Who is the best QB entering 2015? From NFL.com

[PoundTheRock]

The Colts didn't even try against the Cowboys. They were already in the playoffs, hold that against Luck if you must, but you're kidding yourself. He could've smoked us.

 

[jterrell]

Was Romo the QB of the Cowboys? All he had to do is outplay Eli.

Last I checked Romo beat Eli twice last year.
The list is referring to now not 2011.

 

[erod]

What has Luck done to be 5th?

Ya know....that's a damn good point.

(But I'd take him here in a heartbeat.)

 

[PoundTheRock]

Last I checked Romo beat Eli twice last year.
The list is referring to now not 2011.

The past doesn't suddenly stop counting. Eli is still in the NFL and playing at a high level.

 

[erod]

Last I checked Romo beat Eli twice last year.
The list is referring to now not 2011.

Actually, Romo has beaten Eli four times in a row and counting.

 

[jterrell]

The Colts didn't even try against the Cowboys. They were already in the playoffs, hold that against Luck if you must, but you're kidding yourself. He could've smoked us.

What about the postseason did they try then?
When Luck has a ~70 QB rating?

just stop saying stupid things man.

 

[xvendettax914]

The past doesn't suddenly stop counting. Eli is still in the NFL and playing at a high level.

So.. Elis performances as of late are "high level"? ooook then.

 

[erod]

Was Romo the QB of the Cowboys? All he had to do is outplay Eli.

You mean like he has four straight times?

 

[PoundTheRock]

What about the postseason did they try then?
When Luck has a ~70 QB rating?

just stop saying stupid things man.

Last time I checked Andrew Luck led his team further in the playoffs in 2014 than Romo has ever led the Cowboys. Luck being that guy who has only been in the NFL 3 years vs Romo who has countless failures on his resume. I swear some of you are bigger fans of Romo than the Cowboys.

 

[Silver N Blue]

Who would you put over him other than the usual qb's like Brady and Rogers.

Luck

 

[PoundTheRock]

You mean like he has four straight times?

Congratulations to Romo on more wins in meaningless games.

 

[Arkyvarminter]

The Colts didn't even try against the Cowboys. They were already in the playoffs, hold that against Luck if you must, but you're kidding yourself. He could've smoked us.

Oh I forgot..Luck didn't play in that game...

 

[xvendettax914]

Congratulations to Romo on more wins in meaningless games.

Division games = Meaningless?

 

[PoundTheRock]

Division games = Meaningless?

Were they playoff games?

 

[YosemiteSam]

Were they playoff games?

Commanders, Giants, or Eagles?

 

[xvendettax914]

Were they playoff games?

Right, i forgot. Doesnt take winning division games to get there. Got it. September comes and bam, miraculously in the playoffs. Carry on.

 

[PoundTheRock]

Commanders, Giants, or Eagles?

Yes, Romo's lost to every one of those teams in a play in or playoff game.

 

[JDSmith]

I barely watch games on CBS because Phil Simms is such an awful color guy. So I can't say I respect his opinion that much, but whatever.

Having read all of your posts in this thread I have to say that Phil Simms must be all broken up at your lack of respect.

Also, I wouldn't say that you are an absolute moron because that would get me benched, but I'm comfortable saying that your stance is absolutely moronic.

 

[benson]

The Colts didn't even try against the Cowboys. They were already in the playoffs, hold that against Luck if you must, but you're kidding yourself. He could've smoked us.

The Colts didn't even try against the Cowboys. LOL. You fool, no team of 53 NFL professionals steps on to a field and doesn't try. If you had watched the game, Luck had to be pulled for his own safety because of what was going on out there. Luck looked like an amateur against a hungry Cowboys defense, or do you think Luck actually likes getting sacked and throwing interceptions on national television? That's fun for him?

You're an obvious Giants fan troll, either that or an embarrassment for a Cowboys fan.

 

[erod]

Eli has 2 championship rings, he went through Romo directly to win both of them. He's a fantastic QB. For all of the bellyaching around here about Romo's support system, Eli has an atrocious OL and it doesn't stop him.

Running game and defense won those Super Bowls.

Eli doesn't suck, but he's not in Romo's class, period.