Worse FA Signing EVER... Justin Smith 49ers deal

TwoCentPlain

Numbnuts
Messages
15,193
Reaction score
11,109
Now the 49ers have a QB named Smith who stinks and a DE named Smith who stinks. They are cornering the market on "Smiths that stink and make a lot of money." Any other Smiths out there who stink and want a lot of money?

What do you expect from a team that trades their 1st to NE for some chance to draft some scrub OL? The 49ers may have the top pick in the draft next year ... if they don't trade it away like fools.
 

redfog

New Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Here's his recent interview and it will explain everything you need to know. I think it's a good signing myself.

Quote:
--He took a helicopter ride with coach Mike Nolan to see the sights in the Bay Area on Friday. He said he's been on a helicopter before but not like this. He said it was an interesting view of the city, Alcatraz and down the coast line and some of the rural areas.

--The main reason he canceled other visits was meeting coaching staff and some of the players (Jeff Ulbrich and Joe Nedney), and watching the defense and seeing where the team is and where it can go. He was impressed with defensive coordinator Greg Manusky. Top to bottom it's a first-class organization, he said. He said it was a no-brainer.




Quote:
--How does he envision himself being used? "In talking with Greg, it's an an attacking style defense. It's not a 3-4 where you're two-gapping. It's an attacking style of defense." He said he thinks it'll be a great fit.

--Can he play DE in 3-4, as well as 4-3? "Absolutely. In Cincinnati, we switched from 4-3 to 3-4 all the time. A lot of people don't know, but a lot of teams do that, depending on down and distance, the formations offenses are throwing at defenses, and so I've done a lot before."

--On playing outside linebacker in a 3-4 . . . he said it's the coach's call, but he said he could be an asset moving around. He said he can be a moving linebacker, rush from the inside or rush from the outside. "I'll throw it out there," Smith said.


--On his durability: "I haven't thought about it. Every Sunday, you gear up and go out and play with the guys." There are several games he said he could've missed or should've missed, but he doesn't want to leave his teammates hanging.

--He said he planned to go on other visits, but he said after meeting Manusky and coach Nolan, it felt right. He said the city felt right and the situation felt right. He said, "Why go on another visit, if you're going to be right back here?" He also had visits scheduled for Minnesota and, possibly, Jacksonville.

--On his career-low two sacks from last year: "There were a lot of reasons for last year. Both me and Robert Geathers were hampered by injuries that we had with linebackers and secondary, so we were forced into blitzing situations that caused us to have to pinch and penetrate and take up the gap." He added, "I think I bring I bring a lot to the table as far as run and stuffing ability go. If you look at my stats, compared to everybody else over my seven-year career, I think they match up pretty well."

--He said he's not into the specialization of football. He plays first, second and third downs. He rushes the passer and he plays the run. He plays football and he goes 100 percent, and that's all he knows how to do, he said.
 

redfog

New Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Dallas4ever;1980221 said:
Might be a tad overstated but I certainly get your point. Although we shouldn't be too surprised, considering that just last year they overpaid Nate Clements in record fashion. Don't look for their GM to be there very long. ;)

How did they overpay Clements? he got a 7 year 64 million deal being a top 5 CB easily 22 million guaranteed. While there are guys like Drayton Florence who gave up 10.3 yards a pass (one of leagues worst) and got 10 million in guaranteed money. Also a scrub like Reeves who got 20 million in 5 years. Stop being ignorant. You are just bashing them because they ain't the Cowboys. I hate fans like this.
 

Dallas4ever

Active Member
Messages
2,547
Reaction score
2
redfog;1980266 said:
How did they overpay Clements? he got a 7 year 64 million deal being a top 5 CB easily 22 million guaranteed. While there are guys like Drayton Florence who gave up 10.3 yards a pass (one of leagues worst) and got 10 million in guaranteed money. Also a scrub like Reeves who got 20 million in 5 years. Stop being ignorant. You are just bashing them because they ain't the Cowboys. I hate fans like this.


Calm down.:confused: It's ok to have a different opinion. It's an opinionated discussion board.

Please don't let my views aggravate you...........peace!:)
 

silverbear

Semi-Official Loose Cannon
Messages
24,195
Reaction score
25
Bach;1980180 said:
Yep.

It's the difference between being objective and being a blind homer.

Only you cynics equate sneering cynicism with objectivity...

You are most assuredly NOT being objective, with your relentless cynicism... things are simply not as gloomy as you'd have us believe...

But who knows, maybe we need the sneering cynics to counterbalance the pie in the sky pollyannas... perhaps between those two types of fools, a balanced picture can be obtained...
 

silverbear

Semi-Official Loose Cannon
Messages
24,195
Reaction score
25
Teague31;1980112 said:
Justin Smith to the 49ers for $45 million.... coming off a 2 sack season.... a bargain at just $22.5 million per sack.

The Niners are lucky he didn't have 3 sacks, they might not have been able to afford him... :D
 

hairic

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,724
Reaction score
650
I don't see what the issue is. It looks like he got paid what he's worth. $30 million less than Freeney.

I don't think he should have been franchised last year, though.
 

iceberg

rock music matters
Messages
34,432
Reaction score
7,950
Bach;1980180 said:
Yep.

It's the difference between being objective and being a blind homer.

and there's only fools who hide their hated behind such tags as "objective".

just because you hate whine btch and moan doesn't make you objetive.

just a fool.
 

EPL0c0

The Funcooker
Messages
8,178
Reaction score
3,992
Teague31;1980112 said:
Justin Smith to the 49ers for $45 million.... coming off a 2 sack season.... a bargain at just $22.5 million per sack. Absolute insanity! If Jerry had signed that deal, we would be marching on Valley Ranch with torches and pitchforks. Some of these teams have no clue.
I read your post Subject line and I dunno why but "Dallas signs Marcellus Wiley" popped into my head... weird
 
Messages
27,093
Reaction score
0
The 49ers really overpaid for a less than average player honestly... Now they have set the market too high!
 

JoeCorrado

Active Member
Messages
1,973
Reaction score
3
Bach;1980117 said:
I doubt it. Half the board would be making excuses and defending it all the while bashing anyone who dared say it was a horrific deal.

:bow:
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
rathalarge;1980129 said:
We once signed a guy (wr) named Anthony Miller...remember that? Now that was bad!! Or, how about another guy named Carl Pickens, who was so out of shape (hamstring problems) he just retired before the season started!! And don't forget, 'Dat Dude'! I have to give the 'Niner's a flyer on this one. But the money that Justin Smith was given is crazy!!

Pickens was not a bad signing because he didn't cost tons of money. Since he retired he didn't even earn any of his base salary for that year.

I don't remember the contract details for Miller, but I doubt it was for any crazy money.

Dat Dude was bad.

Bryant Westbrook was not a bad signing since they could have cut him at any time during camp if he didn't prove himself. But they didn't do that. He had a poor training camp and pre-season and Dallas still kept him, let him play one game to guarantee his salary and then cut him. Signing not bad. What they did with him was bad.
 

Bach

Benched
Messages
7,645
Reaction score
0
iceberg;1980338 said:
and there's only fools who hide their hated behind such tags as "objective".

just because you hate whine btch and moan doesn't make you objetive.

just a fool.

WG's should have a field day with this one. :wink2:
 

Bach

Benched
Messages
7,645
Reaction score
0
Nexx;1980226 said:
that makes zero sense, after being cut, Javon is a Free Agent, which would make it a Free Agent signing.

There are UFA's and then there are street FA's.

The FA period started Feb. 29, but Zach was signed prior to that because he was released. Javon would fall into that same category.

I was just differientiating between the two. Sorry for the confusion.
 

Marty R

Member
Messages
63
Reaction score
0
Bach;1980563 said:
There are UFA's and then there are street FA's.

The FA period started Feb. 29, but Zach was signed prior to that because he was released. Javon would fall into that same category.

I was just differientiating between the two. Sorry for the confusion.


huh? :confused:
 

Oh_Canada

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,083
Reaction score
4,222
This signing can be summed up in one word...."desperation".
 

Aikbach

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,746
Reaction score
42
It is a strange notion I haven't fully begun to appreciate when I see the 49ers floundering as a laughing stock of an organization when for so long they were the only true threat to Cowboy dominance.
 

iceberg

rock music matters
Messages
34,432
Reaction score
7,950
Bach;1981040 said:
Baseball starts soon.

can you please go bother the baseball fans for awhile and say their owner sucks w/o end?
 
Top