Would you rather?

[CCBoy]

So a playoff win vs an 8-9 team gives us what exactly? A worse draft pick? If a loss the following week is guaranteed (as in my hypothetical), it would at least mix things up.

A win if won, first off, is good. That stands alone...

 

[ChronicCowboy]

Right, so you'd rather that they lose so you can be right that they need to change things up. Like I said.

Answer this question - Would you rather A) go 0-17 to "mix things up" and get a better draft pick or B) lose in the Super Bowl? By your logic, the answer is A.

WTH is this “so you can be right” bs? I asked a simple question.

 

[CCBoy]

Overreaction Monday at its finest….

Drink some EggNog. You’ll feel better..

Bourbon?

 

[CCBoy]

WTH is this “so you can be right” bs? I asked a simple question.

Not everyone has the vision that if not perfect during the journey, your own view is the only relevance to be had....sorry, not true.

 

[Bobhaze]

Whatever anyone thinks of McCarthy personally, he’s 34-15 since 2021 and Cowboys have won 15 straight at home. They haven’t lost back to back games since 2021.

I‘m not defending what they threw out yesterday - it was a complete coaching staff/53 man roster stinker. But with this owner, we are not going to get some coaching “savior” to come in here and plant a miracle.

IMO Big Mac is light years better than Garrett and JJ hires HCs based first and foremost on his personal “comfort” with them not their coaching ability. Unless this team loses 4 straight and the team quits on him, Big Mac is back next year regardless.

 

[ChronicCowboy]

Not everyone has the vision that if not perfect during the journey, your own view is the only relevance to be had....sorry, not true.

Is that English? Sorry can’t compute.

 

[rnr_honeybadger]

The Dallas Cowboys are a brand first. Football I don't think factors into the top 5 in importance to this club.

 

[Mac_MaloneV1]

WTH is this “so you can be right” bs? I asked a simple question.

I gave you an answer. The fact that you chose to not win a playoff game so that you can fire the coach means you'd rather lose and be proven right about this team not being able to win. That is your position.

You can't even answer my question because of how obviously ridiculous your logic is.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

you don't really mean KM leaving didn't change things did you? Up until this game I am betting you believed it did

We had #1 offense under Moore that sucked against good teams.

That’s not changed.

 

[CCBoy]

MM isn't going to be fired, no matter how the season ends.

Winning may be a real motivation. Jerry chomping on his butt might be a motivator as well.

 

[G2]

We had #1 offense under Moore that sucked against good teams.

That’s not changed.

Only it did, you were in the corner sobbing in the fetal position for half the season.

 

[visionary]

A.) Dallas finishes the season 11-6 or 10-7. Dallas loses first round game to Bucs/Saints. McCarthy is fired and Quinn takes over.

B.) Dallas finishes season 12-5. Dallas blows out first round opponent like last season. Dallas loses to Eagles/9ers convincingly in divisional round. MM is retained and Quinn decides to take a HC job.

I’d personally take option A. I think we’ve maxed out with MM, but I’m not necessarily sold on Quinn as HC either.

Neither option is good
Quinn is not a good HC. Even as a DC he is making the same mistakes from 2 years ago in the niners game
I dont think we can win a SB with MM, DQ, Dak combo

If we dont make the NFCCG i would let all 3 go but unfortunately Jerry will not do that and it will be more rearranging deck chairs on the titanic

 

[diamonddelts]

Overreaction Monday at its finest….

Drink some EggNog. You’ll feel better..

Stevie Wonder Wednesday is even better. Enjoy the unfounded optimism.

 

[Redsfan_83]

We had #1 offense under Moore that sucked against good teams.

That’s not changed.

Dak is a totally different QB, forget about yesterdays all over mess. How is Herbert under KM? Why didn't think offer him the interim job? We had the #1 offense in spite of Kellen, MM has done more with Dak in 15 games than Moore did in how many years? C'mon man. This beatdown was on both sides of the ball, not on Dak or just the O

 

[ChronicCowboy]

Neither option is good
Quinn is not a good HC. Even as a DC he is making the same mistakes from 2 years ago in the niners game
I dont think we can win a SB with MM, DQ, Dak combo

If we dont make the NFCCG i would let all 3 go but unfortunately Jerry will not do that and it will be more rearranging deck chairs on the titanic

Yes. The options are bad. We all want Dallas to win the Super Bowl or at minimum break the 27 year title game drought.

But it’s a hypothetical question exploring fan opinion if things go wrong. If we make the NFC championship I want everyone back. But if we don’t, I think a shake-up is necessary to prevent the whole thing going stale next season.

 

[Sarge]

Overreaction Monday at its finest….

Drink some EggNog. You’ll feel better..

Mmmmmmmmmmmm…eggnooooooooooooog…

 

[austin88]

I'm confused. What exactly about yesterday's defensive performance (or Seattle two weeks ago, for that matter) has got people fantasizing about scenarios in which DQ becomes the head coach?

 

[ChronicCowboy]

I'm confused. What exactly about yesterday's defensive performance (or Seattle two weeks ago, for that matter) has got people fantasizing about scenarios in which DQ becomes the head coach?

It would be a Jerry move.

 

[Redsfan_83]

I'm confused. What exactly about yesterday's defensive performance (or Seattle two weeks ago, for that matter) has got people fantasizing about scenarios in which DQ becomes the head coach?

forgot to mention Zona and 9ers

 

[cowboys5xsbs]

A.) Dallas finishes the season 11-6 or 10-7. Dallas loses first round game to Bucs/Saints. McCarthy is fired and Quinn takes over.

B.) Dallas finishes season 12-5. Dallas blows out first round opponent like last season. Dallas loses to Eagles/9ers convincingly in divisional round. MM is retained and Quinn decides to take a HC job.

I’d personally take option A. I think we’ve maxed out with MM, but I’m not necessarily sold on Quinn as HC either.

What about Dan Quinns defense inspired confidence yesterday?