Where would you rank Dak?

[WillieBeamen]

No order:
Brady
Rodgers
Mahomes
Brees
Wentz
Goff
Wilson
Ryan
Rivers
Watson
Luck
Mayfield
Jimmy G
Stafford
Foles

All are without a doubt better. I dont want to hear anything about a damn w/l record, because any of those QBs could get 11 wins on this team.

Debatable:
Cam
Winston
Cousins
Trubisky

All of these QBs have put up seasons with better stats than Dak, but are mostly inconsistent

 

[LatinMind]

Specifically.


1.?
2.?
3.?
4.?
5.?
6.?
7.?
8.?
9.?
10.?

Where do you slot him and who above and below?

And if he’s outside the top ten by all means show your work as well.

“Top ten” , “Top fifteen” etc are abstract concepts without people occupying the spots. So what say you?

If your going to rank him as a singular entity then ur doing a disservice to the team because it’s a team game. If you want to rank him on importance and success, he’s second only to Brady. 2nd in wins and first overall in game winning drives

 

[Proof]

If your going to rank him as a singular entity then ur doing a disservice to the team because it’s a team game. If you want to rank him on importance and success, he’s second only to Brady. 2nd in wins and first overall in game winning drives

That’s a silly answer.

 

[sean10mm]

If your going to rank him as a singular entity then ur doing a disservice to the team because it’s a team game. If you want to rank him on importance and success, he’s second only to Brady. 2nd in wins and first overall in game winning drives

This seems like a weirdly extreme take on a guy with 0 conference championship appearances and 1 postseason win in 3 years.

 

[G2]

10-15 ish.
My favorite thing about Prescott is his durability. I would rank him higher for that. I think Wentz throws a better ball but seems brittle.

 

[Yobwocs]

1. Brady
2. Brees
3. Roethlisberger
4. Wilson
5. Rodgers
6. Rivers
7. Luck
8. Ryan
9. Mahomes
10. Goff
11. Prescott

 

[DHCBF66]

Now that D_Law has signed, I can see the "Dak" threads are taking over.....

 

[Toruk_Makto]

Remove Ryan hes a choke artist w a terrible playoff record... 4-6..hes not clutch

Players don't have win loss records. Teams do.

 

[Redball Express]

Specifically.


1.?
2.?
3.?
4.?
5.?
6.?
7.?
8.?
9.?
10.?

Where do you slot him and who above and below?

And if he’s outside the top ten by all means show your work as well.

“Top ten” , “Top fifteen” etc are abstract concepts without people occupying the spots. So what say you?

I would not have the time to plot the answer you want.

But I would start in our own division with what QBs are making or have gotten and based on performance to get there..

Nick Foles just won a SB and changed teams.

What is he making?

Eli Manning has won two SBs and earns like $23 mil.

Washington signed Smith from KC, no SBs and still waiting. He got a big contract at signing.how much was that?

Wentz is still on his rookie deal but he should shortly be inline for a new contract. How much will he get.?

Somewhere in there is DAK.

But QBs that have reached their potential with SB wins are going to set the high bar.

QB still lacking that are going to the bottom.

Where is DAK?

Hmmm..still quite a ways to the rear.

You do not pay for future possibility.

Only results.

And where do you rank him?

Overall...about 15th based on his success.

Middle of the pack.

Not a Leader but also not an Also Ran.

Room for improvement clearly.

 

[PJTHEDOORS]

Top 5.

 

[PAPPYDOG]

Don't know about the # but you will find him after Tyrod Taylor and Joe Flacco......

 

[Sydla]

Top 5.

Who are the other 4?

 

[StarBoyz83]

No order:
Brady
Rodgers
Mahomes
Brees
Wentz
Goff
Wilson
Ryan
Rivers
Watson
Luck
Mayfield
Jimmy G
Stafford
Foles

All are without a doubt better. I dont want to hear anything about a damn w/l record, because any of those QBs could get 11 wins on this team.

Debatable:
Cam
Winston
Cousins
Trubisky

All of these QBs have put up seasons with better stats than Dak, but are mostly inconsistent

You forgot Ben but for the most part I agree.

 

[StarBoyz83]

Top 5.

Lol drunk already?

 

[Super_Kazuya]

Nobody has liked your post yet. lol

Your groupies must be asleep right now?

Can’t you get all of the sock puppets that you use to like your own babbling posts to throw me a like? Unlike you they are inconsequential to me, I don’t even think about them. Although I did resolve to start handing out likes to you every time you somehow made it through a post without crying about retired Cowboy QBs... so here’s a “like”. You’re finally maturing a little bit.

 

[Sydla]

Lol drunk already?

I am generally curious who he leaves out of his Top 5 to put Dak in.

Brees, Brady, Rodgers have to be in there. Mahomes as well. So is he saying Dak is better than Russell Wilson? Or is Rodgers out?

Inquiring minds want to know.

 

[CF74]

All future Dak threads should list every starting qb with a yes or no.. There’s a lot of passers with better stats than Dak but many lack certain intangibles. Some are winners and some are just plain losers. Many would not succeed in this current offense and some would excel anywhere. Lots of things to factor in.

Mahomes - yes
Brady - Tough one, he’s due to retire but leaning to yes for obvious reasons.
Brees - In his prime yes but also due to retire.
Rodgers - In his prime yes and maybe even now. He’s a head case though.
Big Ben - In his prime yes but he’s a sumbag.
Goff - Maybe but leaning to yes.
Matty Ice - No.
Rivers - No, don’t like him.
Stafford - maybe.
Dalton - no
Luck - maybe.
Wilson - Not anymore he’s lost a step.
Watson - maybe if he gets it back.
Mayfield - yes, he’s a dynamic player.
Tannehill - no
Foles - no
Wince - no, too fragile and mental.
Cam - no
Gabbert - no
Flacco - In his prime yes, he won a lot of postseason games with limited wr’s.
Keenum - no
Cousins - no
Bradford - no
Josh Allen - maybe, need to see more but leaning to yes.
Darnold - no but he appears to have potential.
Bridgewater - no
Trubisky - maybe, he has flashes but leaning to no.
Winston - no
Bortles - no
Carr - no
Manning - maybe in his prime but not now.
Lamar Jackson - no
Rosen - no
Taylor - no
Mariota - no
Garoppolo - no

Dak is middle of the pack until proven otherwise yet I’d stick with him over a lot of these players. I believe we can win with him but he needs better coaching and a healthy o-line if you want to see his full potential..

He also needs to overcome his fear of throwing picks, this is more psychological than anything else but he could use some help with his footwork as well. This year will be interesting....

10-14 wins is very doable barring major injuries of course. I like our chances and believe we will make some noise...

 

[Nav22]

If you go by winning, he’s top 10.

If you go by stats, he’s top 10.

If you go by “eye test” because you have a personal issue with him and his success, DAK SUX LOLZ!

He’s winning at life and his haters are losing at life. It’s fantastic!

 

[CF74]

All future Dak threads should list every starting qb with a yes or no.. There’s a lot of passers with better stats than Dak but many lack certain intangibles. Some are winners and some are just plain losers. Many would not succeed in this current offense and some would excel anywhere. Lots of things to factor in.

Mahomes - yes
Brady - Tough one, he’s due to retire but leaning to yes for obvious reasons.
Brees - In his prime yes but also due to retire.
Rodgers - In his prime yes and maybe even now. He’s a head case though.
Big Ben - In his prime yes but he’s a sumbag.
Goff - Maybe but leaning to yes.
Matty Ice - No.
Rivers - No, don’t like him.
Stafford - maybe.
Dalton - no
Luck - maybe.
Wilson - Not anymore he’s lost a step.
Watson - maybe if he gets it back.
Mayfield - yes, he’s a dynamic player.
Tannehill - no
Foles - no
Wince - no, too fragile and mental.
Cam - no
Gabbert - no
Flacco - In his prime yes, he won a lot of postseason games with limited wr’s.
Keenum - no
Cousins - no
Bradford - no
Josh Allen - maybe, need to see more but leaning to yes.
Darnold - no but he appears to have potential.
Bridgewater - no
Trubisky - maybe, he has flashes but leaning to no.
Winston - no
Bortles - no
Carr - no
Manning - maybe in his prime but not now.
Lamar Jackson - no
Rosen - no
Taylor - no
Mariota - no
Garoppolo - no

Dak is middle of the pack until proven otherwise yet I’d stick with him over a lot of these players. I believe we can win with him but he needs better coaching and a healthy o-line if you want to see his full potential..

He also needs to overcome his fear of throwing picks, this is more psychological than anything else but he could use some help with his footwork as well. This year will be interesting....

10-14 wins is very doable barring major injuries of course. I like our chances and believe we will make some noise...

Forgot two:

Smith - no
Fitzpatrick - no

 

[Austin 3-16]

He's a guy who should be making no more than 20m a year. And I'm a Dak fan. Hate this "latest gets best deal" quarterback market.