Zeke or Kamara?

[zerofill]

Zeke isn't at fault right now. When your offense is as predictable as ours, and the defense really only needs to key on the run... How successful do we expect him to be?

 

[ArtClink]

Who would you rather have and why?

Lol. Its not even close. Kamara runs like a madman every play, giving his all. He destroys Zeke on pass catching skills, and he actually breaks tackles. No contest.

 

[DFWJC]

If the question is to use the 4th overall pick for Zeke or a 3rd rounder for Kamara....then its Kamara by a mile.
But straight up, even though Kamara is now clearly proven to be a 3 down back, Im taking Zeke

 

[Cowboysheelsreds053]

Right now, I'd say Kamara is the better back. But that doesn't mean Zeke isn't a better back.
Zeke can carry a 25-to-30 plus load. I don't know if Kamara can do that. But Kamara is smoother out of the backfield than Zeke and is better in the passing game.
It's like trying to say who would you rather have "Marshall Faulk or Emmitt Smith."
Faulk was better in the passing game, nifty in the running game, but Emmitt was a workhorse and rarely fumbled or made mistakes, and his endurance was second to none.

And ES was great like Walter Payton at picking up blitzers in the passing game.

 

[QuincyCarterEra]

Kamara would never

 

[Future]

Kamara would never

Would never get that volume of carries against difficult fronts.

You're right.

 

[QuincyCarterEra]

Would never get that volume of carries against difficult fronts.

You're right.

The loaded boxes fallacy has already been disproven, sorry bud

 

[Future]

The loaded boxes fallacy has already been disproven, sorry bud

Noooooooo it sure hasn't lol

 

[Future]

The loaded boxes fallacy has already been disproven, sorry bud

You're crazy if you think Zeke and Kara touch the ball with the same amount of space

 

[Verdict]

Who would you rather have and why?

Zeke. If Kamara was playing for this team he would be on IR already with a broken femur due to us running him straight into DTs the entire game. Plus Zeke has the Ewok head that open holes.

 

[Jake]

Imagine Zeke with Brees and Kamara with Prescott, then ask yourself if things would be different for both of them.

 

[CowboyRoy]

Zeke and it’s not even close.

If this was Zeke or Gurley it’d be a better debate.

Kamara and its not even close.

 

[Alohawg1]

Lol. Its not even close. Kamara runs like a madman every play, giving his all. He destroys Zeke on pass catching skills, and he actually breaks tackles. No contest.

Agreed, and if he was a Cowboy, nobody here would trade him for Zeke.

 

[CowboyRoy]

Imagine Zeke with Brees and Kamara with Prescott, then ask yourself if things would be different for both of them.

Imagine Kamara and Brees playing for Garrett with Beasley and Hurns as WR's with THIS Oline?

 

[Shinaoi]

Noooooooo it sure hasn't lol

 

[Shinaoi]

I mean I’m a zeke supporter. I don’t think he’s the problem, but the loaded box is a myth.

 

[mattjames2010]

You're crazy if you think Zeke and Kara touch the ball with the same amount of space

Drop the fanboy crap. Yes it has, it has been discussed often on here, the stats have been shown - go to the thread I made WEEKS ago about trading this overrated skill player.

I don't know why it's so tough for some of you to just admit you're wrong. It's odd.

 

[Future]

Which still doesn't account for the fact that the cowboys don't always run out of a sets with 7 blockers lol.

When they go s11 or even regular 11 and split a TE out, 7 men in the box is a disadvantage for the offense. This number is absolutely, unequivocally meaningless.

 

[Future]

Drop the fanboy crap. Yes it has, it has been discussed often on here, the stats have been shown - go to the thread I made WEEKS ago about trading this overrated skill player.

I don't know why it's so tough for some of you to just admit you're wrong. It's odd.

That thread sucked bc it was the same incomplete data just posted lmao

 

[mattjames2010]

Which still doesn't account for the fact that the cowboys don't always run out of a sets with 7 blockers lol.

When they go s11 or even regular 11 and split a TE out, 7 men in the box is a disadvantage for the offense. This number is absolutely, unequivocally meaningless.

This isn't a valid rebuttal. Backup your **** boy or ****.