Would you trade... RW11 and a 2nd for Marshall..

[Cowboy Brian]

Well since the trend of the week is would you trade X for X? I decided Ill jump in this bandwagon.


Would you trade Roy Williams and 2010 2nd Round pick for Brandon Marshall?


I would, no question. Marshall is my 2nd favorite WR outside of Miles Austin, only after Andre Johnson.

Austin/Marshall would be 10x more deadly than Fitzgerald/Boldin

If I had to, I would even up it to a 1st round pick and Roy Williams.

 

[Gzus]

I'd give up RW11, a 2nd and a 4th for Marshall. He wants out of Denver and would make us an instant SB favorite.

 

[DEZBRYANT x88x]

Yes..

But people wouldnt due to Marshalls personal issues (mini T.O.)

 

[Rampage]

I'd give up Roy for Romo 2 Austin. but no I wouldn't do the trade you mentioned cause I don't want a guy who abuses women on my favorite team. yes I know he's a very good wr but he's plain and simple an *******.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

I'd give up RW11, a 2nd and a 4th for Marshall. He wants out of Denver and would make us an instant SB favorite.

Exactly; People that are saying build for the future are dumb, next season/2011/2012 are the best bets for us the win it all. Marshall brings us this opportunity

 

[big dog cowboy]

Would you trade Roy Williams and 2010 2nd Round pick for Brandon Marshall?

Roy Williams AND a 2nd?

Um, NO.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

I'd give up Roy for Romo 2 Austin. but no I wouldn't do the trade you mentioned cause I don't want a guy who abuses women on my favorite team. yes I know he's a very good wr but he's plain and simple an *******.

I play QB. but it may not be a bad trade! Atleast it wouldnt be like putting 10 people out on offense, since i'd be on the bench.

 

[DaBoys4Life]

i'd trade RW for some lint. Marshall would be the football gods blessing us.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

i'd trade RW for some lint. Marshall would be the football gods blessing us.

I've uncovered one of 6 NFL players you like.

 

[dadymat]

i wouldnt want Marshall if he were free.........id rather keep RW then have that loser here

 

[DaBoys4Life]

I've uncovered one of 6 NFL players you like.

LoL i'm not anti-football however some do think i`m anti-cowboys which is strange to me but those are the breaks i guess.

 

[DaBoys4Life]

i wouldnt want Marshall if he were free.........id rather keep RW then have that loser here

of course.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

i wouldnt want Marshall if he were free.........id rather keep RW then have that loser here

I see him more like OchoCinco than like Terrell Owens, but I may be missing something.

He had an outstanding season with Kyle Orton as his QB, imagine Romo throwing him the ball, and with Austin taking double coverage, Marshall single'd up on he would have freakin' 1200+ yards and miles having 1200+ yards.

 

[Rampage]

I see him more like OchoCinco than like Terrell Owens, but I may be missing something.

He had an outstanding season with Kyle Orton as his QB, imagine Romo throwing him the ball, and with Austin taking double coverage, Marshall single'd up on he would have freakin' 1200+ yards and miles having 1200+ yards.

Marshall is slower that T.O. but with much better hands. he's nothing like Chad. also neither Chad or T-Old hit woman like Marshall does.

 

[Gzus]

Problem with this idea is how are you gonna pay him....
Austin is probably going to want somewhere around 5-6 million a year; Marshall likely around 6-7 million a year. How do you manage to pay both of them without suffering in another area of your team.

 

[Gzus]

He had an outstanding season with Kyle Orton as his QB, imagine Romo throwing him the ball, and with Austin taking double coverage, Marshall single'd up on he would have freakin' 1200+ yards and miles having 1200+ yards.

Marshall would likely be the one that sees most of the double coverage, and Austin would likely see single with a good amount of double as well. If anyone were to benefit the most from this it would be Witten who would be singled. This trade would be a best case amazing scenario, the chances it would happen is very very minimal. But we can all dream

 

[Cowboy Brian]

Problem with this idea is how are you gonna pay him....
Austin is probably going to want somewhere around 5-6 million a year; Marshall likely around 6-7 million a year. How do you manage to pay both of them without suffering in another area of your team.

Roy w is getting 7-9 a year right now, T.O's 8m a year cap hit comes off next year, so pay Miles Roys contract and pay Marshall T.O's contract.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

Marshall would likely be the one that sees most of the double coverage, and Austin would likely see single with a good amount of double as well. If anyone were to benefit the most from this it would be Witten who would be singled. This trade would be a best case amazing scenario, the chances it would happen is very very minimal. But we can all dream

There is no possible way they could double both, so either way it is a win for us. This scenario is a nightmare for Defensive Coordinators, if you take one out of the game the other and Witten will run up 350+ yards on you. We would be unstoppable.

 

[Rampage]

when is the last time a team won a superbowl with two #1 wide receivers?

the answer would be never cause it isn't necessary to waste the money on a #1 wr if you already have one.

 

[Gzus]

There is no possible way they could double both, so either way it is a win for us. This scenario is a nightmare for Defensive Coordinators, if you take one out of the game the other and Witten will run up 350+ yards on you. We would be unstoppable.

Unless you have what happened against the Vikings where their front 4 was on Romo the second the ball was snapped.