Which NFC East quarterback would you rather start on your team?

[cml750]

Eli first - Henson second. While I will root for Bledsoe(as I do for everyone wearing a star although I have to admit that will be hard with TO), I have little faith that he can get it done. This is a young team that needs a young QB to grow with them. Just say no to the geriatric QB brigade.

 

[Da Hammer]

i'd take McNabb since we need a QB with good mobility right now cause of the O-Line. We dont know how they'll perform

 

[BlueWave]

Eli first - Henson second. While I will root for Bledsoe(as I do for everyone wearing a star although I have to admit that will be hard with TO), I have little faith that he can get it done. This is a young team that needs a young QB to grow with them. Just say no to the geriatric QB brigade.

This goes back to the selection that I was expecting Parcells to make in 2003, Chris Simms. We passed on him and now he is the starting QB for the Buccaneers and improving and getting better every time out. Had we made that selection, I think we would be in better shape for the future.

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

This shouldn't even be a debate, if Dallas had McNabb you might as well hand the Superbowl to the Cowboys...enough said.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Eli

he's a more mobile Drew Bledsoe and would be a perfect fit for our O

 

[cml750]

This goes back to the selection that I was expecting Parcells to make in 2003, Chris Simms. We passed on him and now he is the starting QB for the Buccaneers and improving and getting better every time out. Had we made that selection, I think we would be in better shape for the future.

We literally wasted the last two years on old QB's. We should have been letting a young guy get some experience whether it be Simms, Henson, Romo, or whoever...., we would be a lot better off for it!!

 

[Bob Sacamano]

We literally wasted the last two years on old QB's. We should have been letting a young guy get some experience whether it be Simms, Henson, Romo, or whoever...., we would be a lot better off for it!!

hindsight is 20/20, and for all those clamoring for missing out on Simms, remember how he looked before last year? he looked like he was on his way out, now imagine if he was a Cowboy, y'all would have been clamoring for his release too

btw, I dont' call developing Romo and Henson behind Vinny and Drew a waste of time

 

[cml750]

hindsight is 20/20, and for all those clamoring for missing out on Simms, remember how he looked before last year? he looked like he was on his way out, now imagine if he was a Cowboy, y'all would have been clamoring for his release too

btw, I dont' call developing Romo and Henson behind Vinny and Drew a waste of time

Having Henson and Romo holding clipboards was a waste of time. One of them should have been on the field. Would we have lost more games? Yes, but it would probably start paying off this year when we will have a good young team. Like I said I have little faith in Bledsoe(although I will be rooting for him). Watching a veteran like Bledsoe make mistakes makes me a lot angrier than watching a young growing QB make mistakes. Oh well, Bledsoe is the guy. GO BLEDSOE!!!!

BTW- How did Chris Simms get better? BY PLAYING!

 

[Gfunk]

in order of preference:

McNabb
Brunell
Bledsoe
Manning​

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Having Henson and Romo holding clipboards was a waste of time.

how do you know, we haven't seen the development

BTW- How did Chris Simms get better? BY PLAYING!

and how was he able to see the field? BY SITTING! AND DEVELOPING! sitting and playing in a live game go hand-in-hand, some organizations choose to sit a young QB, and some choose to rush them and get their game experience early, neither process is wrong, it's about the QB