Where Romo Ranks all-time as Captain Comeback (and complete success story)

T-RO · Jun 30, 2023

Runwildboys said:
Because 7 years later, his replacement hasn't done anything noteworthy.

C'mon now. AC has issues, but don't descend with him to petty juvenile rivalry. It's not Romo vs. Dak.

fredp22 · Jun 30, 2023

he never won when it mattered.
His 3 straight years of needing a win in final game to make playoffs and flopping all 3 times sealed his reputation. The rest of your stats/numbers/charts mean nothing

Runwildboys · Jun 30, 2023

T-RO said:
C'mon now. AC has issues, but don't descend with him to petty juvenile rivalry. It's not Romo vs. Dak.

It's not Dak vs. Romo for me, actually. I'm rooting for Dak. I just like to point out that unnecessarily ripping on Tony for not achieving the same things Dak hasn't achieved is silly and self defeating.

big dog cowboy · Jun 30, 2023

T-RO said:
As we all know Romo never achieved success as a field goal holder.

And Zeke was a terrible center.

:laugh:

Captain-Crash · Jun 30, 2023

T-RO said:
If you wilt under a playful jab...this might be a difficult thread for you. Factual haymakers, left and right, are coming.

*lip quivering,*, "but romo went Hollywood and dated babes and I never got to see him with his shirt off."

foofighters · Jun 30, 2023

America's Cowboy said:
Another Romo supporting thread throwing jabs at anyone who disagrees or brings up his moments of falling short or wilting under pressure.

LOL!! I find it awesome that you were the first to reply. I remember a post a few days ago about him and that ultra lame pickle-ball "sport."

foofighters · Jun 30, 2023

T-RO said:
Oh, but it gets better. Isn't it a better to take the top guys and then look at what they did per season or per game? Of course it is. Some guys simply have shorter careers. This absolutely is why data analysts often prefer ratios to simple totals.

I get the point of this thread but it's hard to completely take seriously when Derek Carr is leading the pack. I feel like there's more to the story. As in the case with the Cowboys, did they put themselves into that position? How many slow starts has this team historically had. and no, this isn't a Romo thing because they've been slow starters with Dak too.

Captain-Crash · Jun 30, 2023

Romo, still hurting feelings. You got to love it.

SlammedZero · Jun 30, 2023

T-RO said:
Cowboys head coaches after Romo's first year as starter:
Wade Phillips
Jason Garrett

This has always been my to-go-to for defending Romo. That's quite the handicap.

Cowboys5217 · Jun 30, 2023

T-RO said:
If you wilt under a playful jab...this might be a difficult thread for you. Factual haymakers, left and right, are coming.

Just don't forget about the facts of Romo's playoff record.

erod · Jun 30, 2023

This greatest sin of this franchise was the failure to support Romo early with meaningful acquisitions to help a talented but inexperienced and undersized QB from a small school.

He didn't need Mo Claiborne, Felix Jones, Mike Jenkins, etc. He needed Tyron, Martin, and Frederick much earlier so he didn't have to take a beating and run for his life.

Once he refined his game, he was truly elite, but by then, he was beaten to a pulp.

He was the second best QB in Cowboys history to Staubach, and if he had Troy's teams, I believe he wins a 4th Super Bowl with that 90s team.

Momanpr100 · Jun 30, 2023

The guy with Jimmy Johnson as his profile picture can't let go of the past, what a shocker. Romo had his chances, didn't deliver. Couldn't deliver 3 years in a row with a win and in game. Yall prop up Romo like he's a Hall of Famer and only 2nd team All Pro once. I get it, Romo was a good Qb, the same as Dak. They are equals. Don't need to prop one up and don't need to tear one down.

TheMarathonContinues · Jun 30, 2023

Runwildboys said:
Because 7 years later, his replacement hasn't done anything noteworthy.

What the hell did Romo do for you guys to still want him lol? Nothing Dak hasn't done if you want someone who never won more than 2 playoff games and made a career compiling regular stats why not just ask for Kirk Cousins?

TheMarathonContinues · Jun 30, 2023

Runwildboys said:
It's not Dak vs. Romo for me, actually. I'm rooting for Dak. I just like to point out that unnecessarily ripping on Tony for not achieving the same things Dak hasn't achieved is silly and self defeating.

The difference though is Dak is 29....Romo was 36 when he retired and he'd done nothing. A huge difference.

TheMarathonContinues · Jun 30, 2023

SlammedZero said:
This has always been my to-go-to for defending Romo. That's quite the handicap.

He also had Bill Parcells early in his career...and Sean Payton inhouse.

TheMarathonContinues · Jun 30, 2023

foofighters said:
I get the point of this thread but it's hard to completely take seriously when Derek Carr is leading the pack. I feel like there's more to the story. As in the case with the Cowboys, did they put themselves into that position? How many slow starts has this team historically had. and no, this isn't a Romo thing because they've been slow starters with Dak too.

First thing I noticed was Derek Carr then I just voided that whole post. Hell naw lol...

TheMarathonContinues · Jun 30, 2023

Romo threw 5 interceptions against the Bills and ended up coming back to win and that deserves praise? To an extent it does but I mean he threw 5 interceptions...how many of these comebacks were the result of Romo not being able to move the offense and being the reason we were down to begin with?

TheMarathonContinues · Jun 30, 2023

erod said:
This greatest sin of this franchise was the failure to support Romo early with meaningful acquisitions to help a talented but inexperienced and undersized QB from a small school.

He didn't need Mo Claiborne, Felix Jones, Mike Jenkins, etc. He needed Tyron, Martin, and Frederick much earlier so he didn't have to take a beating and run for his life.

Once he refined his game, he was truly elite, but by then, he was beaten to a pulp.

He was the second best QB in Cowboys history to Staubach, and if he had Troy's teams, I believe he wins a 4th Super Bowl with that 90s team.

IN 2015, Romo was injured but when he was healthy he posted:

A passer rating of 79.4 5 Touchdowns and 7 interceptions in just 4 games.....I don't know what in the hell made y'all think he was getting better but 2014 was not the last time we saw him.

SteveTheCowboy · Jun 30, 2023

big dog cowboy said:
And Zeke was a terrible center.

No...Zeke is a TERRIBLE offensive line.

SteveTheCowboy · Jun 30, 2023

TheMarathonContinues said:
Romo threw 5 interceptions against the Bills and ended up coming back to win and that deserves praise? To an extent it does but I mean he threw 5 interceptions...how many of these comebacks were the result of Romo not being able to move the offense and being the reason we were down to begin with?

Were those ints tipped? Dropped? was the WR a dope?

I mean we should use the same criteria we use for Dak, right?

Where Romo Ranks all-time as Captain Comeback (and complete success story)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Confused about stuff

THE BIG DOG

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member