Young > McNair

[Bleu Star]

I just thought I would start up a little offseason debate. The Pro and Anti Young peeps still need a lil stimulation even when our Boys aren't playing.

 

[Wrangler87]

Steve Young?

You're not talking about the NFL's lowest rated passer are you?

 

[Da Hammer]

I just thought I would start up a little offseason debate. The Pro and Anti Young peeps still need a lil stimulation even when our Boys aren't playing.

Get it right Young>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> McNair

 

[windward]

Young 2006> McNair 1995

 

[Rampage]

this thread is crazy. vince young is not better than mcnair. it was 1 bad game.

 

[Wrangler87]

Carter>Young when comparing passing Rookie seasons.

Funny how the media can brainwash people into thinking certain directions.

 

[Da Hammer]

Carter>Young when comparing passing Rookie seasons.

Funny how the media can brainwash people into thinking certain directions.

Please include the win/loss record for both players. Argument over!!!

 

[Bleu Star]

this thread is crazy. vince young is not better than mcnair. it was 1 bad game.

Flame on.

VY > Steve *

 

[cstanton1987]

Carter>Young when comparing passing Rookie seasons.

Funny how the media can brainwash people into thinking certain directions.

ALL HE DOES IS WIN GAMES...seriously Young 2006 >>> McNair 2006

 

[cstanton1987]

Carter>Young when comparing passing Rookie seasons.

Funny how the media can brainwash people into thinking certain directions.

Carter who?...Quincy Carter! Are you serious!? I was as big a Quincy fan as there was in Dallas but there no way in hell I'd take Quincy over VY

 

[Bleu Star]

Carter>Young when comparing passing Rookie seasons.

Funny how the media can brainwash people into thinking certain directions.

Are you serious?

 

[windward]

ALL HE DOES IS WIN GAMES...seriously Young 2006 >>> McNair 2006

my word. McNair won 13 games this season. He's pretty solid himself.

 

[superpunk]

Eli Manning >>>>> Vince Young.

Cowboyszone = Not a Titans board.

 

[Bleu Star]

Eli Manning >>>>> Vince Young.

Blasphemy!

Cowboyszone = Not a Titans board.

I was just trying to get your blood flowing. Looks like it worked.

 

[Wrangler87]

Please include the win/loss record for both players. Argument over!!!

More to winning than QB play. Ask Young. He got 8 special team TD's and four defensive TD's. Think that helped his record?

Drink the media koolaid........

 

[cstanton1987]

my word. McNair won 13 games this season. He's pretty solid himself.

I'd give the Lions share of that figure to the defense

 

[cstanton1987]

Eli Manning >>>>> Vince Young.

Cowboyszone = Not a Titans board.

U Mad?

 

[superpunk]

Steve McNair's team = Made the playoffs

Steve McNair's record as starter this year > Vince Young's

 

[windward]

I'd give the Lions share of that figure to the defense

Well I like Vince as much as anybody, but a strong running game ,special teams and defense had thier fair share of wins in Tennessee, too.

 

[Wrangler87]

Carter who?...Quincy Carter! Are you serious!? I was as big a Quincy fan as there was in Dallas but there no way in hell I'd take Quincy over VY

He had a better QB Rating than Young in their respecitve Rookie seasons.

Carter just didn't get the help of 8 special teams TD's and 4 defensive TD's.