What would Herbert bring SD back in a trade

[Q_the_man]

He's so overrated. Just because you can make all the throws does not make you a great QB.

I would trade him. Im thinking 2 1st to someone like Arizona

 

[csirl]

Not sure Arizona will bring in another QB until they've seen what they have in Carson Beck (injured preseason?).

 

[darthseinfeld]

He's so overrated. Just because you can make all the throws does not make you a great QB.

I would trade him. Im thinking 2 1st to someone like Arizona

Good question. I think 70% of what Stafford went for. Which would be about two 1sts. Stafford went for two 1st, a 3rd and Goff. Goffs value was pretty low at the time. He was an inefficient QB on an expensive contract. But I think still he carried a top 50 value

 

[CowboysFanLover]

A 3rd round pick, that is it, sure Hebert is good but he cannot win when it counts

 

[LouBrown]

Good question. I think 70% of what Stafford went for. Which would be about two 1sts. Stafford went for two 1st, a 3rd and Goff. Goffs value was pretty low at the time. He was an inefficient QB on an expensive contract. But I think still he carried a top 50 value

I think this is probably about right.

It's hard to gauge QB market because there are so few teams who would meet the "QB away from contending" standard. I kind of doubt Herbert would want to sign an extension somewhere like Miami in the middle of a rebuild.

 

[ghst187]

Man right now like a bag of chips. I mean NY or Wash might bid on him but his stock is falling off a cliff. Same HC, no idea what’s going on but he’s about to play himself into a journeyman backup role after this season.

 

[TheCoolFan]

Not much. He's just a guy destined to be a journeyman QB at this point. He will stick around the league as a Rent-A-Starter like Geno Smith. He's not even close to Stafford's level in Detroit

 

[darthseinfeld]

Not much. He's just a guy destined to be a journeyman QB at this point. He will stick around the league as a Rent-A-Starter like Geno Smith. He's not even close to Stafford's level in Detroit

Im going back on my post. I think he is Andy Dalton. I think maybe a team give up a day 2 pick

 

[Kwyn]

At least three firsts. For likely four.

 

[RodeoJake]

A 7th or priority undrafted free agent

 

[erod]

It would take a boatload.

He needs a true QB guru for head coach. Kellen Moore. Kevin O'Connell. Ben Johnson.

Chicago would trade Caleb Williams straight up for Herbert in a heartbeat.

 

[atlantacowboy]

He's so overrated. Just because you can make all the throws does not make you a great QB.

I would trade him. Im thinking 2 1st to someone like Arizona

People said same of Stafford in Detroit and of the guy he took over for......Phillip Rivers. The Chargers are one of those cursed franchises. I hope they do trade. I'd love to see what he could do with a career reset.

 

[StarOfGlory]

Washington would take a look. JD5 is quickly going down the RG3 road.