A Tale of Two QB's

[SpaceCowboy99]

This is just some interesting information for us to digest. Take from it what you will and not intended to start arguments one way or the other.

On a personal note, although I don't like Dak, I do like Jared and if they have such similar careers, I can at least admit that Dak is a good QB for the Cowboys and just needs to deliver in the playoffs to move to the next tier. Crazy how close they are in a lot of ways. Goff has 12 more games played than Dak, factoring that in and their stats are even closer. Not counting Dak's early career dual threat stats as Goff has never been a runner.

	Dak	Goff
Drafted	4th Round	1st Round
Seasons	10	10
Games Played	135	147
Record	82-52-1	89-57-1
Playoff Record	2-5	5-5
Current Contract	4-Yr / $240 Million	4-Yr / $212 Million
Championship Game Appearances	0	2
Superbowl Appearances	0	1
Career Earnings	$296,300,000	$241,627,068
Passing Touchdowns	239	248
Passing Yards	35,074	38,392
Passing C%	67.1%	66%
Passing Yards Avg.	7.6	7.6
Interceptions	92	99
Pick 6s	9	9
Fumbles	65	73
Sacks Taken	278	275
Rushing Yards	2076	595
Rushing Touchdowns	31	12
4th Quarter Comebacks	19	18
Last Night Completions	31/47	25/34
Last Night Yards	376	309
Last Night Interceptions	2	0
Last Night Touchdowns Thrown	1	1
Passer Rating Career	98.4	96.9

 

[SpaceCowboy99]

Oh and I forgot to mention.... Goff has 2 championship appearances with 2 different teams. I think we can all safely assume that if Dak played both another team, he would never recover and would be out of the league in a season or 2.

 

[Pentagruel]

So pretty comparable then. Goff is a good QB overall. He’s been on some capable organizations as well with excellent coaching.

 

[diamonddelts]

"He is I and I am him."

 

[Zman5]

Dak started his career coached by Garrett and Jerry as his GM.. Goff started with McVay.

Enough said.

 

[WillieBeamen]

Dak started his career coached by Garrett and Jerry as his GM.. Goff started with McVay.

Enough said.

Goff started with Jeff Fisher and Bones Fassell (our ex ST coordinator)


Ydkb

 

[America's Cowboy]

It's not even close. Dak is the better QB, especially after playing under much lesser head coaches and a GM/owner. If Dak played under McVay or Campbell, he would have helped not only lead those Goff led teams to Super Bowls, but won them as well.

It definitely is not even close. Dak has achieved more stat-wise with much less than Goff has had to.

 

[CowboyoWales]

This is just some interesting information for us to digest. Take from it what you will and not intended to start arguments one way or the other.

On a personal note, although I don't like Dak, I do like Jared and if they have such similar careers, I can at least admit that Dak is a good QB for the Cowboys and just needs to deliver in the playoffs to move to the next tier. Crazy how close they are in a lot of ways. Goff has 12 more games played than Dak, factoring that in and their stats are even closer. Not counting Dak's early career dual threat stats as Goff has never been a runner.

	Dak	Goff
Drafted	4th Round	1st Round
Seasons	10	10
Games Played	135	147
Record	82-52-1	89-57-1
Playoff Record	2-5	5-5
Current Contract	4-Yr / $240 Million	4-Yr / $212 Million
Championship Game Appearances	0	2
Superbowl Appearances	0	1
Career Earnings	$296,300,000	$241,627,068
Passing Touchdowns	239	248
Passing Yards	35,074	38,392
Passing C%	67.1%	66%
Passing Yards Avg.	7.6	7.6
Interceptions	92	99
Pick 6s	9	9
Fumbles	65	73
Sacks Taken	278	275
Rushing Yards	2076	595
Rushing Touchdowns	31	12
4th Quarter Comebacks	19	18
Last Night Completions	31/47	25/34
Last Night Yards	376	309
Last Night Interceptions	2	0
Last Night Touchdowns Thrown	1	1
Passer Rating Career	98.4	96.9

The eye says both are good QB's, both of whom are excellent Offensive Generals. However, both have Achilles Heels that can stop them from winning it all. Goff suffers under pass-rush and Dak suffers when he needs to step up above and beyond his usual game.
If you were the HC of the opposition you'd dial up an increased number of blitz's and against Dak, go all out to get a lead and sit in zone (play the odds that his anxiety will get the better of him).

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

This is just some interesting information for us to digest. Take from it what you will and not intended to start arguments one way or the other.

On a personal note, although I don't like Dak, I do like Jared and if they have such similar careers, I can at least admit that Dak is a good QB for the Cowboys and just needs to deliver in the playoffs to move to the next tier. Crazy how close they are in a lot of ways. Goff has 12 more games played than Dak, factoring that in and their stats are even closer. Not counting Dak's early career dual threat stats as Goff has never been a runner.

	Dak	Goff
Drafted	4th Round	1st Round
Seasons	10	10
Games Played	135	147
Record	82-52-1	89-57-1
Playoff Record	2-5	5-5
Current Contract	4-Yr / $240 Million	4-Yr / $212 Million
Championship Game Appearances	0	2
Superbowl Appearances	0	1
Career Earnings	$296,300,000	$241,627,068
Passing Touchdowns	239	248
Passing Yards	35,074	38,392
Passing C%	67.1%	66%
Passing Yards Avg.	7.6	7.6
Interceptions	92	99
Pick 6s	9	9
Fumbles	65	73
Sacks Taken	278	275
Rushing Yards	2076	595
Rushing Touchdowns	31	12
4th Quarter Comebacks	19	18
Last Night Completions	31/47	25/34
Last Night Yards	376	309
Last Night Interceptions	2	0
Last Night Touchdowns Thrown	1	1
Passer Rating Career	98.4	96.9

do you have the first pick in the draft? if yes, then lets do it. lets draft a Goff!!!

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Oh and I forgot to mention.... Goff has 2 championship appearances with 2 different teams. I think we can all safely assume that if Dak played both another team, he would never recover and would be out of the league in a season or 2.

what was the point of your post? I don't get it.... one was the 1st over all pick. the other a 4th round pick..... do you have the 1st over all pick?

this is not a defense of Dak. its the stupidity of the comparison.

 

[Bob-Lillys-War]

This is just some interesting information for us to digest. Take from it what you will and not intended to start arguments one way or the other.

On a personal note, although I don't like Dak, I do like Jared and if they have such similar careers, I can at least admit that Dak is a good QB for the Cowboys and just needs to deliver in the playoffs to move to the next tier. Crazy how close they are in a lot of ways. Goff has 12 more games played than Dak, factoring that in and their stats are even closer. Not counting Dak's early career dual threat stats as Goff has never been a runner.

	Dak	Goff
Drafted	4th Round	1st Round
Seasons	10	10
Games Played	135	147
Record	82-52-1	89-57-1
Playoff Record	2-5	5-5
Current Contract	4-Yr / $240 Million	4-Yr / $212 Million
Championship Game Appearances	0	2
Superbowl Appearances	0	1
Career Earnings	$296,300,000	$241,627,068
Passing Touchdowns	239	248
Passing Yards	35,074	38,392
Passing C%	67.1%	66%
Passing Yards Avg.	7.6	7.6
Interceptions	92	99
Pick 6s	9	9
Fumbles	65	73
Sacks Taken	278	275
Rushing Yards	2076	595
Rushing Touchdowns	31	12
4th Quarter Comebacks	19	18
Last Night Completions	31/47	25/34
Last Night Yards	376	309
Last Night Interceptions	2	0
Last Night Touchdowns Thrown	1	1
Passer Rating Career	98.4	96.9

Superbowl appearance .

Just with that , its not even close .

Post season is what matters .

 

[Bob-Lillys-War]

Who cares about passer rating against trash teams ?

Playoffs are the only that count .

 

[Zman5]

Goff started with Jeff Fisher and Bones Fassell (our ex ST coordinator)


Ydkb

Just for one year and Fisher was fired after 2016 season. Then Goff was coached up by McVay while Garrett clapped and did his damage for another 3 years.

 

[Brax]

It's not even close. Dak is the better QB, especially after playing under much lesser head coaches and a GM/owner. If Dak played under McVay or Campbell, he would have helped not only lead those Goff led teams to Super Bowls, but won them as well.

It definitely is not even close. Dak has achieved more stat-wise with much less than Goff has had to.

impossible to take you seriously when you put up a avatar like that.
Theres no GM taking Dak over Goff bases on CCG, SB and Dak no show in Playoff games, just the facts sorry.

 

[UncleRico]

What is the point of this post though? 2 guys drafted the same year have similar #’s but one was the #1 overall pick and has played for great coaches and on great teams. Goff IMO couldn’t have handled the scrutiny being the Cowboys QB like Dak has since entering league.

 

[BoyzBlaster]

I'd take Goff every day of the week but it's not like he's super elite. Although he does throw a very nice ball.

 

[Redsfan_83]

The Lions have never won a Super Bowl, and 30 years and counting for our Cowboys. One cannot say the comparisons aren't even close, and both have been given very good quality players to play with.

 

[CowboyFrog]

impossible to take you seriously when you put up a avatar like that.
Theres no GM taking Dak over Goff bases on CCG, SB and Dak no show in Playoff games, just the facts sorry.

There actually is a GM who has and would... lol again how does this escape anyone? There is a GM who would start our current LB's as starting LB's in the NFL.. who would tell you "Hutch" threw the best ball or that he has never seen anyone throw a ball like "The 40 year old graduate" from oklahoma state....who would go into a season with Zeke as a number #1 RB recently... THERE IS A GM WHO WOULD DO ALL OF THIS

 

[America's Cowboy]

impossible to take you seriously when you put up a avatar like that.
Theres no GM taking Dak over Goff bases on CCG, SB and Dak no show in Playoff games, just the facts sorry.

You put Goff behind the recent teams and different head coaches Dak has had, Goff would totally suck even worse. That's a guarantee.

 

[Shotgun Dave]

he would never recover and would be out of the league in a season or 2.

Based upon what do you make this claim? He would be OUT OF THE LEAGUE in a season or two?

Can’t wait to hear the rationale behind this.