SI Has Tony As The #10 Rated QB.. I don't agree

[Vinnie2u]

http://mmqb.si.com/2015/07/03/nfl-quarterback-rankings/2/

Flacco, Ryan, Rivers are ahead of him... I think he's #5

 

[Rogah]

If the criteria is looking exclusively at the year 2015, then I put him #2 behind only Rodgers.

 

[silver]

I would put him ahead of Ryan, and Luck, but behind the others including Flacco.

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

How does Ryan continually gain more credibility than Romo. If the knock on Romo is what has he done? then what the HECK has Ryan done?!?!

 

[jzcowboy]

I would put him ahead of Ryan, and Luck, but behind the others including Flacco.

Why? Looking for actual reasons.

 

[ctrous25]

Romo is better than Ryan and it's not even close. I feel he's better than flacco and rivers too but could see where others might not

 

[Sarge]

Dead horse.

 

[jday]

How does Ryan continually gain more credibility than Romo. If the knock on Romo is what has he done? then what the HECK has Ryan done?!?!

It is a combination of what Ryan has done and hasn't done. What he has done: Drafted in the 1st round. What he hasn't done: Quarterback for the Dallas Cowboys. If you combine those two and you are a writer for a nationally syndicated news agency, then Ryan is clearly better than Romo. It is so obvious...

 

[KJJ]

Many still see the bobbled snap in Seattle when they think of Romo. They continue to see all the ill-timed mistakes that have plagued his career and until he wins a championship the lack of respect he receives will continue.

 

[perrykemp]

10 is too low. There are strong arguments to rank Romo in the 4-6 range.

That's plenty of good enough to win a Superbowl.

 

[silver]

Why? Looking for actual reasons.

Well, most of them are clutch and have won the big one in a clutch way. Flacco especially. Only Rivers hasn’t won a ring and him and Tony may be on a par. But the rest of them, Ben, Tom, Aaron, Drew and Payton are all better QB's. Luck and Ryan not so much clutch if you ask me. Tony has been clutch at times, especially last season, but until he wins the big one he won’t crack the top 5. All of this of course is my humble opinion and have nothing but my naked eye observations to base this on.

 

[Avery]

 

[DTown214]

I had Romo at number 5 before this past year. I had 1.Rodgers 2.Manning 3.Brady 4.Brees 5.Romo...

Going into this season I'd probably have it 1.Rodgers 2.Brady 3.Romo 4.Manning 5.Luck 6.Brees...

Am I crazy?

EDIT: forgot about Big Ben. He's definitely up there somewhere.

 

[Toruk_Makto]

Man. If Luck one day actually plays as well as these other top qbs he's routinely placed ahead it would really be something.

 

[gmoney112]

I had Romo at number 5 before this past year. I had 1.Rodgers 2.Manning 3.Brady 4.Brees 5.Romo...

Going into this season I'd probably have it 1.Rodgers 2.Brady 3.Romo 4.Manning 5.Luck 6.Brees...

Am I crazy?

EDIT: forgot about Big Ben. He's definitely up there somewhere.

I'd probably put Ben 4th after Romo. I'm not sure what happened to Peyton last season, it seemed like he was injured.

Right now, there's only two QB's i'd take if offered for this season alone and that's Rodgers and Brady. Matt Ryan is such an overhyped QB, I don't get it. I think it's because the media is in love with his "Matty Ice" moniker.

 

[erod]

This is like trying to get an honest take on politics from the established media.

If Romo played in the northeast, he'd be worshipped. But he plays here, so he'll never get an honest opinion from up there.

He'll shut his critics up for good these next two years. Watch.

You have be a football imbecile not to recognize him as elite. Or lack journalistic integrity.

There are five elite quarterbacks: Brady, Manning, Rodgers, Brees, and Romo. Luck is coming, and Manning and Brees are slipping.

 

[big dog cowboy]

SI Has Tony As The #10 Rated QB

meh.

SI is only good for one mag a year to me.

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

http://mmqb.si.com/2015/07/03/nfl-quarterback-rankings/2/

Flacco, Ryan, Rivers are ahead of him... I think he's #5

maybe not #5 but certainly not behind Ryan and Rivers. Flacco, I believe, half more Super Bowel rings than Romo half playoff wins.

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

How does Ryan continually gain more credibility than Romo. If the knock on Romo is what has he done? then what the HECK has Ryan done?!?!

the truth is that Ryan and Romo half done nothing past the regular playoff season, Ryan even less.

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

meh.

SI is only good for one mag a year to me.

The Super Bowl edition?