CowboyMike;3723047 said:
I thought Skin of Evil was absolutely pointless. Just like they would touch on the rest of the season, Tasha's death was senseless and so was the episode.
Got to disagree. An amoral alien malevolent being, with total control over the lives of the shuttlecraft crew (was there someone other than Troi inside the ship?), creates a no-win situation for victims and rescuers alike. All of their advanced technology was rendered practically useless--so much so to the point where a major series character was killed as casually as any of us would have stepped on a bug.
In the end, the survivors found themselves acting more so out of revenge while they escaped--which was almost a complete 180 degree stance away from the established Gene Roddenberry 24th century "evolved" human attitude he centered ST:TNG on. I have always considered it one of Roddenberry's more edgy retro plotlines dealing with utterly alien entities without any regard for other intelligent lifeforms, much like his
Wolf In The Fold from the original series.
CowboyMike;3723047 said:
Conspiracy was good if not a little weird. It has been suggested that the aliens in that episode were a precursor for the Borg, but never solidified. I thought DS9 did a much better job with pretty much the same plot (minus the aliens) in "Homefront" and "Paradise Lost".
Agreed. I do like the episode, but have to admit that an alien invasion composed of what I have always described as 'beetle scorpions' which burrow into your neck and control you mind and body through your brain stem was a little thin.
:
Roddenberry borrowed the idea for the tiny aliens from the creatures Khan used to control Captain Terrell and Chekov in STII:Wrath. They were more 'menacing' in the movie than they ever were in the episode.
CowboyMike;3723047 said:
"Contagion" was good. I'll give you that. I was unimpressed with "Q Who", to be honest. But it did set up possibly the greatest Star Trek episode ever, "The Best of Both Worlds, Parts I and II".
One of my favorite pieces of dialogue from any ST episodes comes nearly at the end of
Contagion, when Picard escapes from the facility on the planet and jumps onto the Romulan bridge through the transporter 'rip'. With her ship falling apart around her, the Romulan commander tells Picard that they cannot halt the ship's self-destruct, but that she will have the pleasure of at least having him die with them also--to which Picard replies (as he finally senses the Enterprise's transporter lock on him), "Not I think today, Commander". After he disappears, the look of disgust on her face is priceless. Great, great scene in my opinion.
"Q Who"? Where can I began? Nevermind. I'll go old windbag on you and bore you to death.
However, I will say that
Q Who was the first episode in Roddenberry's second series which reestablished the original series' main theme that the Federation was not 'all-powerful' and created a new alien race which made the Klingons and Romulans combined looked tame by comparison. One of the episode's subplots delved deeper into Guinan's character which I also enjoyed a lot of. Heck, her past dealings with Q (which were never explained indepth) were significant enough that Q was concerned about her being on the ship with him. Now, why would a ommipotent entity care one iota about some mortal (albeit a very LONG lived mortal)?
Best Of Both Worlds is my all-time favorite as well. It beats out my next three favorite two-parters:
Redemption,
Unification and
Descent.
CowboyMike;3723047 said:
I do have some favorites in Season 2, though. I thought "The Outrageous Okona" was a fun episode with a good performance from Bill Campbell, who was in the top 2 originally considered for Riker.
"The Measure of a Man" may be among the top five of the entire series. It is an absolutely excellent episode, in my opinion.
Love those two choices. Two of my favorites off the top of my head are
The Survivors and
Relics.
Great dialogue at the end of
Survivors. Forgive me. This is from memory, so it's not exact at all
: :
Picard: It's no wonder you tried so hard to hide your identity. You are responsible for the destruction of Rana 3!
Kevin: No! I was defending Rana and that is the reason for my shame.
Picard: Shame? Who really destroyed the planet?
Kevin: They called themselves the Hushnock. A malevolent race of hideous thought and mind. I tried to fool the Hushnock as I did you, but they saw through my illusions. It only made them madder. More cruel.
At one point, Reshan ran off to help the other colonists defend themselves from the Hushnock.
Troi (I think): Why did you not fight as well?
Kevin: I am a Dowd. I will not kill and thus did not help Reshan and the others.
Troi: But you could have saved them all.
Kevin: I... will... not... kill.
Picard: Then... what you tried so hard to prevent... happened. Reshan died defending the colony.
Kevin: This is what I wanted to hide from you. This is my shame. When Reshan died, in a fit of anger, I lashed out and destroyed the Hushnock...
Picard: ... but you were only defending the colonists ...
Kevin: No no no. You do not understand. I did not kill a hundred Hushnock. Or a thousand. I killed them all. All Hushnock everywhere...
Are the lives of 10,000 colonists worth the lives of
30 billion? Is the destruction of an
entire species worth the love of one woman?
*********
I could finish it, but I have typed too much junk as it is. :laugh1: