American Idol season 11

[Cajuncowboy]

Dial tone has --Colton,Elsie and Sanchez in the bottom three .... I really like Colton --I was hohum on Sanchez last night --I get tired of her..Don't like Elsies attitude --But I like this thread so much better then the last one

I doubt Colton goes home. Even if he is the bottom vote getter, he is one they will save.

 

[Wimbo]

I think Elise screwed up by doing Lady GaGa. She is more of a bluesy/rock type of singer & she should have found a song to capitalize on that strength. These last two weeks have allowed contestants to pick songs that show off their strengths - they have not been forced to sing a particular genre or artist. I think she wasted the opportunity.

 

[justbob]

I doubt Colton goes home. Even if he is the bottom vote getter, he is one they will save.

I agree--not sure they will save Elsie or Holly --but I think they will everyone else

 

[kristie]

I think Elise screwed up by doing Lady GaGa. She is more of a bluesy/rock type of singer & she should have found a song to capitalize on that strength. These last two weeks have allowed contestants to pick songs that show off their strengths - they have not been forced to sing a particular genre or artist. I think she wasted the opportunity.

she did. she should've sang the song that she & phillip sang together.

 

[Tony33]

Elise was awesome, I really don't know what the rest of you were watching. I'd save her before Colton everyday.

 

[Tony33]

America wasn't wrong, the judges have pet cats. It was clear that their pet cats are Jessica and Jousha. Jousha didn't deserve to be in the bottom 3 and neither did Elise. Jessica was were she belonged.

 

[Gemini Dolly]

If only Elise and Jessica had a *****.

Colton vs. Philipx2 is going to be the finale.

 

[kristie]

i'm sorry if anyone here hasn't seen the show yet but i can't resist:

[YOUTUBE]URMH1rVRMRQ[/YOUTUBE]

 

[kristie]

http://www.eonline.com/news/_i_Amer...tion_Shocker__To_Save_or_Not_to_Save__/308509


the majority of the comments on this show that there are people who don't agree with the save or the way the judges behaved thursday night. there are even some who feel that it will all backfire on the judges & poor jessica. what do all of you think?

 

[theogt]

Of course they had to use the save. Jessica is the best singer on the show.

 

[kristie]

Of course they had to use the save. Jessica is the best singer on the show.

i know. it was getting to the point where they either had to use it or just forget about it because after the number of contestants reached 5 then they couldn't use it.

 

[Cajuncowboy]

http://www.eonline.com/news/_i_Amer...tion_Shocker__To_Save_or_Not_to_Save__/308509


the majority of the comments on this show that there are people who don't agree with the save or the way the judges behaved thursday night. there are even some who feel that it will all backfire on the judges & poor jessica. what do all of you think?

It will backfire on Jessica. People are upset the way the judges acted. The way Jennifer grabbed the mic, I thought she was channeling Kanye West. It was so obviously set up.

 

[kristie]

It will backfire on Jessica. People are upset the way the judges acted. The way Jennifer grabbed the mic, I thought she was channeling Kanye West. It was so obviously set up.

that's what i was thinking. the only thing about it that seemed unscripted to me was jessica's reaction when the judges stormed the stage.

 

[Cajuncowboy]

that's what i was thinking. the only thing about it that seemed unscripted to me was jessica's reaction when the judges stormed the stage.

Oh, I don't think she knew. But the judges, producers and Ryan certainly did.

 

[ragman]

Some people are saying that Stephen Tyler let slip that they were going to use the save on Thursday night's show. Did anyone see that? Can anyone confirm that?

 

[kristie]

Some people are saying that Stephen Tyler let slip that they were going to use the save on Thursday night's show. Did anyone see that? Can anyone confirm that?

i saw it. he did say that. not a smart move on his part.

 

[Cajuncowboy]

Some people are saying that Stephen Tyler let slip that they were going to use the save on Thursday night's show. Did anyone see that? Can anyone confirm that?

He did. He said after the bottom three were revealed, "We are going to use the save tonight."

It was stupid.

 

[kristie]

Oh, I don't think she knew. But the judges, producers and Ryan certainly did.

ryan & one of the producers, nigel lythgoe, actually tweeted about it, saying that the results would be shocking.

 

[Cajuncowboy]

ryan & one of the producers, nigel lythgoe, actually tweeted about it, saying that the results would be shocking.

That figures. You can't make up that kind of stupid.

 

[kristie]

That figures. You can't make up that kind of stupid.

no you can't.