The problem with dak is his performance ( other than some empty stats in many games) , is actually regressing from his initial years. Brees and Manning , kept ascending . This is the worry with Dak . Even when the OL and Zeke were humming , we still lost way too many on his watch . There is something in his game that is inconsistent.
Not true. Manning's QBR and PR were declining in his 4th and 5th seasons, and he was throwing a boatload of INT's. Brees regressed in his 5th season.
Even so, is Dak's performance regressing, or is the team's performance regressing? It isn't automatically the same thing.
By any measure other than team wins Dak was performing at an extremely high level when he got hurt. His QBR and PR were high, and he was the primary reason the team was competitive despite an awful defense. The only problem with the offense turnovers - mostly fumbles early in the game.
The culprit on the team failure was a defense giving up an average of 36 points per game in the games Dak played in. Manning and Brees would also find it a bit difficult to overcome that.