American Idol season 11

[Muhast]

Amen --singing like a girl and flippin his hair like a girl was more then I could stand

And skipping around the stage. Couldn't stand him.

 

[Cajuncowboy]

This week they are singing SONGS OF THIS DECADE.

Elise and Hollie need to bring it or they are outta here.

Wow! All two years worth to pick from?

 

[kristie]

Wow! All two years worth to pick from?

that's right.

 

[Tony33]

Two out of three ain't bad I guess. While I like Hollie, I know the judges were a bit hard on her as she had some problems but she was good enough to stay. I just don't see Joshua staying for the long haul.


And thank God the hair flippin' machine is gone.

Phillip and Elise are two of the best singers. Jousha and Jessica are great but I don't get into cookie cutter singers. I have seen what they do 1000 times before. Hollie has been bad that is why the judges are hard on her. Colton and the rest aren't anything special. It is four person race, Phillip, Elise Joshua, and Jessica are the best.

 

[Tony33]

I still can't believe they put Jermine in he was horrible.

 

[Cajuncowboy]

Phillip and Elise are two of the best singers. Jousha and Jessica are great but I don't get into cookie cutter singers. I have seen what they do 1000 times before. Hollie has been bad that is why the judges are hard on her. Colton and the rest aren't anything special. It is four person race, Phillip, Elise Joshua, and Jessica are the best.

If you are talking top three, IMO it's Colton, Skylar and Jessica as far as pure voice talent is concerned. Elise, Skylar and Phillip are the three top in regards to entertainers. They all three have great stage presence.

 

[Tony33]

If you are talking top three, IMO it's Colton, Skylar and Jessica as far as pure voice talent is concerned. Elise, Skylar and Phillip are the three top in regards to entertainers. They all three have great stage presence.

The four I mentioned are all better than Sklyar. Admittedly I'm not into country music that much but she is honestly hit or miss for me. Colton won't beat out Phillip, Joshua or Jessica, he isn't on their level, IMO.

 

[Cajuncowboy]

The four I mentioned are all better than Sklyar. Admittedly I'm not into country music that much but she is honestly hit or miss for me. Colton won't beat out Phillip, Joshua or Jessica, he isn't on their level, IMO.

Skyar has more range, better tonality and is more commercial ready than Elise or Joshua. Jessica needs A LOT of work on her stage presence and simply performing. She is a very good signer but there is much more to it than just standing there signing. And the BB Chez thing for someone in a signing competition is just so lame. She hasn't even developed her own persona as a performer yet and she is trying the (failed) Beyonce thing.

 

[kristie]

I still can't believe they put Jermine in he was horrible.

I know. that was bad.

 

[kristie]

colton & skylar:

[YOUTUBE]OEJbiOMwm6A[/YOUTUBE]

 

[justbob]

Great duo----not sure Idol don't have the best talent this year

 

[kristie]

Great duo----not sure Idol don't have the best talent this year

yeah. this season is one of those where the talent is good but not great. there have been seasons where the talent has been better(seasons 2, 5, & 7).

 

[theogt]

I'm going to say that Jessica Sanchez is the best singer to ever appear on AI. And it's not even close. She's an extremely rare talent.

 

[Tony33]

Philip, Elise, Jousha and Skylar the best tonight.

 

[Tony33]

Philip, Elise, Jousha and Skylar the best tonight.

 

[Tony33]

I'm going to say that Jessica Sanchez is the best singer to ever appear on AI. And it's not even close. She's an extremely rare talent.

No, she is good but she isn't even the best singer on the show this year.

 

[kristie]

hollie got thrown under the bus big time by the judges despite giving what i thought was an awesome performance. i'm pissed off about that.

 

[kristie]

here's the performance:

[YOUTUBE]lo9ztwwjdnY[/YOUTUBE]

 

[Cajuncowboy]

Hollie has a nice voice but last night performance lacked punch and her notes bounced all over the place. She should probably be in the bottom three. Whie Elsie had a good performance, I bet she is there as well.

 

[justbob]

Dial tone has --Colton,Elsie and Sanchez in the bottom three .... I really like Colton --I was hohum on Sanchez last night --I get tired of her..Don't like Elsies attitude --But I like this thread so much better then the last one