Who is the best QB entering 2015? From NFL.com

[pugilist]

Because he's not that good.

let me guess, you equate superbowl rings with individual QB performance?

 

[KJJ]

The only people who consider Romo in this category are Cowboys fans.

You mean Cowboy FANS.

 

[pugilist]

Brees
Ben
Eli
Luck - Mostly due to the age factor. Way more physically talented than Romo.
R. Wilson - Another age pick.

can't tell if serious.jpg

 

[dstovall5]

Because he's not that good.

 

[erod]

Brees
Ben
Eli
Luck - Mostly due to the age factor. Way more physically talented than Romo.
R. Wilson - Another age pick.

You are nuts.

Romo is so vastly superior to Wilson and Eli, it's not even worthy of a conversation. He moves in the pocket better than both, sees the feel WAY BETTER than both, and reads defenses at an entirely different level.

He just didn't have stellar defenses to win his games for him. He had to do everything by himself until last year.

 

[ConstantReboot]

The highest rated QB from last season didn't make the list???


NFL.COM
Who is the best quarterback in the NFL entering the 2015 season?

18%Tom Brady

43%Aaron Rodgers

6%Ben Roethlisberger

6%Peyton Manning

10%Andrew Luck

17%Other


Total Votes: 108480

What a stupid poll. Romo belongs in the list. NFL is showing their bias once again.

 

[Arkyvarminter]

You are nuts.

Romo is so vastly superior to Wilson and Eli, it's not even worthy of a conversation. He moves in the pocket better than both, sees the feel WAY BETTER than both, and reads defenses at an entirely different level.

He just didn't have stellar defenses to win his games for him. He had to do everything by himself until last year.

He either knows nothing about football or is trolling. Probably both.

 

[ConstantReboot]

Brees
Ben
Eli
Luck - Mostly due to the age factor. Way more physically talented than Romo.
R. Wilson - Another age pick.

So your saying Luck is better based on age and physic? I know a bunch of pretty girls that are young. I think they will top your list.

 

[PoundTheRock]

You are nuts.

Romo is so vastly superior to Wilson and Eli, it's not even worthy of a conversation. He moves in the pocket better than both, sees the feel WAY BETTER than both, and reads defenses at an entirely different level.

He just didn't have stellar defenses to win his games for him. He had to do everything by himself until last year.

You can't be serious. Russell Wilson has averaged almost 8 yards per attempt for his career throwing to some guys from a milk carton. Romo has a better everything on offense than him.

 

[Toruk_Makto]

At this point, objectively I'd say:

1. Rodgers
2. Brady
3. Romo
4. Roethlisberger
5. Luck
6. P. Manning
7. Brees
8. Flacco
9. Wilson
10. Ryan/Newton

What has Luck done to be 5th?

 

[Toruk_Makto]

Brees
Ben
Eli
Luck - Mostly due to the age factor. Way more physically talented than Romo.
R. Wilson - Another age pick.

On a list of who is the best qb today you include Age as a factor? How silly of you.

 

[JIMMYBUFFETT]

Brees
Ben
Eli
Luck - Mostly due to the age factor. Way more physically talented than Romo.
R. Wilson - Another age pick.

Okay, now you make sense. You're selecting Luck because he's physically more talented even though he's not as good of an NFL QB yet. You're selecting Wilson because he's younger but again not as good of an NFL QB. You should have told us this is how you judge a QB's performance. Eli must have been a typo because even he doesn't think he's as good as Romo.

 

[Arkyvarminter]

When he put Eli on his list all credibility went out the window...

 

[StylisticS]

Brees
Ben
Eli
Luck - Mostly due to the age factor. Way more physically talented than Romo.
R. Wilson - Another age pick.

Romo was better than all of those qb's last season.

 

[PoundTheRock]

Eli has 2 championship rings, he went through Romo directly to win both of them. He's a fantastic QB. For all of the bellyaching around here about Romo's support system, Eli has an atrocious OL and it doesn't stop him.

 

[Fritsch_the_cat]

R. Wilson - Another age pick.

 

[Arkyvarminter]

Eli has 2 championship rings, he went through Romo directly to win both of them. He's a fantastic QB. For all of the bellyaching around here about Romo's support system, Eli has an atrocious OL and it doesn't stop him.

He went through Romo? Romo doesn't play Defense. You should know that.

 

[xvendettax914]

Brees
Ben
Eli
Luck - Mostly due to the age factor. Way more physically talented than Romo.
R. Wilson - Another age pick.

Rough day. Needed a good laugh.

 

[PoundTheRock]

He went through Romo? Romo doesn't play Defense. You should know that.

Was Romo the QB of the Cowboys? All he had to do is outplay Eli.

 

[jterrell]

What is there to explain? I'm saying nationally people don't think Romo is as good as those other QBs and they're largely right. That's why he wasn't included in the poll.

Not sure how to say this nicely sooo I'll just be honest. That's just stupid.


Rodgers is better. Brady deserves more credit for his big game antics. Manning has history on his side.
After that???

Get the heck out of here.
Romo easily outplayed Luck last year. And Romo finished with almost 15 points higher QB rating.
Big Ben has been a solid performer and he has hardware but he wasn't better than Romo last year.

Romo had the highest yards per attempt and QB rating in football last year.
He was also highest in the 4th quarter and in close game situations late.

I know Colts fans who consider Romo better than Luck right now.

Arguing Romo doesn't deserve on the list is again really really stupid.
It'd be like not putting Murray at top 5 for RBs even tho he led the league last year in rushing yards.