What would have been the outcome if Jerry had retained Tom Landry?

rnr_honeybadger

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,417
Reaction score
17,298
Given the state of the Cowboys and the general doom and gloom in this place, I figured it might be a good idea to discuss some hypotheticals of what might have been.

Go back in time to when Jerry purchased the Cowboys. What would have been the outcome if he had retained Tom Landry and allowed Landry to rebuild the Cowboys. What would he have done differently? Would he have been as successful as Jimmy in creating a SB contender?
 

CouchCoach

Staff member
Messages
41,122
Reaction score
74,904
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I think if he doesn't hire Johnson and turn the actual football stuff over to him, Booger is selling the team just like Bright was forced to do inside of 4 years.

Tom Landry was a great HC in his time but his time was over, he was no longer innovative and Brandt and Schramm had fallen off their game as well. They had a great run and 20 winning seasons in a row was an astonishing accomplishment.
 

PAPPYDOG

There are no Dak haters just Cowboy lovers!!!
Messages
18,906
Reaction score
32,564
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Given the state of the Cowboys and the general doom and gloom in this place, I figured it might be a good idea to discuss some hypotheticals of what might have been.

Go back in time to when Jerry purchased the Cowboys. What would have been the outcome if he had retained Tom Landry and allowed Landry to rebuild the Cowboys. What would he have done differently? Would he have been as successful as Jimmy in creating a SB contender?

Landry was done his time to step down was evident.
Look like to call them as I see them so Jerry deserves credit for bringing in Jimmy and the Viking deal.
But then his ego spilled the milk and it's been laying on the table for 26 years and counting!
 

jsb357

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,570
Reaction score
7,281
Cowboys would be in the same boat as Miami. A team living off it's glory days in the 70's

A team living off it's glory days in the 90's...

sounds familiar

tenor.gif
 

Motorola

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,554
Reaction score
9,235
Cowboys would be in the same boat as Miami. A team living off it's glory days in the 70's
During the 90's the Dolphins were in the playoffs 7 times, then twice more for the 2000 and 2001 seasons. Five postseasons they bowed out in the divisional round. The one AFC championship appearance was the '92 postseason - losing to the Bills, who notched their 3rd consecutive AFC title and Super Bowl berth.
 

unionjack8

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,039
Reaction score
26,480
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Given the state of the Cowboys and the general doom and gloom in this place, I figured it might be a good idea to discuss some hypotheticals of what might have been.

Go back in time to when Jerry purchased the Cowboys. What would have been the outcome if he had retained Tom Landry and allowed Landry to rebuild the Cowboys. What would he have done differently? Would he have been as successful as Jimmy in creating a SB contender?
No more superbowls
 

CWR

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,652
Reaction score
34,382
I think if he doesn't hire Johnson and turn the actual football stuff over to him, Booger is selling the team just like Bright was forced to do inside of 4 years.

Tom Landry was a great HC in his time but his time was over, he was no longer innovative and Brandt and Schramm had fallen off their game as well. They had a great run and 20 winning seasons in a row was an astonishing accomplishment.

What a time to be alive.
 

rnr_honeybadger

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,417
Reaction score
17,298
Dunno, y'all think Landry couldn't have achieved anything more with Aikman, Emmit and Irvin? Or who knows what sort of team it would have been, maybe no Emmit or Aikman. Tough to tell but a football mind like Landry's
 

RonnieT24

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,551
Reaction score
21,630
Dunno, y'all think Landry couldn't have achieved anything more with Aikman, Emmit and Irvin? Or who knows what sort of team it would have been, maybe no Emmit or Aikman. Tough to tell but a football mind like Landry's

Landry was already on record that he was drafting Aikman. The difference is that he would not have drafted Emmitt because he would never have traded Herschel. It's often overlooked that Landry was putting together a pretty good roster of future pro-bowlers before he was canned.

Newton, Tuinei, Norton, Gogan, Herschel and Irvin were already in the fold. They were planning on adding Aikman to the mix in '89. Jimmy came in and ripped the bandages off when it came to aging veterans like Randy, Danny, Too-Tall etc. But I suspect Landry was going to do that too. Landry just would not have thrown Troy to the wolves the way Jimmy did and let him take that beating.. which in turn may have let Troy have a longer career. Jimmy turned the roster over quicker than Landry would have I think.. but I also think Landry was respectful enough not to pi$$ all over his boss unlike Jimmy. Of course with cancer taking him out not to long after it wasn't going to end well anyway..

I never bought into the notion that Landry had forgotten how to coach.. He had been too good for too long for me to buy that. Where the Cowboys failed in the 80's was talent evaluation. They missed on too many high picks .. Sherrard, Noonan, Cannon, "Hogenboom" as Landry liked to call him.. The list is long of guys who the Cowboys went in on but got little or nothing on the field.. Picking up the guys I mentioned above indicated that they might have been on the way to solving that.. Once you got him good players I think Landry would have done fine..
 

McKDaddy

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,344
Reaction score
8,594
Landry was my coach for the first decade & a half of my fandom but in those last several seasons even a teenager could see that the old guard was getting left behind. It wasn't handled well but they needed a new start. Folks would be complaining about 32 years of failure rather than 25.
 
Top