TheMarathonContinues
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 76,471
- Reaction score
- 70,755
dude you are making my point. there are 4 teams and four qbs you mentioned out of 32 teams with 3 deep at QB..you know what thos eodds are, also let me reply..
Andy Reid how many SBs appearances? Sb wins=0... So Mcnabb is better than Romo and dak, NOFNWY..about the same type of qbs IMO .he inherited Smith did not draft him and if he or any of the nfl knew what mahomes would become he would have went #1 overall not 13th or wherever he went, again a Elite generational pick, sometimes is luck..
Harbaugh they used up and then overpaid a player who was great one year on the SB run silair to afoles who caught fire, then what? Jackson was flier and they ahd to run an offense to suit his needs vs hiom being eliete , hes not an Elite QB, hes and elite Athlete playing QB..great thing Hrbaugh got the archetect who made Kap good and was abke to use that for Jackson but noone truly knew hed be this good for at least a year..so i did not see any super GM/Coach move for any ogf them that brought a QB, some luck buddy..
Pete carroll LOL dude just brought in some overpriced FA to start and took Wilson in the 3rd round but did not know hed be this good or he would have been taken first overall.. before that it was some bad QBs in Seatle..go look it up..BTW forst 2 years when Seatle was great that was an elite defense and run game that gave time for RW to bcome who he did..oh and old PC let aplay call be put in RW hands whwn it shold have been Lynch on the gal line that cost him a SB.
Same goes for old BigBen i remember a super Defense, betis and run game that simply said let the qb not give the game away and we we win.. ben became gret later but he was not the reason they won that first SB, not eve close..there were several mediocre qbs before ben on those PB teams btw, worse then dak..
so even if i gave you the argumanet which im not we can split the difference my point is theres no formula for finding elite players especially at QB and it takes some luck and timing to find those...
now if the argumanet is they had a better GM or HC sure they built a great defense on all those teams, instaled a great Run Game and dint replay on the QB from day one to shoulder the load..
we never gave romo that sufficating of defesne at the same time as a great line and run game and let the game come to them, dak really hasnt got that yet either , some of it yes but those 4 teams all had that in common..some of the best defnses the nfl ever had and a strong run game..
this year NE is doing it with great defense ansd ST because they dont have a good offense, really below avg offense including brady..
Us we had horrioble ST, inconsistent play on defense , and our offense coudnt find an identity ie coaching was sporadic..
so again yes i go Coaches more of an issue then our QB selections..
I didn't say it was only 4 teams. You said you didn't have time to go down 32 times. If you have the time.....go look at what the 32 teams have done. And I bet you will see a trend of the bad coaches/organization doing stupid things at quarterback and the good coaches/organization doing smart things as quarterback. I wasn't telling you to compare who's better and who's not. Fact is McNabb made it to the Super Bowl and Andy Reid has as well with inferior talent. That's where we are at. We are trying to get to the Super Bowl.
In regards to what we never gave Romo....what did the Giants give Eli? What did Packers give Rodgers or Saints give BreeS?