You know, when my forum account flags 2 likes and 23 quotes, it kind of makes me feel like there isn't a whole lot of agreement, which is fine. I didn't expect a whole lot of agreement. As a matter of fact, i don't agree with the move....about 98% of me.
The reasons are legitimate. The Cowboy have so many needs on defense. However, we seem to be having to talk ourselves into taking two, maybe three possible choices. That seems kind of weak to me. At #10 there should be at least a half dozen exciting choices. Where are the DT's. considering the run defense, a big blue chip DT should be there at #10 but I don't see one in this round, actually.
Also, according to the experts I'm reading, this draft is heavy in DB's in rounds 2-3. Is taking a CB with the #10 pick really that critical? Most believe the top defensive prospects will be gone.
There is definitely some talent in the top ten at OT and I believe the Cowboys will need some help at that position, I don't feel at all confident in the health of either starter. there is also some really good WR's, but been there, done that.
I would put as much as 70% confidence that the Cowboys are going to trade down, They may have already targeted someone that they can get at a lower position in the 1st round. However, what if they can't find a trade partner willing to meat Jerry's demands? Is there going to be an almost "can't miss" player out there?
The best argument for not taking the QB to me is the salary. If we are talking about 10 million a year for a rookie, then forget it. I didn't realize the rookie cap went that high after the top 5. I was figuring on about 3 mill a year and i think now i am wrong on that figure.
I haven't looked into your quotes yet, so this should be interesting although it's probably not going to increase my self confidence.