silverbear;1339430 said:
Dungy still didn't have a choice in the matter, if he wanted the head coach job...
I don't believe Dom Capers was the defensive coordinator for the Fins last year... he was on the staff, but was only recently promoted to DC...
BEFORE the Fins hired their new head coach, giving that new head coach no say in the matter... at least, that's what a press releasee on the Fins' official website says:
So, that makes at least TWO different coaches that the Fins "forced" on... indeed, if you look at ALL of the recent head coach hirings, and go to that team's website, you'll find that each and every one of those new head coaches have been "forced" accept staff not of their choosing...
Each and every one of them...
This isn't accurate. Capers was the DC last year and Cameron was hired on January 19th, before Robiskie was retained. With regard to Capers, a 1st year head coach hired relatively late would likely be thrilled to have a guy on board that he knows what he can expect from. There is a point about continuity of coaches that even a new coach would be likely to see, especially if the guy in place is already successful.
It's a little ridiculous comparing guys with track records like Capers and Lebeau and Moore to a guy like Garrett who's never been a coordinator before, and wasn't here already. Couple his lack of experience with the reports that he's still being considered as a HC candidate would have to give any but either the marginal candidate or the guy that knows he's at the end of the string anyway to be uncomfortable about whether he's just keeping a seat warm for the heir apparent. It is an unusual order of hire for that reason.
Having said that, there is a plus if Garrett is as sharp as advertised. Pickings for assistants this time of year get pretty slim so if you bring in another young head coach after the SB with no staff in place it's a crap shoot what he'll be able to piece together for a staff. A bad staff usually = a bad HC. So that leads me to conclude it'll be Phillips or Turner, two guys that would probably take the job if Jerry told either one that he was going to call plays from the press box himself.
But if the intention is to look for a young up and comer like a Rivera I have to agree this is *** backwards. It's hard to see where Rivera would not view Garrett as a direct threat.