Why do people get so bent out of shape at Cowboy criticism?

yimyammer

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,574
Reaction score
7,004
Who cares what other people think? It doesn’t have any effect on the outcome and winning is all that matters anyway. Is any form of praise more satisfying than winning?

As I’ve read many posts where people become highly offended by Cowboys criticism, I can’t help but wonder why so many people get upset by the “haters” (there will always be haters) and other people who criticize the Cowboys.

Do you fall apart when you boss corrects your work? What do you do when your wife or significant other criticizes you? What about when friends get upset with you?

Seriously, how do you make it through the day with such thin skin? Why get so upset about what other people say or think about something you have absolutely no control over, involvement in or direct influence over?

It doesn’t matter what other people think about your beloved team, all that matters is winning and the satisfaction you derive from being devoted to your team.

In my opinion, winning is that much sweeter when the entire world is against me.

I’d be curious to know how old the people are who continually gripe about people criticizing the Cowboys. It seems I had much thinner skin when I was younger, so maybe this is just attributable to being passionate and young.

I’m sure this post will somehow be offensive and feathers are flying everywhere, but this wasn’t my intent, I was genuinely curious why this occurs and if it was merely a symptom of youth or something else.

No judgment here, you’re entitled to feel and react however you like, I just never let other peoples opinions affect my quality of life or the things I enjoy.

I enjoy thoughtful analysis and critiques of the Cowboys personnel, coaches, management and ownership, but I ignore tabloid journalism that tends to amount to nothing more than sensational rants in attempt to garner attention. These media outlets are counting on the very reaction too many people give them. They know if they provide inflammatory and controversial material, they’ll increase their audience.

Quit buying into their tactics and ignore them, or at least don’t give them the satisfaction of a reaction! Then, maybe, just maybe, they’ll start to write something worthwhile. This seems to be the way of the press in all forms of journalism these days and until people quit rewarding their behavior, it will just continue. I know this is idealistic, but it’s what is truly needed in all forms of journalism on all kinds of topics.

Thoughtful, mutually enlightened discussion never occurs because issues are always presented in a way that polarizes all parties involved. This doesn’t help anyone much less solve any problems. I can’t help but feel our inability to have civil discussion and open minded debate is putting the future of this country in an extremely perilous position, especially when something so unimportant in the scheme of life as the success or failure of the Dallas Cowboys devolves into a shouting match between the “realists” and the “optimists”.

You always hear people say, “don’t talk about religion or politics”, but I say those are the very things we need to talk about. Are there any bigger issues in our world than these two subjects? If we can’t talk about these matters, how do we expect to understand them or bring resolution to an issue?

This is a great forum to practice civil discussion based upon sound reason, firm evidence, logical and persuasive arguments set within an atmosphere of tolerance and a mutually desired outcome (“realists” or “optimist” , we all want to win a Super Bowl, don’t we?).

Hey, if we can do it here, maybe we can do it everywhere.

In my opinion, that’s true change from which hope can be born out of.

Just something to think about…..
 

Cajuncowboy

Preacher From The Black Lagoon
Messages
27,499
Reaction score
81
Because we are the
Dallas Freakin' Cowboys! We are THE team.Stop criticizing the criticism critics!

The nerve!








:D
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
Nothing wrong with constructive criticism but the whining gets to be too much at times.

Just something to think about
 

yimyammer

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,574
Reaction score
7,004
Cajuncowboy;2933703 said:
Because we are the
Dallas Freakin' Cowboys! We are THE team.Stop criticizing the criticism critics!

The nerve!








:D

Touch'e
 

WV Cowboy

Waitin' on the 6th
Messages
11,604
Reaction score
1,744
At the end of the day I really don't care what people say about the Cowboys.

I love'm and follow them no matter what.

All I ask for is to report accurately what is fair, ... give credit where credit is due, and criticize if it is merited.

I do get tired of the Cowboys not getting credit where it is due, or being criticized even if what they have done is trivial, not that unusual or that bad. Or if what they have done is not that different than what other teams are doing.

I think the players and the team deserve that much.

That normally doesn't happen, I complain a little, and then move on.

I hate it when you can tell the reporter is only following his/her own agenda.

I guess for me to expect integrity in reporting is expecting too much.
 

iceberg

rock music matters
Messages
34,404
Reaction score
7,932
Doomsday101;2933709 said:
Nothing wrong with constructive criticism but the whining gets to be too much at times.

Just something to think about

i just read a lot less. : )
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,114
Reaction score
11,463
Who says people get that upset by it, or "fall apart" when they read it?

This is a message board. People post articles and others comment on what was written. That's just the nature of it.

Just because someone says it's stupid that losing Anthony Henry or Tank Johnson is going to kill us doesn't mean it upsets them in real life.
 

ZeroClub

just trying to get better
Messages
7,619
Reaction score
1
Chocolate Lab;2933751 said:
Who says people get that upset by it, or "fall apart" when they read it?

This is a message board. People post articles and others comment on what was written. That's just the nature of it.

Just because someone says it's stupid that losing Anthony Henry or Tank Johnson is going to kill us doesn't mean it upsets them in real life.

That's a good point.

I can't imagine that anybody here becomes tearful because of something Skip Bayless or Emmitt Smith says.
 

yimyammer

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,574
Reaction score
7,004
Chocolate Lab;2933751 said:
Who says people get that upset by it, or "fall apart" when they read it?

This is a message board. People post articles and others comment on what was written. That's just the nature of it.

Just because someone says it's stupid that losing Anthony Henry or Tank Johnson is going to kill us doesn't mean it upsets them in real life.

I didn't say they did, I was just asking if they did. I just find some of the responses (which may only be from few and repeat customers) to be highly sensitive, but that may just be the way it comes across in the written word. However, given how irrational people get with other subjects in other venues, I kind of doubt it.

People also tend to be far more inflammatory when they can hide behind the comfort of their PC
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
If you go to any teams fan site, you will find similar feelings. It isn't unique to this site, or this fan base.

Don't believe it, pick any site of a team that someone is critical of and witness the backlash.

You can even pick other team sports.
 

ABQcowboyJR

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,424
Reaction score
494
yimyammer;2933697 said:
Do you fall apart when you boss corrects your work? What do you do when your wife or significant other criticizes you? What about when friends get upset with you?

Never been through any of this......haha


Like said above its the nature of online forums.
 

CoCo

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,603
Reaction score
187
Chocolate Lab;2933751 said:
Who says people get that upset by it, or "fall apart" when they read it?

This is a message board. People post articles and others comment on what was written. That's just the nature of it.

Just because someone says it's stupid that losing Anthony Henry or Tank Johnson is going to kill us doesn't mean it upsets them in real life.

CL,

With all due respect...

Uh, some here do. They definitely do.

There may be some folks who overdramatize it. But there is serious anger that gets kicked up on this board over a variety of issues. Shoot we just saw the political zone closed because differing opinions couldn't have a civil conversation.

The same thing happens when discussing other topics too including how the press reports on our team.

Exhibit A: Quarterback Coach vs Ed Werder

Any more questions?
 

Shake_Tiller

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,438
Reaction score
1,563
I criticize the critics of the criticism of the critics who criticize criticism for criticism's sake. And I think I an going to have a good cry, maybe watch a Lifetime movie and eat some chocolate.
 

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
It happens with every single team in the NFL. Criticize them and their fans will take offense.

My issue with Cowboys criticism usually falls when the media makes it obvious they are desperate for any Cowboys story. Last night we have a game going on between two AFC teams and at halftime 80% of the conversation with Bob Costas and Jeff Fisher is about criticizing the new videoboard that the Cowboys have at Cowboys Stadium. And Costas was the guy that brought it up. And I could go on and on about how bad the puppets at ESPN are, but I think we've gotten that point by now.

The other part that bothers me is criticism where there's some extremely screwy logic and/or inaccuracies involved. Or when there's just plain unprofessionalism involved. It's one thing to write a column saying that Wade is a poor coach and showing some nice details why. It's another to call him an 'idiot' or a 'bafoon' and refer to guys in a snide way like calling Terrell Owens as 'El Dorado' (yes, I know that's his middle name, but it's still a name calling jab at Owens and the writers who pull this crap know it). I'd feel the same way if a professional writer called Daniel Snyder an 'idiotic midget.'

To tell you the truth I think the Cowboys could go anywhere from 7-9 to 13-3 this season, so if somebody says they are going 6-10, that's not too far off from what I think they could possibly do. But if somebody says that they are going 6-10 without any substance backing it up and making it easy to see that they have an obvious vendetta against the team, then they need to be called out if they are a member of the professional media.




YAKUZA
 

yimyammer

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,574
Reaction score
7,004
Hostile;2933803 said:
If you go to any teams fan site, you will find similar feelings. It isn't unique to this site, or this fan base.

Don't believe it, pick any site of a team that someone is critical of and witness the backlash.

You can even pick other team sports.

No doubt and it applies to all kind of sites, not just Cowboy football.

I like to discuss what I perceive to be deficiencies in the team in order to be better educated as to why my perception is invalid or speculate how we might overcome a legitimate deficiency. Some people deem this to be negative or "hating" when in m mind it's just me trying to get educated and be constructively critical. I certainly hope our owner and coaches are constantly reevaluating and being constructively critical of all phases of the game and of all personnel and coaches.

Before I found this site, I started posting at the Dallas Cowboys site forum and one of my first posts, I had the audacity to say I thought the Cowboys would finish 8-8 and everyone started calling me a troll, etc, etc. I was like WTH? It's just my lame-*** opinion, I'm not trying to incite a riot.

By the way, the year I made this awful prognostication, we went 13-3, anyone want me to predict 8-8 again?
 

casmith07

Attorney-at-Zone
Messages
31,538
Reaction score
9,312
I don't care if they criticize our team, but at least present your argument in a logical and intelligent manner.

Critics like to just throw out buzz words and phrases like "stretch the field", "front seven" and "big play capability." They use numbers to try and compare players, ignoring the fact that you can be on a team like the Lions and put up big numbers because you're playing from behind all the time throwing the football.
 

Bizwah

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,158
Reaction score
3,877
I don't whine too much. I rarely read what the pundits want to say.

But you can't call the people "thin skinned" and weak for getting angry.

Do you have kids?

I ask because.....

I can take all kinds of crud....I do all the time....doesn't really bother me when I'm insulted....or when I'm criticized. If I'm criticized at work, I simply try to get better. If I'm criticized somewhere else, I simply ignore it.

But when it's my wife or kids.....then, I get riled up.

My guess is that most of these guys would be the same. They can probably take a lot of junk from folks....but if you insult their family...they get angry and spout off.

Many of us feel like that about the Cowboys. I get angry with the constant garbage our team seems to take. It actually seems like folks go out of their way to dog on the Cowboys. But I try to ignore it the best I can.
 

BrassCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,808
Reaction score
3,401
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Doomsday101;2933709 said:
Nothing wrong with constructive criticism but the whining gets to be too much at times.

Just something to think about

this :signmast:
 

sonnyboy

Benched
Messages
7,357
Reaction score
0
Yakuza Rich;2933852 said:
It happens with every single team in the NFL. Criticize them and their fans will take offense.

My issue with Cowboys criticism usually falls when the media makes it obvious they are desperate for any Cowboys story. Last night we have a game going on between two AFC teams and at halftime 80% of the conversation with Bob Costas and Jeff Fisher is about criticizing the new videoboard that the Cowboys have at Cowboys Stadium. And Costas was the guy that brought it up. And I could go on and on about how bad the puppets at ESPN are, but I think we've gotten that point by now.

The other part that bothers me is criticism where there's some extremely screwy logic and/or inaccuracies involved. Or when there's just plain unprofessionalism involved. It's one thing to write a column saying that Wade is a poor coach and showing some nice details why. It's another to call him an 'idiot' or a 'bafoon' and refer to guys in a snide way like calling Terrell Owens as 'El Dorado' (yes, I know that's his middle name, but it's still a name calling jab at Owens and the writers who pull this crap know it). I'd feel the same way if a professional writer called Daniel Snyder an 'idiotic midget.'

To tell you the truth I think the Cowboys could go anywhere from 7-9 to 13-3 this season, so if somebody says they are going 6-10, that's not too far off from what I think they could possibly do. But if somebody says that they are going 6-10 without any substance backing it up and making it easy to see that they have an obvious vendetta against the team, then they need to be called out if they are a member of the professional media.




YAKUZA


You hit the nail on the head with why we get pissed.

Every negative Cowboy prediction this year falls into one of those two categories.
 
Top