American Idol

[kristie]

In particular, watch the last 20 seconds or so of her Think performance.

Probably only a matter of time until she sings Sinead O'Connor's Nothing Compares 2 U.

siobhan can't sing that even if she wanted to because prince wrote that song, & i've heard that he won't let any of his music be performed on idol.

 

[kristie]

Really? I fast forwarded through Cook after about 20 seconds. I thought it was boring.

i didn't think it was boring. i thought it was hot, but then again i'm probably being biased.

 

[kristie]

tonight's theme was #1 hits from the billboard charts & i have to say that not everyone did well except for crystal, who sang "me & bobby mcgee", & siobhan, who sang "superstition". also having miley cyrus as the top 11's mentor was, to me, extremely dumb despite the fact that she has been successful. i think they should've gone with someone else as a mentor. any thoughts?

 

[JohnnyHopkins]

tonight's theme was #1 hits from the billboard charts & i have to say that not everyone did well except for crystal, who sang "me & bobby mcgee", & siobhan, who sang "superstition". also having miley cyrus as the top 11's mentor was, to me, extremely dumb despite the fact that she has been successful. i think they should've gone with someone else as a mentor. any thoughts?

Aside from the two you mentioned, it was a pretty blah night overall, but I did like the guy (I can't remember his name, just a character flaw of mine ) that sang "The Power of Love". He is very talented with the guitar as well as his singing ability.

Miley Cyrus as the mentor was a huge bomb.

 

[Khartun]

tonight's theme was #1 hits from the billboard charts & i have to say that not everyone did well except for crystal, who sang "me & bobby mcgee", & siobhan, who sang "superstition". also having miley cyrus as the top 11's mentor was, to me, extremely dumb despite the fact that she has been successful. i think they should've gone with someone else as a mentor. any thoughts?

I thought Crystal was great and Siobhan was so-so, but better than the last few weeks. Her screaming at the end of each song is getting annoying, especially when it is a bad scream like last week. The competition looks to me like it will come down to Crystal, Siobhan, and Big Mike.

Miley being a mentor was ridiculous.

 

[Gemini Dolly]

Crystal was good, the rest ZzzZzzZzzZ, although Siobahn's scream awoke me.

Andrew goes home tonight. I hope. I cant stand that man. Paige and Tim will round out the bottom 3.

 

[theogt]

Crystal was good, the rest ZzzZzzZzzZ, although Siobahn's scream awoke me.

Andrew goes home tonight. I hope. I cant stand that man. Paige and Tim will round out the bottom 3.

Good is an understatement. That was one of the best performances on AI that I've ever seen.

 

[Gemini Dolly]

WHO IS VOTING FOR ANDREW GARCIA?? SHOW THY SELF!
UGHHHHHH

Paige did have to go though. She has sucked it for a while.

 

[theogt]

WHO IS VOTING FOR ANDREW GARCIA?? SHOW THY SELF!
UGHHHHHH

Paige did have to go though. She has sucked it for a while.

Garcia just needs to get back to things like this where he takes something familiar and makes it fresh and original and interesting.

[youtube]Tu5N6CSGh4Q[/youtube]

 

[kristie]

Aside from the two you mentioned, it was a pretty blah night overall, but I did like the guy (I can't remember his name, just a character flaw of mine ) that sang "The Power of Love". He is very talented with the guitar as well as his singing ability.

Miley Cyrus as the mentor was a huge bomb.

casey james sang that one.

 

[Gemini Dolly]

Casey James looks so stiff, especially when he plays guitar. He needs to loosen up on that stage. His singing is okay and hes a pretty guy. heh.

 

[kristie]

Casey James looks so stiff, especially when he plays guitar. He needs to loosen up on that stage. His singing is okay and hes a pretty guy. heh.

he is cute, i'll admit that, & i think kara dioguardi is in love with him.:laugh1:

it makes me sick to be honest.:laugh1:

 

[kristie]

WHO IS VOTING FOR ANDREW GARCIA?? SHOW THY SELF!
UGHHHHHH

Paige did have to go though. She has sucked it for a while.

i think the next to go will be tim urban. he seriously annoys me.

 

[JohnnyHopkins]

How the heck is Tim Urban hanging on??? He went from not originally being in the top 24 to now going on tour with the top ten!

 

[kmp77]

How the heck is Tim Urban hanging on??? He went from not originally being in the top 24 to now going on tour with the top ten!

http://www.votefortheworst.com/

But the two worst were in the bottom two though. So Urban will go home next week.

 

[kristie]

http://www.votefortheworst.com/

But the two worst were in the bottom two though. So Urban will go home next week.

i hope so because that website is such a joke. it's run by a bunch of losers who claim that because of them, sanjaya stuck around longer then he should have.

 

[Gemini Dolly]

Tonight was R&B night and Usher mentored. I love me some Usher.

LEE was the best of the night for me. He has a very radio friendly voice, but what he lacks has always been confidence. Tonight he showed his stuff and he was brilliant.

Crystal changed it up, wore a dress and played piano, it was aight. I prefer her playing the guitar and not dolled up. But I understand her changing it up.

Siobahn was 1st up to go and she sucked it hard. It was all over the place vocally and the screaming was off pitch. She knew it and looked devastated even before the judges critiqued her.

Andrew, I highly dislike him, but his rendition of Chris Brown's Forever was good. However, I agree with Simon that his personality is boring.

Didi Tim and Katie are my predictions for B3 w/ Tim going home.

 

[Cajuncowboy]

Well, I watched it again tonight against my better judgement but my daughter wanted me to so I did.

The show stinks. While Randy kara and Simon may have some skins on the wall, they have lost their musical ear trying to be whatever it is they are trying to be on this show.

And if Ellen could ever get one complete coherent sentence out of her mouth it would be a miracle of God.

With that said, the best left in this competition is That Casey guy.

The young kid at the end is very good as well. Don't think he will win but he is good.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Casey James looks so stiff, especially when he plays guitar. He needs to loosen up on that stage. His singing is okay and hes a pretty guy. heh.

he is cute, i'll admit that, & i think kara dioguardi is in love with him.:laugh1:

it makes me sick to be honest.:laugh1:

LOL at the grunge look. It's freakin' 2010.

 

[kristie]

what did everyone think of big mike's performance? i thought it was fantastic.