Johnson undercut any leverage he may have had to force a trade because the broad signing bonus recovery language is in his contract restructures. If Johnson hadn’t restructured the contract he signed in 2010 or gotten the more favorable signing bonus language, the maximum amount of signing bonus the Texans would have been able to recoup from him with a holdout this year would have only been $469,583 (the prorated amount of signing bonus in 2014 from his 2010 deal). The broad language allows the Texans to recover a maximum of $4,444,583 from Johnson in 2014. Johnson should have been risking $70,437 of signing bonus with a six-day training camp holdout, but it’s $666,687 instead. If Johnson misses the entire Texans’ training camp and no more than four weeks of the regular season, they can recoup $2,222,291 from him when it would have been $234,791 with the better language. Johnson would also be giving up $588,235 of his $10 million base salary for each week of the regular season he missed.
The broad language also effectively removes retirement as an option for Johnson as Carson Palmer did in 2011 with the Cincinnati Bengals. Players aren’t subject to the daily fines for missed training with retirement, but signing bonus recovery is more onerous on the player. A team can demand repayment of the signing bonus proration from the current contract year and the remaining years of the deal upon the retirement. If the player doesn’t repay this money, the team can seek an award through arbitration. Johnson’s contract runs through 2016. The Texans could demand $11,364,168 from Johnson if he retired when it should have only been $939,168. Palmer didn’t have to worry about signing bonus recovery because the proration with his 2005 contract extension ended in 2010.