Washington vs Mayer vs Kincaid

[ghst187]

Washington is just tantalizing from a size and potential standpoint. The problem is I could see him being a complete bust too. IMO he could be the next Randy Moss of TEs or Rico Gathers.
Mayer on the other hand looks like a can’t miss stud for the next 10 years who does everything well.
Kincaid looks like more the receiver and potential Kelce.
If I have to pick one at 26…I honestly have to go with Mayer, esp given Kincaids back injury and our emotional scarring from the Lafluer debacle.

 

[Malhavoc]

I just would want a 21 year old at Mayer’s level then a finished product like Kincaid at 24.

Was Kelce a finished product at 24 ?

 

[Malhavoc]

Washington is just tantalizing from a size and potential standpoint. The problem is I could see him being a complete bust too. IMO he could be the next Randy Moss of TEs or Rico Gathers.
Mayer on the other hand looks like a can’t miss stud for the next 10 years who does everything well.
Kincaid looks like more the receiver and potential Kelce.
If I have to pick one at 26…I honestly have to go with Mayer, esp given Kincaids back injury and our emotional scarring from the Lafluer debacle.

The Randy Moss comp is not a good one. Moss was a freak athlete with tape and production. Moss was a top 10 talent that dropped because of character concerns.

 

[baltcowboy]

Was Kelce a finished product at 24 ?

Well give me Mahomes. Kielce didn’t become a Hall of Famer until the quarterback change. Kincaid compared to Kelce

 

[ghst187]

The Randy Moss comp is not a good one. Moss was a freak athlete with tape and production. Moss was a top 10 talent that dropped because of character concerns.

Not a draft comparison, an ability comparison to dominate

 

[Malhavoc]

Well give me Mahomes. Kielce didn’t become a Hall of Famer until the quarterback change. Kincaid compared to Kelce

So Kelce didn’t get better ? it was all Mahomes ? And nobody said that Kincaid should be compared to Kelce. The fact that you think Kincaid is a finished product is the real joke.

 

[baltcowboy]

So Kelce didn’t get better ? it was all Mahomes ? And nobody said that Kincaid should be compared to Kelce. The fact that you think Kincaid is a finished product is the real joke.

You brought Kelce into the discussion not me. We will see supposedly Kincaid is rated high. We will see.

 

[Malhavoc]

You brought Kelce into the discussion not me. We will see supposedly Kincaid is rated high. We will see.

I brought Kelce into the discussion because you said Kincaid at 24 was a finished product. Kelce was the same age when he was drafted and is now a completely different player. My point was it is insane to think that Kincaid at 24 is done developing as a player.

 

[DanA]

Well give me Mahomes. Kielce didn’t become a Hall of Famer until the quarterback change. Kincaid compared to Kelce

Kelce had back to back 1,000 yard seasons before Mahomes became a starter.

 

[baltcowboy]

I brought Kelce into the discussion because you said Kincaid at 24 was a finished product. Kelce was the same age when he was drafted and is now a completely different player. My point was it is insane to think that Kincaid at 24 is done developing as a player.

Well hopefully you will cheer Kincaid on and admit you were wrong in a few years.

 

[baltcowboy]

Kelce had back to back 1,000 yard seasons before Mahomes became a starter.

Didn’t become a hall of fame level player until Mahomes came along. Todd Christianson was a regular 100 catch 1,000 yard receiver and Super Bowl champ with the Raiders. No hall of fame.

 

[DanA]

Didn’t become a hall of fame level player until Mahomes came along. Todd Christianson was a regular 100 catch 1,000 yard receiver and Super Bowl champ with the Raiders. No hall of fame.

Todd Christianson had 625 yards in his first 4 seasons. Kelce had 2,862 yards.

 

[baltcowboy]

Todd Christianson had 625 yards in his first 4 seasons. Kelce had 2,862 yards.

Christianson never had Mahomes as a quarterback in a passing era.

 

[Nemesis4u]

watch this link and tell me you want any of these te's over washington.. If we miss on him then we take laporta later on we dont need to waste a first round pick on a shultz clone with slightly better blocking.

 

[Malhavoc]

Well hopefully you will cheer Kincaid on and admit you were wrong in a few years.

I don’t need to wait. I already know you’re wrong. The notion that a 24 year old player just drafted has reached his peak is silly and ridiculous.

 

[manster4ever]

Kincaid IMO is a top 20 player. Mayer ain’t far behind. Washington is a round 2 player. Love Kincaid. Really like Mayer. Washington has intriguing size and athleticis.

I mean....IMO if Jason Witten was taken in the 3rd there's no way Washington should go any higher. (kinda kidding, I know that's not the way it works) But Mayer, Kincaid, the Iowa kid and the Oregon kid are all potentially rated higher than Washington. Too many on this board in love with his size. I'm not buying it.

 

[Croomraider]

My TE order:

1) Washington is by far and away my favorite guy!! Hope it happens!!
2) Kincaid (wears 86 and looks like schultz 2.0 lol)
3) Mayer (if this dude keeps getting bigger and bigger does he move to OLine lol??)

 

[MAZEREZAM]

Kincaid is 24 years old. Your not concerned about his age. I wish he tested because I just didn’t see anything in his play that made me say 4.5 speed tight end or Kelse.

Or his back for that matter? The injury that kept him from participating on his pro day 4 months after sustaining it.

 

[MAZEREZAM]

watch this link and tell me you want any of these te's over washington.. If we miss on him then we take laporta later on we dont need to waste a first round pick on a shultz clone with slightly better blocking.

I would not have the worst blocking TE as the backup for not taking Washington, IMO.

 

[exciter]

Washington is such a great redzone player that he averaged 1 TD per season in college...

​	REC​	YDS​	TD​
Mayer​	180​	2099​	18​
Washington​	45​	774​	3​

Laporta?