Football Outsiders NFL Tier List. Dak B+, mostly positive responses

[G2]

It's fantasy.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

If that's the case then how come they don't have all of the backup QB's in the list. Where's Ben DeNucci?

That's your blind hatred of Dak making you over look the obvious again.

I have no issue with the rankings at all.

I just think when you have 2 QBs for some teams and 3 for the Panthers all lumped in together it looks like it's offensive rankings as opposed to QBs rankings.

 

[Motorola]

No, but at least the same level. Dak should be between C+ and B-.

I wonder if this poll is by team and not by the player. Why else would you have all 3 QB's for Carolina ranked the same? Both QB's for Wash, the Titans, and the Saints?

These are clearly offensive rankings disguised as QB rankings.

Tannehill and the rookie Willis both C+? No. The Titans offense is C+.

All 3 of the Panthers QBs on the same teir? Come on now.

Or one could surmise that the 'Football Outsiders' guys aren't sure who will be the starting QB come opening day for a number of teams - hence having photos of both /all players on the roster shown for those squads.

Doing that way, though essentially invalidates their "tier" ranking exercise.
At the very least - it calls into question what are they doing.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Or one could surmise that the 'Football Outsiders' guys aren't sure who will be the starting QB will be come opening day for a number of teams - hence having photos of both /all players on the roster shown for those squads.
Doing that way, though invalidates \ calls into question their "tier" ranking exercise, IMO.

I highly doubt there's a QB controversy in Tennessee. There has been zero talk of that.

I also highly doubt the Panthers aren't going to start the QB they just traded for.

Also New Orleans having 2 QBs on there? Jamies was playing great and the Saints were like 5-1 before he got hurt last year.

I agree with your last statement. Doing it that way invalidates things. It's either QB rankings or not. It can't be some kind of hybrid system disguised as QB rankings.

 

[phildadon86]

I highly doubt there's a QB controversy in Tennessee. There has been zero talk of that.

I also highly doubt the Panthers aren't going to start the QB they just traded for.

Also New Orleans having 2 QBs on there? Jamies was playing great and the Saints were like 5-1 before he got hurt last year.

I agree with your last statement. Doing it that way invalidates things. It's either QB rankings or not. It can't be some kind of hybrid system disguised as QB rankings.

No. It’s QB rankings. The reason for having multiple quarterbacks for one team is because they don’t know the starter yet. Not hard to figure out. Unless you’re trying to discredit the list. You love lists that serve you though. Lol

what’s wrong? Don’t like the list and trying to invalidate it? Go figure. Like I said. You’re a hypocrite

 

[phildadon86]

I have no issue with the rankings at all.

I just think when you have 2 QBs for some teams and 3 for the Panthers all lumped in together it looks like it's offensive rankings as opposed to QBs rankings.

And yea you have issues with the rankings. No way do you believe these rankings when last week you were going on about Dak not being in the top 10 lol. Just stop already.

 

[acr731]

The haterade blinds some folks.

You know this from your vast experience of being that same person.....

 

[acr731]

Just another opportunity for the Dak haters to toss flames.

So everyone should accept the countless Dak propping threads and have no permission to offer opinions, do I have this right? Only positive comments are allowed?

This is exactly how Germany was during WW2. You better worship you-know-who. If you don't, or are brave enough to criticize or speak out against him, you find yourself lined up against a wall.

 

[America's Cowboy]

You know this from your vast experience of being the same person.....

Nah, all of you Romoholics would gang up like street thugs on anyone who would say anything obvious and critical of Romo...begging the mods to ban any critically speaking posters. Big difference than here.

 

[Nav22]

Dak on the same level as the 2 QB's who just played in the super bowl?

Crack is bad for the brain.........

Just wait until NFL players, coaches and execs have their say.

Will they be “on crack” too?

I look forward to you and your ilk furrowing your brows in a vain attempt at understanding football.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

And yea you have issues with the rankings. No way do you believe these rankings when last week you were going on about Dak not being in the top 10 lol. Just stop already.

Dak isn't top 10 in my rankings.

Where these 3 rank the Cowboys offense doesn't change that for me.

Dak has to change that, not these guys.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

No. It’s QB rankings. The reason for having multiple quarterbacks for one team is because they don’t know the starter yet. Not hard to figure out. Unless you’re trying to discredit the list. You love lists that serve you though. Lol

what’s wrong? Don’t like the list and trying to invalidate it? Go figure. Like I said. You’re a hypocrite

Lists are fun.

I just think the way they did it was stupid by lumping QBs from the same team in together at the same grade.

 

[acr731]

Just wait until NFL players, coaches and execs have their say.

Will they be “on crack” too?

I look forward to you and your ilk furrowing your brows in a vain attempt at understanding football.

Speaking out against Dak means you don't understand football. Interesting....

Nah, all of you Romoholics would gang up like street thugs on anyone who would say anything obvious and critical of Romo...begging the mods to ban any critically speaking posters. Big difference than here.

Speaking out against Dak makes you a Romoholic. Also interesting...

 

[Hawkeye0202]

 

[Flamma]

I'm dropping Dak to B
Dropping Lamar to C+
Raising Burrow to A

 

[PAPPYDOG]

Basically the same tier as Wilson, Stafford, Jackson, and Burrow.

https://www.footballoutsiders.com/podcasts/2022/2022-nfl-quarterbacks-tier-list

Just ran out of toilet paper...the above should help!!!

 

[JBS]

These are clearly offensive rankings disguised as QB rankings.

Tannehill and the rookie Willis both C+? No. The Titans offense is C+.

All 3 of the Panthers QBs on the same teir? Come on now.

it’s not all 3 of them on the same tier..it’s all of them combined are on that tier

 

[KJJ]

So everyone should accept the countless Dak propping threads and have no permission to offer opinions, do I have this right? Only positive comments are allowed?

This is exactly how Germany was during WW2. You better worship you-know-who. If you don't, or are brave enough to criticize or speak out against him, you find yourself lined up against a wall.

The Dak propping threads have been far fewer than the Dak bashing threads and the propping threads turn into bashing threads. You can’t even start a positive thread about him without many turning it into a something negative.

 

[CowboyRoy]

Basically the same tier as Wilson, Stafford, Jackson, and Burrow.

https://www.footballoutsiders.com/podcasts/2022/2022-nfl-quarterbacks-tier-list

Hebert gets way too much love for what he has done. But yah, thats a good list. And I like how the first tier. Definitely top 3 there.

 

[CowboyRoy]

Dak on the same level as the 2 QB's who just played in the super bowl?

Crack is bad for the brain.........

That comment right there just shows how much you dont understand football or QB play.

You dont understand the different between team success and QB abilities.

If the Stafford winning a SB didnt teach you anything about QB play, you are hopless.