Can Jonathan Mingo finally develop into a reliable fourth option for the Cowboys?

He's not reliable as a WR, and he went from being an elite return specialist to a jag overnight. He couldn't even get the fair catch right.

If he can't get back to being a good returner, there's no reason for him to even be on the team. IMO, if he doesn't show that he can get back to the weapon he was in 2024, he won't make the roster.
One would think that after all these years watching football I would know the difference. I'm not saying he's a great WR—i don't think he's even a #3 but I do think he's a really good #4, and I don't buy that he "needs to focus on just returning", not when he put up the numbers he did in '24 both as a WR and RS. I know you didn't say that and I think we're at least somewhat in agreement.
 
One would think that after all these years watching football I would know the difference. I'm not saying he's a great WR—i don't think he's even a #3 but I do think he's a really good #4, and I don't buy that he "needs to focus on just returning", not when he put up the numbers he did in '24 both as a WR and RS. I know you didn't say that and I think we're at least somewhat in agreement.
Why? He's never shown anything in the NFL.
 
The whole league is playing checkers while Jerry is playing bingo with Mingo.
 
No, WR doesn't normally take this long. And you shouldn't slow down Flournoy's development on sunk cost fallacy.
 
He was a second rounder not bad but then he had shaky QB play his Jets career

Yeah, and I remember wanting us to draft him. I completely forgot about him though lol. We should have nice depth between him, Lamb, Flournoy, Pickens, and MVS (Turpin is his own category to me lol).
 
It's hard to tell who is number 5 after Lamb,Pickens, Ferguson and Fluornoy.

Ferguson will steal some or most of Fluornoys targets at #3 actually, so there's that too.

Yeah, it would most likely take injury in order for him to get any targets over the above mentioned group.
And then you don't know if his camp/practice session performances will be superior to those other depth piece wide receivers.

Probably cut or practice squad at best imo.
 
If Mingo had shown real hopes for seeing more action, we'd know by now. But he surely hasn't. I do suspect there's a valid reason for confidence in him being as wanting as it is. I think the main reason why he's still on this team is that Jerry is simply reluctant to admit his bad judgment. It's obvious.
 
Last edited:
I don’t think he has much of a chance at all.

Here are our tiers, with nods to classic 80’s fantasy/sf movies

“We are the saviors of the universe”
  • Pickens - Big physical downfield contested ball
  • Lamb - Big, versatile YAC
  • Fluornoy - Physical fast contested ball
“Three receivers enter, one receiver cut“
  • Kavontae Turpin - Fast versatile elusive gadget - pretty much a lock due to special teams and the go go gadget aspect.
  • Marquez Valdes-Scantling - Big fast vertical - his speed and downfield threat factor as well as the fact they went after him in the off season gives him the edge. Early word from OTAs and minicamp were also positive.
  • Johnathan Mingo - Big physical possession (womp, womp, sad trombone)

“There can be only one (or none)
  • Traeshon Holden - Big physical possession
  • Camden Brown - Big physical red zone and contested ball
  • Jordan Hudson - Big physical possession
  • Denzel Mims - Big fast vertical
  • Tyler Johnson - Physical possession

Mingo absolutely must beat out Holden, Brown, Hudson and Johnson or he’s - hundred percent gone. They are similar enough to him that the better performer stays That entire final group are all headed to the practice squad or free agency unless the team goes with a sixth receiver or there is an injury.

Holden probably has the edge for a sixth spot unless one of the others balls out. He also seems to have some chemistry with Dak.

For what it’s worth, Mingo’s “plus” side is that he’s really big and is a willing blocker. He’ll also play special teams

If he beats out those guys, he still has to beat out either Scantling or Turpin which, as mentioned is an extreme long shot

@Stash I’m afraid your man Mims is likely a goner. He didn’t even play very well in the UFL. He’s also too similar to Scantling and Mingo but with even less accomplishment than Mingo. He looks like he was added as insurance.


I would put Anthony Smith in this list ahead of a few others . Anytime you burn a draft pick on a guy he’s going to get a look at in Camp with the thought of at least stashing him PS at least a year .
 
I would put Anthony Smith in this list ahead of a few others . Anytime you burn a draft pick on a guy he’s going to get a look at in Camp with the thought of at least stashing him PS at least a year .
I’m sure he’ll make the practice squad. I’m pulling for him to make the 53.

I just wish he wasn’t already 24.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
474,529
Messages
14,543,250
Members
24,212
Latest member
JerryJonesSupporter
Back
Top