Is Dak only a Tier 2 QB?

[Diehardblues]

You think I dont know what goes on in this house?
Do you believe that you have to educate everyone in this forum on what everyone is posting.
I guess I have been around too long to understand how to make up my own mind, my own opinions.
I respect your opinions as well BTW.

I’m anything but a Dak Homer. I’ve often been a critic but I also recognize and am more in the middle as most Cowboy fans are.

I’ve chosen to place myself out there to take on these handful of extreme Dak trolls who are attempting to take over the narrative on Dak which didn’t represent our fanbase or this forum.

Once I had this one Dak troll inadvertently admit he was and begun hiding his personal info when questioned about I suspected was a rival fan posing as a Cowboy fan strictly here to troll Cowboy fans about their QB.

It’s time to clean this forum up. Everyone is fed up with the rhetoric . Most can’t even participate in discussions . And I’m just the guy to take it on.

 

[CouchCoach]

Well said . And my agenda is the Dak trolls . They can’t stand it.

There it is. All these Dak threads started by you are trolling by the mere definition.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

There it is. All these Dak threads started by you are trolling by the mere definition.

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

Watson hasnt played in a year and wont play for another. There is no way Lamar Jackson is a better QB. Wilson is past his prime.

Dak is top 10, which is 2nd tier.

33 is now past their prime for QBs?

 

[PAPPYDOG]

Dak trolls are a few select members who basically are attacking Dak and holding him almost solely responsible for our lack of success. And they are in every Dak thread trolling Dak supporters .

Most fans are more in the middle and see his assets and liabilities.

The Dak homers and haters are a problem too but they aren’t continually starting Dak threads . This effort isn’t intended or directed at them . They aren’t trying to take over every Dak thread and general narrative .

Anyway, this is why I’ve begun my charade of Dak threads to deter and take on these Dak trolls . One of which inadvertently admitted he was trolling Cowboy fans about Dak. And is most likely a rival fan posing as a Cowboy fan. The other is our most noted Dak troll. There’s a couple others.

They can’t stand these more positive threads about Dak. With the season upon us the forum will be under more strict scrutiny and will merge and limit these Dak threads which really need their own forum or place for all to be dumped since it’s become so difficult to have normal adult discussions on our QB.

But that’s the last thing these Dak trolls want.

Only Dak can shut up the critics and doubters by winning vs playoff teams and he simply doesn't have the gusto/talent for it.
Nevertheless, he is a Tier 1 QB (Probably the best in the NFL currently) and the haters are jealous of his extensive talent base.
Now, so what if he can only beat non-playoff teams....really now how petty to demand more than 25 wins vs the NFC East!

Now don't listen to the haters and keep posting daily on the greatness of Dak!!!

 

[Typhus]

I’m anything but a Dak Homer. I’ve often been a critic but I also recognize and am more in the middle as most Cowboy fans are.

I’ve chosen to place myself out there to take on these handful of extreme Dak trolls who are attempting to take over the narrative on Dak which didn’t represent our fanbase or this forum.

Once I had this one Dak troll inadvertently admit he was and begun hiding his personal info when questioned about I suspected was a rival fan posing as a Cowboy fan strictly here to troll Cowboy fans about their QB.

You are on the polar opposite, so lets not kid around, lets be adults and tell the truth.
I respect both sides, and Im not hiding, everyone knows my opinion on Dak, but Im also a realist and optimist and hope for the best.
You keep being you and @MountaineerCowboy keep it up to... I bet both of your typing skills will be world class.

 

[Diehardblues]

You are on the polar opposite, so lets not kid around, lets be adults and tell the truth.
I respect both sides, and Im not hiding, everyone knows my opinion on Dak, but Im also a realist and optimist and hope for the best.
You keep being you and @MountaineerCowboy keep it up to... I bet both of your typing skills will be world class.

We really don’t need rival fans in here trolling Cowboy fans . If we do then this isn’t the Cowboys fan forum I thought it was . Nor want to be a part of .

 

[Typhus]

We really don’t need rival fans in here trolling Cowboy fans . If we do then this isn’t the Cowboys fan forum I thought it was . Nor want to be a part of .

Those peeps are easily identifiable, but I do not speak for everyone, so if your crusade is to educate green posters that might not know better, than I applaud your efforts.
I dont see you exposing one side or the other, its rather polar and obvious, but I enjoy your posts as well.

 

[Diehardblues]

Only Dak can shut up the critics and doubters by winning vs playoff teams and he simply doesn't have the gusto/talent for it.
Nevertheless, he is a Tier 1 QB (Probably the best in the NFL currently) and the haters are jealous of his extensive talent base.
Now, so what if he can only beat non-playoff teams....really now how petty to demand more than 25 wins vs the NFC East!

Now don't listen to the haters and keep posting daily on the greatness of Dak!!!

Holding our QB solely responsible for his franchises lack of success is pure troll driven .

Only trolls like Stephen A and Horseface present such garbage . And a handful of trolls here .

It’s the same crap we had with Romo. It’s so ridiculous it needs its own play pen. It simply doesn’t become adult discussion .

 

[Diehardblues]

Those peeps are easily identifiable, but I do not speak for everyone, so if your crusade is to educate green posters that might not know better, than I applaud your efforts.
I dont see you exposing one side or the other, its rather polar and obvious, but I enjoy your posts as well.

I knew the window would be closing once the season begun . And was so fed up with the Dak trolls narrative dominating the airwaves . It was time someone took them on. Most everyone is fed up with it.

If they are so easily detected why are fans feeding them?

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

I knew the window would be closing once the season begun . And was so fed up with the Dak trolls narrative dominating the airwaves . It was time someone took them on. Most everyone is fed up with it.

You're such a hero, bro.

 

[CowboyRoy]

Wilson had some good receivers in Seattle, but he might be upgraded in Denver.
Was a great signing by the Donks, he will have a comfortable offense, a lateral spread that fits his game perfectly.
Good FO in Donky land.

Love Wilson, and 4 years ago I take Wilson. I like him in Denver.

 

[PAPPYDOG]

Holding our QB solely responsible for his franchises lack of success is pure troll driven .

Only trolls like Stephen A and Horseface present such garbage . And a handful of trolls here .

It’s the same crap we had with Romo. It’s so ridiculous it needs its own play pen. It simply doesn’t become adult discussion .

We have 160million (20% of our Cap) reasons to point the finger at Dak our leader.
Unless we have a new leader who handles the ball more and makes more cap dollars than Dak?
So my sweet frustrated buttercup which is it?

 

[Typhus]

I knew the window would be closing once the season begun . And was so fed up with the Dak trolls narrative dominating the airwaves . It was time someone took them on. Most everyone is fed up with it.

Dak doesnt totally suck, but he will never be Tom Brady.
Why is it so polarizing to so many that he is just a decent starting NFL QB in this league.

 

[KJJ]

All Justin Herbert has done so far is put up numbers. No playoff appearances in his first two seasons and has a losing QB record. Dak has a win over him. Don’t know how Herbert would be ahead of Stafford after last season. These QB rankings and tiers make no sense.

 

[Typhus]

We have 160million (20% of our Cap) reasons to point the finger at Dak our leader.
Unless we have a new leader who handles the ball more and makes more cap dollars than Dak?
So my sweet frustrated buttercup which is it?

The cap is not the problem Pappy.

 

[Diehardblues]

Dak doesnt totally suck, but he will never be Tom Brady.
Why is it so polarizing to so many that he is just a decent starting NFL QB in this league.

This is what trolls do. They rile up the neighborhood for their own entertainment.

 

[PAPPYDOG]

The cap is not the problem Pappy.

When 20% of it is invested in a Lemon........well its a major PROBLEM!!!

 

[Diehardblues]

We have 160million (20% of our Cap) reasons to point the finger at Dak our leader.
Unless we have a new leader who handles the ball more and makes more cap dollars than Dak?
So my sweet frustrated buttercup which is it?

There is so many contributing factors to the Cowboys lack of success this era which begin long before Dak arrived.

Obviously you don’t have the ability to look beyond our QB. You must think he is out there with 10 caddies. Lol

 

[john van brocklin]

With Dallas Cowboys training camp practices on the horizon, eyes will be on the field for the first time in a while. The person that will likely be the center of attention is the face of the franchise, quarterback Dak Prescott.

Prescott is to many a highly regarded talent in the league, but according to a survey by The Athletic of 50 coaches and executives across the NFL, Prescott is a Tier 2 quarterback. In fact, he comes in just outside of the top 10 at No. 11.

Tier 1:
1. Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay Packers (1.00 Voting Average)
2. Patrick Mahomes, Kansas City Chiefs (1.02)
3. Tom Brady, Tampa Bay Buccaneers (1.16)
4. Josh Allen, Buffalo Bills (1.22)
5. Justin Herbert, Los Angeles Chargers (1.28)
6. Joe Burrow, Cincinnati Bengals (1.34)
Tier 2:
7. Matthew Stafford, Los Angeles Rams (1.68)
8. Russell Wilson, Denver Broncos (1.72)
9. Deshaun Watson, Cleveland Browns (1.88)
10. Lamar Jackson, Baltimore Ravens (2.00)
11. Dak Prescott, Dallas Cowboys (2.10)
12. Derek Carr, Las Vegas Raiders (2.10)
13. Kyler Murray, Arizona Cardinals (2.32)
14. Matt Ryan, Indianapolis Colts (2.46)

https://www.si.com/nfl/cowboys/news/dallas-rumor-update-quarterback-dak-prescott-training-camp

I believe this is a fair ranking for Dak.
If he wants to move up in the rankings he needs to be more consistent.