Would you rather?

[ChronicCowboy]

A.) Dallas finishes the season 11-6 or 10-7. Dallas loses first round game to Bucs/Saints. McCarthy is fired and Quinn takes over.

B.) Dallas finishes season 12-5. Dallas blows out first round opponent like last season. Dallas loses to Eagles/9ers convincingly in divisional round. MM is retained and Quinn decides to take a HC job.

I’d personally take option A. I think we’ve maxed out with MM, but I’m not necessarily sold on Quinn as HC either.

 

[Mac_MaloneV1]

B obviously.

This poll is exactly why I say things like "half this board would rather the Cowboys lose and be right."

 

[ChronicCowboy]

B obviously.

This poll is exactly why I say things like "half this board would rather the Cowboys lose and be right."

They lose in both scenarios genius.

 

[Redsfan_83]

In either scenario MM is coming back. DQ may or may not leave, but hedging a bit that defensive head coaches do not typically succeed in todays NFL so......

 

[acr731]

MM isn't going to be fired, no matter how the season ends.

 

[stilltheguru]

Quinn is not a better coach than Mccarthy. Not even close!

 

[Kingofholland]

I'll take the unknown of option c.

 

[Mac_MaloneV1]

They lose in both scenarios genius.

Your point is "I don't want them to win a playoff game."

Would you rather go 0-17 or lose in the Super Bowl? They lose either way.

 

[Mac_MaloneV1]

Quinn is not a better coach than Mccarthy. Not even close!

Quinn sucks.

There is absolutely nothing to suggest that he should be a HC anywhere

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Quinn and McCarthy leaving changes nothing.

The same way Kellen Moore leaving changed nothing.

 

[Brooksey]

I'll go with Option C, we beat the Eagles in the divisional and move on to the NFC championship game against SF.

Everyone comes back

 

[The Quest for Six]

Dan Quinn has been getting too much of a pass this year when it comes to this defense..

 

[phildadon86]

Quinn and McCarthy leaving changes nothing.

The same way Kellen Moore leaving changed nothing.

Still waiting to see Moore's genius with a real QB. Remember when you said that?

 

[Redsfan_83]

Quinn and McCarthy leaving changes nothing.

The same way Kellen Moore leaving changed nothing.

you don't really mean KM leaving didn't change things did you? Up until this game I am betting you believed it did

 

[ChronicCowboy]

Your point is "I don't want them to win a playoff game."

Would you rather go 0-17 or lose in the Super Bowl? They lose either way.

So a playoff win vs an 8-9 team gives us what exactly? A worse draft pick? If a loss the following week is guaranteed (as in my hypothetical), it would at least mix things up.

 

[Mac_MaloneV1]

So a playoff win vs an 8-9 team gives us what exactly? A worse draft pick? If a loss the following week is guaranteed (as in my hypothetical), a loss would at least mix things up.

Right, so you'd rather that they lose so you can be right that they need to change things up. Like I said.

Answer this question - Would you rather A) go 0-17 to "mix things up" and get a better draft pick or B) lose in the Super Bowl? By your logic, the answer is A.

 

[Aven8]

Overreaction Monday at its finest….

Drink some EggNog. You’ll feel better..

 

[Redsfan_83]

So a playoff win vs an 8-9 team gives us what exactly? A worse draft pick? If a loss the following week is guaranteed (as in my hypothetical), it would at least mix things up.

There is no team in the NFC that should scare us outside the 9ers, and no team plays the fierce D that the Bills do. Not sure any of you on here followed the defensive stats the Bills have put up this year, sans 3 top players

 

[Swagger]

A.) Dallas finishes the season 11-6 or 10-7. Dallas loses first round game to Bucs/Saints. McCarthy is fired and Quinn takes over.

B.) Dallas finishes season 12-5. Dallas blows out first round opponent like last season. Dallas loses to Eagles/9ers convincingly in divisional round. MM is retained and Quinn decides to take a HC job.

I’d personally take option A. I think we’ve maxed out with MM, but I’m not necessarily sold on Quinn as HC either.

It doesn't really matter as Prescott will be resigned and the Cowboys are unable to beat good teams on the road so unless the team is perfect in other regular season games to secure the #1 seed they will be unable to get over the hump until a better QB is brought in.

 

[CCBoy]

They lose in both scenarios genius.

You also targeting merchant ships in the Red Sea. Talk on concept instead of just insulting another's focus. Genius attack?