What's with this feigned ignorance about the PI call?

[ElGatoGrande]

The hold on the shoulder that takes the receiver off stride and prevents him from jumping for the ball was well executed, but it is still there for all to see. They played a great angle on it last night (the one you're not seeing on all the talk shows) and yet Collinsworth acted like it was insignificant. I know the media loves to generate conflict and controversy but c'mon now,,,

 

[tyke1doe]

I hate the way pass interference is called now. It's very difficult for defenders to adequately defend receivers these days.

 

[EST_1986]

That call was pretty tricky tack, overall it was bad and this board would have been in full meltdown if that was Carr on ODB

 

[tyke1doe]

The hold on the shoulder that takes the receiver off stride and prevents him from jumping for the ball was well executed, but it is still there for all to see. They played a great angle on it last night (the one you're not seeing on all the talk shows) and yet Collinsworth acted like it was insignificant. I know the media loves to generate conflict and controversy but c'mon now,,,

I don't think it should have been pass interference either. It was a ticky tack call to me. But we'll take it.

 

[tyke1doe]

That call was pretty tricky tack, overall it was bad and this board would have been in full meltdown if that was Carr on ODB

WINNER, WINNER CHICKEN DINNER!!!!

 

[NoLuv4Jerry]

When I first saw the play...I contended that Williams should have caught the ball anyway. I felt like he should have ran through and high pointed the ball. But when I saw the reverse camera angle...DRC deliberately impeded Williams ability to run through the route and high point the ball. So it ABSOLUTLEY was the right call.

 

[blindzebra]

Well they got away with a blatant PI on the first drive on Dez and not a word from Turkey Neck.

 

[TellerMorrow34]

I actually thought we caught a very lucky break there. I don't think that should have been called.

 

[anava]

Thought the refs missed the one earlier in the game when Dez was grabbed in the endzone. You get some right in the game and you get some wrong. Usually balances out.

 

[JD_KaPow]

The hold on the shoulder that takes the receiver off stride and prevents him from jumping for the ball was well executed, but it is still there for all to see. They played a great angle on it last night (the one you're not seeing on all the talk shows) and yet Collinsworth acted like it was insignificant. I know the media loves to generate conflict and controversy but c'mon now,,,

When I first saw the play...I contended that Williams should have caught the ball anyway. I felt like he should have ran through and high pointed the ball. But when I saw the reverse camera angle...DRC deliberately impeded Williams ability to run through the route and high point the ball. So it ABSOLUTLEY was the right call.

I've watched the play many times and see none of what you're talking about. There was no hold, no impeding. It was a terrible call, and I love it.

 

[Direwolf63]

Ticky tack is a good way to put it. As another said, if that was a Cowboys DB on a Giants receiver we would all be howling at the refs.

 

[DenCWBY]

If you watch Cromartie's left hand too, he hooks it under Williams arm as Williams is making his cut to stay with him. If anything it could have been a holding call. I hate PI because it's such an inconsistent call.

 

[TellerMorrow34]

Well they got away with a blatant PI on the first drive on Dez and not a word from Turkey Neck.

And this one I do think was absolutely PI and was blown and missed.

So they canceled one another out.

 

[NoLuv4Jerry]

I've watched the play many times and see none of what you're talking about. There was no hold, no impeding. It was a terrible call, and I love it.

A runner needs to move his arms to actually run....he was held on the top of his shoulder...which prevented him from running through the route...which is WHY....Williams did not get to the spot he needed to be at

 

[Seven]

I've watched the play many times and see none of what you're talking about. There was no hold, no impeding. It was a terrible call, and I love it.

Well said, my man.

 

[EST_1986]

I've watched the play many times and see none of what you're talking about. There was no hold, no impeding. It was a terrible call, and I love it.

TWill just wasn't in position to catch it with his body and thats the only reason he didn't catch it, the DB played it perfectly

 

[JD_KaPow]

A runner needs to move his arms to actually run....he was held on the top of his shoulder...which prevented him from running through the route...which is WHY....Williams did not get to the spot he needed to be at

Except for the part that he wasn't held.

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

The hold on the shoulder that takes the receiver off stride and prevents him from jumping for the ball was well executed, but it is still there for all to see. They played a great angle on it last night (the one you're not seeing on all the talk shows) and yet Collinsworth acted like it was insignificant. I know the media loves to generate conflict and controversy but c'mon now,,,

Forget about all that.

NO CONTACT after five yards.

 

[StarBoyz83]

That call was really ticky tacky. You're allowed to grab the shoulder or put your hand on their waist as long as you don't turn them. He didnt turn him at all. Dallas got 4 free points there for sure.

 

[speedkilz88]

Some of you guys are blind as bats. Like the OP said the grab prevented Terrance from making his leap for the ball. I could cover a WR if I was allowed to do that.