Nice info.
The 2 penalty machines are no longer on the team, so hopefully that improves.
Not exactly. Over the last 4 years Williams averaged about .47 penalties per game. Collins averaged about .44 per game. Tyron Smith averaged .64 penalties per game! Tyron had 25 penalties in 39 games in 4 years.
Tyron has actually been pretty consistent in his penalty totals. Williams had a fluke year accumulating 12 penalties in 2021 and only 15 in the previous 3 years.
Collins had only 3 penalties in 2019 (he did not play in 2020) but 8 in 2021. But he had 8 penalties in 2018.
In terms of holding calls, 19 of Williams' 27 penalties were holding calls. Collins had 9 holding calls of 19 penalties. Tyron had 18 holding calls in 25 penalties and Biadasz had only 3 holding calls in 11 penalties.
One other point, for those who think Collins was unreliable, he played in 43 games over the last 4 years. Tyron has played in only 39.
Of course penalty stats are not as solid as other stats because they are the result of the refs' judgement. We have all seen penalties awards that were questionable, and penalties not called when they were pretty obvious. Still we have to assume these even out of the most part. The exception may be Connor Williams. I do think the refs were picking on him in 2021.