No it’s not exactly how you said it. You tried to use it as evidence he throws ACCURATELY CONSISTENTLY consistently, BECAUSE HE DID IT ONCE, LIKE THAT IS EVIDENCE HE WAS GOOD.
Did you see his pass over the middle right before half and how his facial expressions reflected how much he knew he sucked? Why not mention that ‘dart’ that landed in the dirt despite the WR being open?
Or the floater to Gallup on the go route where he had all day to throw, but it was so slow and high that the DB could catch up..