Dak is a greater QB than Aikman?

Rayman70 said:
I guess the era's make the comp kinda impossible. Just like we can't compare Roger to Aikman or Dak. Roger is probably more impressive because he played at a high level during a time when the league was much more run heavy and defenses were allowed to brutalize the QB.
Click to expand...
You could still brutalize QBs a lot more when Troy played than now. Heaven forbid you even land on a QB now or graze his helmet
 
Rayman70 said:
I guess the era's make the comp kinda impossible. Just like we can't compare Roger to Aikman or Dak. Roger is probably more impressive because he played at a high level during a time when the league was much more run heavy and defenses were allowed to brutalize the QB.
Click to expand...
It is ridiculous and that's why my answer is no answer there is no answer to this I don't think anybody really believes that Prescott or Romo are better than Troy or Roger but what we do know and I believe this from the bottom of my heart you put Romo or Prescott on those teams and they still win I don't think that those changes would hurt the team it's like Matthew Stafford and Sam Darnold being put on super teams and winning no different than Trent Dilfer Brad Johnson and Jim Mcmahon and other players like him can win Super Bowls so could Prescott and Romo on the proper teams and those were proper teams.

We call those super teams for a reason They were all in before the turn was ever coined they were built to win in the playoffs the Cowboys have not been that for a long long time and that is why it's an unfair comp because I believe if you put Romo or Prescott on those teams and that's the only change you made in all the scenarios that happened for all of them would have been the same if it unfolded the same way they do not hurt that team they are better then Danny whitee,

That I know of for sure I mean what'd he play in 3NFC championship games and couldn't get it done he could they couldn't get it done because of him I don't care what you want to say about number 11 he was a disaster when you have an upside down interception to touchdown ratio see I had to flip it it's hard to say backwards he had far more mistakes and interceptions in those games in the playoffs then you will ever see from a player playing in that many championship games and somehow he got credit for being there no if you put Romo or Prescott on those teams they win one of those and they go to the Super Bowl I believe that I do believe that that's the only question that should be here if you put them on better teams like we've seen these other guys yes the answer is yes that is why Denver went out and got Peyton Manning he wasn't even a near shell of his old self and they went out and got a ring I believe if you would put Romo or Prescott on that team they'd do the same Look at the teams and how they were assembled They are called super teams for a reason..

So yes I believe Prescott or Romo could win a Super Bowl on the proper team on a real team not that teams that you say had enough All pros and Pro Bowlers or really good players on it during the regular season those players folded under pressure made him look bad But if he'd been lucky enough like Matthew Stafford was to get on the Rams team that he led the league in interceptions and had two interceptions in the Super Bowl and they wiped it under the floor like it never happened That I can tell you a hard Yes romo or Prescott could have also won the Super Bowl on that team..

I mean how do you think guy like Blake Bortles or even worse Mark Sanchez twice went to an AFC championship game just like Danny White but they were the reasons they didn't get further They were supposed to just not mess it up but you put Romo or Prescott on those teams I believe they could win a Super Bowl on those teams The Cowboys have yet to assemble a playoff caliber team that you could call a super team yes they have had great talent sprinkled in all over the place they were very top heavy but those players did not show up in the playoffs including guys like Tyler Smith and Tyron Smith and Frederick and Martin and and Zeke and all these guys they just didn't play well in the playoffs.
 
blueblood70 said:
It is ridiculous and that's why my answer is no answer there is no answer to this I don't think anybody really believes that Prescott or Romo are better than Troy or Roger but what we do know and I believe this from the bottom of my heart you put Romo or Prescott on those teams and they still win I don't think that those changes would hurt the team it's like Matthew Stafford and Sam Darnold being put on super teams and winning no different than Trent Dilfer Brad Johnson and Jim Mcmahon and other players like him can win Super Bowls so could Prescott and Romo on the proper teams and those were proper teams.

We call those super teams for a reason They were all in before the turn was ever coined they were built to win in the playoffs the Cowboys have not been that for a long long time and that is why it's an unfair comp because I believe if you put Romo or Prescott on those teams and that's the only change you made in all the scenarios that happened for all of them would have been the same if it unfolded the same way they do not hurt that team they are better then Danny whitee,

That I know of for sure I mean what'd he play in 3NFC championship games and couldn't get it done he could they couldn't get it done because of him I don't care what you want to say about number 11 he was a disaster when you have an upside down interception to touchdown ratio see I had to flip it it's hard to say backwards he had far more mistakes and interceptions in those games in the playoffs then you will ever see from a player playing in that many championship games and somehow he got credit for being there no if you put Romo or Prescott on those teams they win one of those and they go to the Super Bowl I believe that I do believe that that's the only question that should be here if you put them on better teams like we've seen these other guys yes the answer is yes that is why Denver went out and got Peyton Manning he wasn't even a near shell of his old self and they went out and got a ring I believe if you would put Romo or Prescott on that team they'd do the same Look at the teams and how they were assembled They are called super teams for a reason..

So yes I believe Prescott or Romo could win a Super Bowl on the proper team on a real team not that teams that you say had enough All pros and Pro Bowlers or really good players on it during the regular season those players folded under pressure made him look bad But if he'd been lucky enough like Matthew Stafford was to get on the Rams team that he led the league in interceptions and had two interceptions in the Super Bowl and they wiped it under the floor like it never happened That I can tell you a hard Yes romo or Prescott could have also won the Super Bowl on that team..

I mean how do you think guy like Blake Bortles or even worse Mark Sanchez twice went to an AFC championship game just like Danny White but they were the reasons they didn't get further They were supposed to just not mess it up but you put Romo or Prescott on those teams I believe they could win a Super Bowl on those teams The Cowboys have yet to assemble a playoff caliber team that you could call a super team yes they have had great talent sprinkled in all over the place they were very top heavy but those players did not show up in the playoffs including guys like Tyler Smith and Tyron Smith and Frederick and Martin and and Zeke and all these guys they just didn't play well in the playoffs.
Click to expand...
If Dak would have been on those 90s teams, hopefully he would hand the ball to # 22 inside the 5 yard line instead of audibling to a pass play every down.
 
StuckMojo said:
If Dak would have been on those 90s teams, hopefully he would hand the ball to # 22 inside the 5 yard line instead of audibling to a pass play every down.
Click to expand...
He does not audible he has an option but you can stay stick that narrative where all the other false narratives go about Prescott That's not true at all He does not avoid the runs he looks at the defense like you don't know how to read and sees that they're playing the run and maybe they have an opportunity with two of the best receivers in football to throw the football But if the Cowboys wanted to run all they need to do is call an absolute run play only then why give him the option again it goes to coaching Prescott problem was he listened to the coaches and he should have just go with his gut and he should have maybe held onto the ball 1 second more when Pickens finally got open but yeah I don't want to hear the nonsense because that's all Troy did his hand the ball off and occasionally threw it so if you want to go there we can go there the guy never had to carry anything except his own gear I mean he literally had a super team I don't want to hear the excuses because he had one of the best offensive lines and run games and defenses and coaching Staffs in football the same with Roger that is why you keep running because you had the run game to support it Show me where this team has showed anything in the run game where the quarterback should stick to it all the time show me that run game in the playoffs it wasn't there the offensive line wasn't opening holes you know all those playoff games that they lost you know what the one constant was There was no run game there was number physicality up front we lost in the trenches on both sides of the football it was under 3 yards per carry in the playoffs all those losses that's the common denominator and you want your quarterback to feel really good and confident in his run game when there isn't that kind of run game here of course with Emmett Smith and that offensive line he would hand it off gladly He would gladly love for him to trust the offensive line in the run game that it could get in from the 5 yard line but we've seen it in the past we got a penalty you know that's why they passed right because Schoonmaker's motion you know he moved before the snap moved him back It changed the way you call plays but go ahead keep saying things that I can easily neutralize with common sense I saw what I saw Troy and Roger never had to carry the team and of course they handed the ball off to the Tony Dorsett and Emmett Smith we don't have those guys on this team we definitely don't have the offensive line I don't care how good the offensive line was at times in the regular season for Romo and Dak when it mattered most they got manhandled in the playoffs that's why we lost that's why the offense was one dimensional and that's why they were forced to pass because they couldn't run the ball at all under three yards CARRY pitiful..
.
 
Rayman70 said:
I guess the era's make the comp kinda impossible. Just like we can't compare Roger to Aikman or Dak. Roger is probably more impressive because he played at a high level during a time when the league was much more run heavy and defenses were allowed to brutalize the QB.
Click to expand...
The league was still brutalizing QBs in Troys time as well. Maybe not quite as bad, but still bad
 
blueblood70 said:
He does not audible he has an option but you can stay stick that narrative where all the other false narratives go about Prescott That's not true at all He does not avoid the runs he looks at the defense like you don't know how to read and sees that they're playing the run and maybe they have an opportunity with two of the best receivers in football to throw the football But if the Cowboys wanted to run all they need to do is call an absolute run play only then why give him the option again it goes to coaching Prescott problem was he listened to the coaches and he should have just go with his gut and he should have maybe held onto the ball 1 second more when Pickens finally got open but yeah I don't want to hear the nonsense because that's all Troy did his hand the ball off and occasionally threw it so if you want to go there we can go there the guy never had to carry anything except his own gear I mean he literally had a super team I don't want to hear the excuses because he had one of the best offensive lines and run games and defenses and coaching Staffs in football the same with Roger that is why you keep running because you had the run game to support it Show me where this team has showed anything in the run game where the quarterback should stick to it all the time show me that run game in the playoffs it wasn't there the offensive line wasn't opening holes you know all those playoff games that they lost you know what the one constant was There was no run game there was number physicality up front we lost in the trenches on both sides of the football it was under 3 yards per carry in the playoffs all those losses that's the common denominator and you want your quarterback to feel really good and confident in his run game when there isn't that kind of run game here of course with Emmett Smith and that offensive line he would hand it off gladly He would gladly love for him to trust the offensive line in the run game that it could get in from the 5 yard line but we've seen it in the past we got a penalty you know that's why they passed right because Schoonmaker's motion you know he moved before the snap moved him back It changed the way you call plays but go ahead keep saying things that I can easily neutralize with common sense I saw what I saw Troy and Roger never had to carry the team and of course they handed the ball off to the Tony Dorsett and Emmett Smith we don't have those guys on this team we definitely don't have the offensive line I don't care how good the offensive line was at times in the regular season for Romo and Dak when it mattered most they got manhandled in the playoffs that's why we lost that's why the offense was one dimensional and that's why they were forced to pass because they couldn't run the ball at all under three yards CARRY pitiful..
.
Click to expand...
Option/audible…same thing. Run game working like a charm on 1st drive… first and goal at the 5 yard line we have a 4 yard run to the 1 yard line, then incomplete pass, then Dak takes a 9 yard sack.
 
StuckMojo said:
Option/audible…same thing. Run game working like a charm on 1st drive… first and goal at the 5 yard line we have a 4 yard run to the 1 yard line, then incomplete pass, then Dak takes a 9 yard sack.
Click to expand...
Yeah last I checked you didn't read the defense they had it probably stacked up if he did audible which you're assuming he did is because he's seen the fact that they were reading the run and they had something open but it didn't work guess what somebody needs to go back 'cause if it's the play I remember as soon as they snap the ball a dude ran right in the there was a gap and no blocking again and we're blaming the quarterback because the play didn't get blocked up yeah that's what we do around here don't blame the offensive line and the fact that the play could have worked but didn't because of the offensive line..

You mean the sack that happened like in a millisecond when nobody blocked the inside guy no there's no excuse other than the play didn't work because of the offensive line shall we go there with the rest of the team that's no case in point you picked out one play in the whole game they scored 31 points is that what we're going to keep doing excusing the defect for 34 points you're another one bye bye
 
blueblood70 said:
Yeah last I checked you didn't read the defense they had it probably stacked up if he did audible which you're assuming he did is because he's seen the fact that they were reading the run and they had something open but it didn't work guess what somebody needs to go back 'cause if it's the play I remember as soon as they snap the ball a dude ran right in the there was a gap and no blocking again and we're blaming the quarterback because the play didn't get blocked up yeah that's what we do around here don't blame the offensive line and the fact that the play could have worked but didn't because of the offensive line..

You mean the sack that happened like in a millisecond when nobody blocked the inside guy no there's no excuse other than the play didn't work because of the offensive line shall we go there with the rest of the team that's no case in point you picked out one play in the whole game they scored 31 points is that what we're going to keep doing excusing the defect for 34 points you're another one bye bye
Click to expand...
Last I checked you do not know how to use punctuation!
 
blueblood70 said:
Oh great comeback grammar spelling sentence structure that's all you got because you're wrong!! Nice try
Click to expand...
Come back to what? Your defense of Dak? Nothing’s going to change my opinion on the poorly chosen “options”by our head coach and QB in some of this goal line situations. We are giving away points that we should be scoring and with this defense, we need all the points we can get.
 
blueblood70 said:
He does not audible he has an option but you can stay stick that narrative where all the other false narratives go about Prescott That's not true at all He does not avoid the runs he looks at the defense like you don't know how to read and sees that they're playing the run and maybe they have an opportunity with two of the best receivers in football to throw the football But if the Cowboys wanted to run all they need to do is call an absolute run play only then why give him the option again it goes to coaching Prescott problem was he listened to the coaches and he should have just go with his gut and he should have maybe held onto the ball 1 second more when Pickens finally got open but yeah I don't want to hear the nonsense because that's all Troy did his hand the ball off and occasionally threw it so if you want to go there we can go there the guy never had to carry anything except his own gear I mean he literally had a super team I don't want to hear the excuses because he had one of the best offensive lines and run games and defenses and coaching Staffs in football the same with Roger that is why you keep running because you had the run game to support it Show me where this team has showed anything in the run game where the quarterback should stick to it all the time show me that run game in the playoffs it wasn't there the offensive line wasn't opening holes you know all those playoff games that they lost you know what the one constant was There was no run game there was number physicality up front we lost in the trenches on both sides of the football it was under 3 yards per carry in the playoffs all those losses that's the common denominator and you want your quarterback to feel really good and confident in his run game when there isn't that kind of run game here of course with Emmett Smith and that offensive line he would hand it off gladly He would gladly love for him to trust the offensive line in the run game that it could get in from the 5 yard line but we've seen it in the past we got a penalty you know that's why they passed right because Schoonmaker's motion you know he moved before the snap moved him back It changed the way you call plays but go ahead keep saying things that I can easily neutralize with common sense I saw what I saw Troy and Roger never had to carry the team and of course they handed the ball off to the Tony Dorsett and Emmett Smith we don't have those guys on this team we definitely don't have the offensive line I don't care how good the offensive line was at times in the regular season for Romo and Dak when it mattered most they got manhandled in the playoffs that's why we lost that's why the offense was one dimensional and that's why they were forced to pass because they couldn't run the ball at all under three yards CARRY pitiful..
.
Click to expand...
You know, if you stare at this post for awhile, I think you can see a spaceship going around Mars with lighting in the background!
 
5Stars said:
You know, if you stare at this post for awhile, I think you can see a spaceship going around Mars with lighting in the background!
Click to expand...
I saw a sailboat.

images
 
blueblood70 said:
He does not audible he has an option but you can stay stick that narrative where all the other false narratives go about Prescott That's not true at all He does not avoid the runs he looks at the defense like you don't know how to read and sees that they're playing the run and maybe they have an opportunity with two of the best receivers in football to throw the football But if the Cowboys wanted to run all they need to do is call an absolute run play only then why give him the option again it goes to coaching Prescott problem was he listened to the coaches and he should have just go with his gut and he should have maybe held onto the ball 1 second more when Pickens finally got open but yeah I don't want to hear the nonsense because that's all Troy did his hand the ball off and occasionally threw it so if you want to go there we can go there the guy never had to carry anything except his own gear I mean he literally had a super team I don't want to hear the excuses because he had one of the best offensive lines and run games and defenses and coaching Staffs in football the same with Roger that is why you keep running because you had the run game to support it Show me where this team has showed anything in the run game where the quarterback should stick to it all the time show me that run game in the playoffs it wasn't there the offensive line wasn't opening holes you know all those playoff games that they lost you know what the one constant was There was no run game there was number physicality up front we lost in the trenches on both sides of the football it was under 3 yards per carry in the playoffs all those losses that's the common denominator and you want your quarterback to feel really good and confident in his run game when there isn't that kind of run game here of course with Emmett Smith and that offensive line he would hand it off gladly He would gladly love for him to trust the offensive line in the run game that it could get in from the 5 yard line but we've seen it in the past we got a penalty you know that's why they passed right because Schoonmaker's motion you know he moved before the snap moved him back It changed the way you call plays but go ahead keep saying things that I can easily neutralize with common sense I saw what I saw Troy and Roger never had to carry the team and of course they handed the ball off to the Tony Dorsett and Emmett Smith we don't have those guys on this team we definitely don't have the offensive line I don't care how good the offensive line was at times in the regular season for Romo and Dak when it mattered most they got manhandled in the playoffs that's why we lost that's why the offense was one dimensional and that's why they were forced to pass because they couldn't run the ball at all under three yards CARRY pitiful..
.
Click to expand...
Another Magic Eye post. This time I see Dragon eating a banana.
 
5Stars said:
You know, if you stare at this post for awhile, I think you can see a spaceship going around Mars with lighting in the background!
Click to expand...
I have no idea what this means, but it's funny!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 223 more.
Total: 8,067 (members: 323, guests: 7,744)
Robots: 1,564

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
476,012
Messages
14,656,864
Members
24,226
Latest member
Dorsett99Yards
Back
Top