What happened? A deeper look at the two plays that ended the Baltimore game

cbartel81

New Member
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
What HAPPENED!? A deeper look at the two plays that ended the Baltimore game
It has always been said that the difference between winning and losing in the NFL always comes down to the team that makes the big plays. You never know when they are going to happen and which one will be the big play. That is why you have to play all of them 100% and to the best of your ability all the time. The most important play in football has and always will be... the next one. The two touchdown runs in the 4th quarter sealed the game in the Ravens favor. Many of us were wondering what happened and who was to blame. I will (as any coach does) go through the tape with you to disect what happened to our defense on these two critical plays. Here we go:

The McGahee Run

The formation is Baltimore's Tackle-over left (unbalanced) set. In ordinary fashion Dallas sets the strength to the overloaded side (their right). Spears is lined up in a weak 1 shade on the right eye of the Center. Ratliff is in a strong 3 (outside eye of the left Guard). Canty in a 9 outside of the over Tackle. Ware in a loose 9 outside of the 3rd Tackle (the TE Heap is on the offensive right with the Guard). Spencer is in a 5 outside Heap. By alignment Thomas (55) is responsible for the weak-side B gap. This is the gap between the Right Guard and TE. James has the strong-side C gap between the 2nd and third tackle. Hamlin should be the extra fitter on James' side and Davis the extra fitter on Thomas' side. The formation looks like this:
............................TB
.
............................QB.................... ........................Z
X.................. /Y..G..C..G./T..T/.T/
C..................L../../.E_/..N.../.E...R.............................C
....................../..W...........S
...................../..................\
...................SS...................._FS

When the ball is snapped, Dallas runs an "Eddie" line slant to the strength. This tells the End (Spears) he is responsible for the strong-side A gap (between the C and Guard on the right side). Now gap assignments move over 1. This tells Thomas he must now take the weak-side A gap and Davis has to fit into the weak-side B gap. Then we see the problem. As Thomas sees the double-team on Spears he must attack the Guard that gets up to his level with his left shoulder and spill the ball to the unblocked defender Davis. But he doesn't. He engages the Guard with his right shoulder, tries to look behind him, and re-direct too late. As Davis comes to fill his gap he finds Thomas in his way, whom while turning essentially blocks him. Hamlin takes a bad angle and misses and McGahee is off to the races. Spencer is also bad on this play. When he gets this base block by Heap, he needs to bench-press him off of him, fold over, and come flat down the line of scrimmage to make a play on the ball-carrier. He could have easily made this play, but he spends too much time mucking with Heap and not getting down the heel-line. As for Thomas, when he takes in the Guard with the wrong shoulder and not keeping his inside shoulder free, he creates a north-south seam through the heart of the defense. At this point the only thing that will stop McGahee is the goalpost if he hits his head on it. First Thomas, then Spencer, then Hamlin. DO YOUR JOB! PLAY YOUR GAP!

The McClain Run

This is one of the most common running plays in the game. 24 Power-O. Every lineman blocks down, pull the backside Guard to kick the End, and lead with the Fullback. This one is 90% on Spencer and 10% on James. Spencer is reading the outside knee of Heap. As soon as he blocks down, Spencer has to close on the pulling Guard, take his helmet and put it in the knee-cap of the pulling Guard. this will cause a road block and force the ball to bounce outside. James should be there to make this tackle. You can see that James is expecting this to happen and it doesn't because Spencer tries to run around the block to make the tackle. You never ever do this and the end result is why. It allows the hole to expand and allow the Fullback to lead up on the backer and he does. James gets too high on the block, doesn't stay square, and is blasted to the ground. Davis is bad here because he has to come in from outside-in and attck with his inside shoulder. Hamlin has to get lower and take the runners legs out from him. His effort here is pathetic. Above all though, Spencer is aweful. He has to sacrifice his body here to allow James to make this play.Again, DO YOUR JOB! PLAY YOUR GAP! Also, Bradie James you have to decide if you are the hammer or the nail. The nail always loses.

In conclusion these are only two plays in many, but two costly plays nonetheless. I can only think that had the offense been more productive and kept the ball longer over the course of the game, the defense would have been better late. There are only so many bullets an NFL offense can fire at a defense before they hit you on one of them. The less they have the ball the fewer opportunities they have to do so. Outside of these two plays the defense played well. They are directly responsible but they cannot face anybody in this league for that many plays and not expect to give up one or two big plays when they are provided no rest and relief from Romo and company. These are fixable problems but they are running out of time to do so. God-willing they will use this week in practice to cure these problems and get to the playoffs via a Philadelphia win. But, they can do this if the injury bug keeps them from practicing this week. Get out and practice. They will have the whole offseason to heal up if they don't. I hope this clears things up a bit.
 

FLCowboyFan

Hoping to be half the man Tom Landry was.
Messages
4,967
Reaction score
3,555
Thank you for some awesome analysis.

It could be that the D was tired at the end of the game and that is why they made mistakes or that the pressure got to them.

Either way the analysis of what actually happened shows that it was not all of Davis. He was just the last line of defense so he is the most obvious
 

theebs

Believe!!!!
Messages
27,462
Reaction score
9,207
I put that last one on spencer too, I know the safeties missed him but spencer should have stopped that play dead at the line of scrimmage.
 

iceberg

rock music matters
Messages
34,405
Reaction score
7,932
cbartel81;2518291 said:
What HAPPENED!? A deeper look at the two plays that ended the Baltimore game
It has always been said that the difference between winning and losing in the NFL always comes down to the team that makes the big plays. You never know when they are going to happen and which one will be the big play. That is why you have to play all of them 100% and to the best of your ability all the time. The most important play in football has and always will be... the next one. The two touchdown runs in the 4th quarter sealed the game in the Ravens favor. Many of us were wondering what happened and who was to blame. I will (as any coach does) go through the tape with you to disect what happened to our defense on these two critical plays. Here we go:

The McGahee Run

The formation is Baltimore's Tackle-over left (unbalanced) set. In ordinary fashion Dallas sets the strength to the overloaded side (their right). Spears is lined up in a weak 1 shade on the right eye of the Center. Ratliff is in a strong 3 (outside eye of the left Guard). Canty in a 9 outside of the over Tackle. Ware in a loose 9 outside of the 3rd Tackle (the TE Heap is on the offensive right with the Guard). Spencer is in a 5 outside Heap. By alignment Thomas (55) is responsible for the weak-side B gap. This is the gap between the Right Guard and TE. James has the strong-side C gap between the 2nd and third tackle. Hamlin should be the extra fitter on James' side and Davis the extra fitter on Thomas' side. The formation looks like this:
............................TB
.
............................QB.................... ........................Z
X.................. /Y..G..C..G./T..T/.T/
C..................L../../.E_/..N.../.E...R.............................C
....................../..W...........S
...................../..................\
...................SS...................._FS

When the ball is snapped, Dallas runs an "Eddie" line slant to the strength. This tells the End (Spears) he is responsible for the strong-side A gap (between the C and Guard on the right side). Now gap assignments move over 1. This tells Thomas he must now take the weak-side A gap and Davis has to fit into the weak-side B gap. Then we see the problem. As Thomas sees the double-team on Spears he must attack the Guard that gets up to his level with his left shoulder and spill the ball to the unblocked defender Davis. But he doesn't. He engages the Guard with his right shoulder, tries to look behind him, and re-direct too late. As Davis comes to fill his gap he finds Thomas in his way, whom while turning essentially blocks him. Hamlin takes a bad angle and misses and McGahee is off to the races. Spencer is also bad on this play. When he gets this base block by Heap, he needs to bench-press him off of him, fold over, and come flat down the line of scrimmage to make a play on the ball-carrier. He could have easily made this play, but he spends too much time mucking with Heap and not getting down the heel-line. As for Thomas, when he takes in the Guard with the wrong shoulder and not keeping his inside shoulder free, he creates a north-south seam through the heart of the defense. At this point the only thing that will stop McGahee is the goalpost if he hits his head on it. First Thomas, then Spencer, then Hamlin. DO YOUR JOB! PLAY YOUR GAP!

The McClain Run

This is one of the most common running plays in the game. 24 Power-O. Every lineman blocks down, pull the backside Guard to kick the End, and lead with the Fullback. This one is 90% on Spencer and 10% on James. Spencer is reading the outside knee of Heap. As soon as he blocks down, Spencer has to close on the pulling Guard, take his helmet and put it in the knee-cap of the pulling Guard. this will cause a road block and force the ball to bounce outside. James should be there to make this tackle. You can see that James is expecting this to happen and it doesn't because Spencer tries to run around the block to make the tackle. You never ever do this and the end result is why. It allows the hole to expand and allow the Fullback to lead up on the backer and he does. James gets too high on the block, doesn't stay square, and is blasted to the ground. Davis is bad here because he has to come in from outside-in and attck with his inside shoulder. Hamlin has to get lower and take the runners legs out from him. His effort here is pathetic. Above all though, Spencer is aweful. He has to sacrifice his body here to allow James to make this play.Again, DO YOUR JOB! PLAY YOUR GAP! Also, Bradie James you have to decide if you are the hammer or the nail. The nail always loses.

In conclusion these are only two plays in many, but two costly plays nonetheless. I can only think that had the offense been more productive and kept the ball longer over the course of the game, the defense would have been better late. There are only so many bullets an NFL offense can fire at a defense before they hit you on one of them. The less they have the ball the fewer opportunities they have to do so. Outside of these two plays the defense played well. They are directly responsible but they cannot face anybody in this league for that many plays and not expect to give up one or two big plays when they are provided no rest and relief from Romo and company. These are fixable problems but they are running out of time to do so. God-willing they will use this week in practice to cure these problems and get to the playoffs via a Philadelphia win. But, they can do this if the injury bug keeps them from practicing this week. Get out and practice. They will have the whole offseason to heal up if they don't. I hope this clears things up a bit.

wow. you've already said in 5 posts what most can't do in a lifetime of posting. appreciate the analysis w/o the drama.
 

BigDave95

Active Member
Messages
667
Reaction score
135
iceberg;2518351 said:
wow. you've already said in 5 posts what most can't do in a lifetime of posting. appreciate the analysis w/o the drama.

No joke. Best 5th post EVER!!
 

igtmfo

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,322
Reaction score
127
Great stuff Cbartel.

It seems from your analysis that guys would need to score 30 on the Wunderlic just to understand gap responsibility. Amazing.

Question: With all your insight, what might be responsible for these miscues? ... lack of coaching detail, lack of reps, outright failure to make players aware of these things, or what? Is stuff pretty elementary?

Question 2: Are you a coach yourself?
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
good stuff man.

I didn't notice the Zach Thomas issue live but I did notice Spencer because they actually brought it up previously about us jumping blocks....

We really need to play Ellis more in those short yardage type situations where we are just stopping the run. Ellis plays excellent gap control football.

Ken Hamlin must learn to tackle. You can't be the last line of defense and a) whiff like he did on McGahee or b) get stiff-armed like he did against McClain.
 

TwentyOne

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,673
Reaction score
5,317
cbartel81;2518291 said:
I can only think that had the offense been more productive and kept the ball longer over the course of the game, the defense would have been better late. There are only so many bullets an NFL offense can fire at a defense before they hit you on one of them. The less they have the ball the fewer opportunities they have to do so. Outside of these two plays the defense played well. They are directly responsible but they cannot face anybody in this league for that many plays and not expect to give up one or two big plays when they are provided no rest and relief from Romo and company.

Right on the money.

And thanks for the explanation. I appreciate it.
 

ndanger

Active Member
Messages
2,298
Reaction score
13
Wow ! No drama, no agenda, and post of the year in my opinion. Excellent post. Please feel free to spend as much of your valuable time posting here as you like. It will not go unappreciated by me or most on this forum. Thanks for your time and effort. :bow:
 

xWraithx

Benched
Messages
3,449
Reaction score
1
cbartel81;2518291 said:
icon4.gif

Wade, is that you??
 

AdamJT13

Salary Cap Analyst
Messages
16,583
Reaction score
4,529
cbartel81;2518291 said:
This one is 90% on Spencer and 10% on James.

So no responsibility at all for anyone else who missed a tackle on that play?
 

wileedog

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,356
Reaction score
2,393
AdamJT13;2518454 said:
So no responsibility at all for anyone else who missed a tackle on that play?

Exactly.

Yes, those players up front get the blame for missing their assignments, but Hamlin's entire job in run defense is to clean it up when that happens. He failed miserably, twice in a row.

Still trying to figure out what Newman was trying to do on that 2nd one too.

Also, I don't necessarily agree with those trying to pin this on the offense. A bonehead play is a bonehead play, and Spencer in particular made two of them. Not sure what being on the field a lot has to do with completely ignoring your responsibilities and free-lancing around a blocker.

Nice analysis of the plays though.
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
wileedog;2518482 said:
Exactly.

Yes, those players up front get the blame for missing their assignments, but Hamlin's entire job in run defense is to clean it up when that happens. He failed miserably, twice in a row.

Still trying to figure out what Newman was trying to do on that 2nd one too.

Also, I don't necessarily agree with those trying to pin this on the offense. A bonehead play is a bonehead play, and Spencer in particular made two of them. Not sure what being on the field a lot has to do with completely ignoring your responsibilities and free-lancing around a blocker.

I agree with both side of this issue. Offense and defense were to blame for this loss. not one or the other.
 

InDakWeTrust

DezBRomo9
Messages
2,091
Reaction score
432
Geez, CBartel81, your like our future D-Coordinator! I agree totally with the evaluation on Spencer, he just jumped the pulling guard, instead of taking him head on, which would have eliminated the running lane for McGahee, then on the second play, he does the same exact thing. Thomas, was trying to cover backside pursuit in the run, although with McGahee, it would have taken him a Drew Bledsoe minute to cut back.

Our DLine isn't bad, but I would like to see us invest in a true 1 gap DE opposite Canty. We need a guy that can shoot a gap or handle a double team and not be put on his butt. A guy like Castillo or Pittsburgh's Smith or Keisel would make this defense improve. Bowen and Hatcher are okay, but I still want a bluecollar player who can play and just stuff the run.

During both plays, I believe that KD showed that he shouldn't be playing much more than special teams either. He over pursued, and got tangled up with ZT, essentially killing both of their chances on the WM run.

I still put almost all of the blame on this play on two players, Spencer and Hamlin, both made similar mistakes on each run, and they scored on each. Hamlin didn't tackle and Spencer gave up his gap, had either one done their job on either play, it would have been 2nd and 7 on each one instead of 6 points, IMO.

Very good couple of posts man!!!
 

CaptainAmerica

Active Member
Messages
5,030
Reaction score
26
Sure Hamlin has blame, but at that point we had to have a 3 and out.

I may be wrong but even if Hamlin makes the tackle, I think they had a first down and could have almost run out the clock.

It would be interesting to know exactly how many yards the runner gained before Hamlin missed the tackle.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
CaptainAmerica;2518508 said:
Sure Hamlin has blame, but at that point we had to have a 3 and out.

I may be wrong but even if Hamlin makes the tackle, I think they had a first down and could have almost run out the clock.

It would be interesting to know exactly how many yards the runner gained before Hamlin missed the tackle.

Hamlin was up at the line of scrimmage quickly.

He just took a bad angle to get there. Hamlin HAS to make those tackles tho.
The safety can NOT ever miss those as that is it.

We needed a 3 and out for sure but a first down on the first play of the drive would not have killed us. We had 3 timeouts then.

On the second attempt we really needed to play a more goal-line oriented defense imho but we certainly didnt need missed tackles or running away from blocks giving up the gaps.
 
Top