired. But this penalty call did effect the way the outcome of the game was determined. It deprived the Cowboys of a lot of possibilities to determine the outcome.
Having said that, the Cowboys did have another two plays to get the 1st down. Admittedly, 3rd and 11 is a lot harder than 3rd or 4th and 1, especially in that weather. But on 4th down, Dak threw a good pass to Cooper who got both hands on the ball. Maybe the weather effected the play, but that's a ball Cooper should catch. It was good enough for a 1st down. Cooper dropped it. Game over. Just like the ref has to make the right call in a clutch situation in the game, the #1 receiver on the team has to make that catch at that point in the game.
Refs who react to the result of a play and not the actual play should be fired. In this case the ref saw the player go to the ground and ASSUMED he was tripped. He did not see tripping because there was no tripping.
I am not saying this call changed the outcome of the game. The Cowboys could have gone 4 and out on the next series or just came up short of a TD to lose as tie expired. But this penalty call did effect the way the outcome of the game was determined. It deprived the Cowboys of a lot of possibilities to determine the outcome.
Having said that, the Cowboys did have another two plays to get the 1st down. Admittedly, 3rd and 11 is a lot harder than 3rd or 4th and 1, especially in that weather. But on 4th down, Dak threw a good pass to Cooper who got both hands on the ball. Maybe the weather effected the play, but that's a ball Cooper should catch. It was good enough for a 1st down. Cooper dropped it. Game over. Just like the ref has to make the right call in a clutch situation in the game, the #1 receiver on the team has to make that catch at that point in the game.
