LaTunaNostra said:
Henson isn't being talked down. He's been photoshopped with Aikman, compared to Aikman, and had the name "franschise" attached to his name more than any current player I've seen on this team, including #31.
But from third, and possibly fourth on the depth chart, it's pretty hard to sustain much enthusiasm for seeing him this year in anything but preseason. He's just too far back to get very excited about him this year, imo.
Like a Carson Palmer last season , he may have to do zilch this season but watch and learn to get handed the starting position next year. If and when he does, I know I will get excited. But this year, no player three deep on the depth chart in any position matters all that much.
Chances are very very strong he won't bypass Carter and Vinnie this year. He hasn't been strategically placed to do so, even if he is wunderkind who can shrug off a few years of rust in a shor time.
If he does, however, somehow manage to bypass one of them from his scout team duties and third team QBing in preseason, it will makes things very interesting.
I doubt he will though. He just won't get the primo snapo to make it possible.
I do hope we get to see him for the couple of drives with the first team Bill used to give his third QBs in preseason in NY. But those may go to Romo, who they are going to have to decide stays or goes. Drew is not a pressing matter. He obviously stays. There is no impetus to give him snaps over Tony, for whom this preseason seems critical.
For now, I am much more excited about Julius Jonee and 2004.e
Let's examine something that was said in response to me shall we? QBs taken high like Mirer, Shuler, etc. are potential busts.
Also said to me was a comparison to Hutchinson and the hype he received.
I brought up our last 2 top draft picks and talked about the hype that surrounded their selection as far as the fans went. Of course that got discarded a bit, but I think it is relevant and I am picking it back up.
Drew Henson, Roy Williams, and Terence Newman. Let's just examine those 3 and talk about perception among fans.
In 1991 the Cleveland Browns selected Eric Turner with the 2nd overall pick. He was a safety from UCLA and pretty much a bust. (Other Safeties taken high have busted too.) Were Cowboys fans wringing their hands that Roy Williams might be the next Eric Turner? No, they were anointing him the next Ronnie Lott. High expectations and standards. We only need to scoot over to our rival Extremeskins to see the hype that Sean Taylor is getting. Hyping a player is natural for fans of that team. If a guy has a chance to really reach his potential the fans are insane with optimism. Hype Taylor alongside Williams and Cowboys fans will bristle that Taylor hasn't accomplished anything yet. Williams was compared to Lott before he had accomplished anything. Dichotomy? I think so.
In 1997 the Detroit Lions selected Bryant Westbrook from Texas with the 5th oveall selection. Pretty much a colossal bust. (There have been other CBs taken high who busted too.) Were Cowboys fans wringing their hands that Terence Newman might be the next Bryant Westbrook? No, we were comparing him to Deion Sanders. High expectations and standards. Dichotomy? I think so.
I could go on and do this for any position on the football field. DT, Dan Wilinson in 1994. LB, Quentin Coryatt in 1992. RB, Blair Thomas in 1990. The list goes on.
For the most part football fans do not see who their team drafted and think the worst could happen. I guarantee you that if you go to the Patriots website they are not talking about Vince Wilfork in the same sentences with Steven Emtman and Dan Wilkinson.
Go to Chargers, Bills, Giants, and Steelers sites and I bet you the majority are excited about the new signal callers and talk of giving them their shots does not get beaten down and trampled on. There will always be a few, but not a majority. I would be shocked if any of those sites are wringing their hands thinking their new thrower is the next Ryan Leaf.
Yet that is what we have here. It doesn't make any sense at all. Drew Henson has been rated alongside a lot of young QBs who their team's fans are giddy about. Do you think there was apprehension in Jacksonville last year when they gave the ball to Leftwich? No, there was excitement. The future had arrived.
Here we get weeping, wailing, and gnashing of teeth when we should have a little excitement.
I guarantee you that the picks in 2005 will have fans and hype instead of what we have now fr Henson. You can't even tell me it is the QB position because like I said, other teams fans are excited about their next generation. I seriously doubt that Steelers fans are upset at jpegs of Big Ben. I doubt Tommy Maddox's fans are complaining about the harmony of the forum. Bradshaw fans are not up in arms.
I have a few fellow vocal Henson fans, but nothing like the swell of support for Williams, Newman, and whoever the picks are in 05 will be. It is confusing.