Would you take a #1 for Martellus Bennett now?

[Bleu Star]

Carpenter is having more of a positive impact on this team than Bennett is right now.

That is a mirage.

Fact: Barbie has entered his 4th season.
Fact: MartyB has entered his 2nd season.

All rookies should be given three full seasons to acquit themselves.

Barbie, in his 4th year, is barely holding onto a situational will position after being drafted in the 1st round.

MartyB is still existing under the three year rule.

 

[Bleu Star]

Can we trade Wade for a 1st?

 

[Cochese]

That is a mirage.

Fact: Barbie has entered his 4th season.
Fact: MartyB has entered his 2nd season.

All rookies should be given three full seasons to acquit themselves.

Barbie, in his 4th year, is barely holding onto a situational will position after being drafted in the 1st round.

MartyB is still existing under the three year rule.

He is on the clock.

Its time to produce, or ****.

 

[wileedog]

That is a mirage.

Fact: Barbie has entered his 4th season.
Fact: MartyB has entered his 2nd season.

All rookies should be given three full seasons to acquit themselves.

Barbie, in his 4th year, is barely holding onto a situational will position after being drafted in the 1st round.

MartyB is still existing under the three year rule.

Which is why I said right now, but my point still stands. At the moment, if I had to cut someone outright I would cut Bennett before Carpenter.

Plus I can't imagine any scenario under the sun where you hold on to a 2nd year player and hope he develops into something remotely useful over getting a 1st round pick for him. Especially when you have a future HOFer already in front of him on the depth chart, and a 3rd stringer who is at the very least blocking just as well.

I'd take a third because I think his work ethic is garbage, his route running is terrible and he's not going to develop. Next year at this time we're going to be hoping for a 2nd day pick, but that's my opinion.

 

[Bleu Star]

Which is why I said right now, but my point still stands. At the moment, if I had to cut someone outright I would cut Bennett before Carpenter.

Plus I can't imagine any scenario under the sun where you hold on to a 2nd year player and hope he develops into something remotely useful over getting a 1st round pick for him. Especially when you have a future HOFer already in front of him on the depth chart, and a 3rd stringer who is at the very least blocking just as well.

I'd take a third because I think his work ethic is garbage, his route running is terrible and he's not going to develop. Next year at this time we're going to be hoping for a 2nd day pick, but that's my opinion.

Duly noted sir.

 

[Wood]

Bennett just wasnt used right this year. Dallas changed Bennetts assignment this year because his blocking vastly improved but its costing him some seam routes. I am absolutely convinced you put him as starter on a passing offense and he is top 7 TE in the league. Dallas should trade him if they are going to under utilize him like this.

 

[ZeroClub]

Classic narcissistic personality disorder

Yikes. Are you saying that Marty B has a mental disorder?

Seems a little harsh. He's 21 years old. He's playing pro football, making a lot of money, doing pizza commercials with Jerry, doing all varieties of media.... Seems like he's handling it relatively well for a 21 year old, IMO.

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

No, give him a full season as a starter and the guy will mature quickly enough. His time will come but right now we have Witten...

I agree.Give MB one full season to develop. Fer now, Romo and Witt have this man-love bbf thing going on. And it's difficult for MB to horn in on that relationship. And that relationship transfers to consistent Romo-to-Witten intermediate short passes. And it works. And MB is the odd man out, statistically speaking. It's a little Witten-the-featured=passer and a little MB-being-immature. Not a good combination. Give him time. Who else out there who can replace him well? And who out there who will settle as No. 2 to Witten?