Anyone still think Reggie McNeal can't play QB in the NFL?

Maikeru-sama

Mick Green 58
Messages
14,548
Reaction score
6
sago1 said:
First time I've seen him play & thought he looked real good. He not as big as most would want, but he showed an arm & athletic ability. Doubt he goes any higher then 3rd but performance in combine could move him up/down. He certainly could be solid backup. Actually more athletic then Romo with better arm.


He is 6-2 and goes about 215?

I wonder what the average in the NFL is, just too lazy to look tonight but I bet there are guys playing QB with similar height and weight.

- Mike G.
 

Maikeru-sama

Mick Green 58
Messages
14,548
Reaction score
6
Reggie McNeal QB 6’2 209 Texas A&M
By: Robert Davis

Reggie McNeal entered A&M as one of the elite dual threat QB recruits in the country. He has steadily progressed and is now one of the top dual threat college quarterbacks in the country. McNeal moved into the starting lineup as a sophomore and threw for 1,782 yards, eight touchdowns to seven interceptions, while completing 51.1% of his passes. He added another 370 yards and 4 touchdowns on the ground. McNeal made dramatic improvements just a year later as a junior, finishing the year with a school record 2,791 yards, with 14 touchdowns to just four picks, while completing 58.1% of his passes. On the ground, he ran for 718 yards and eight touchdowns.

McNeal is a big time threat throwing the ball or running it. He has a very good arm, and can make every throw on the football field. He will stand in the pocket and deliver a strike. When things break down, he can leave the pocket and find a receiver, or tuck it and pick up yardage on the ground. McNeal is an awesome athlete, and has excellent speed. He could probably switch to wide receiver at the next level if he has to go that route.

Reggie has made a lot of improvements during his time at A&M, but he still has a ways to go. He still suffers through bouts of inconsistency on the field. His accuracy is up and down at times. He also still forces too many passes. McNeal will need time at the next level to adjust to an NFL playbook and to further develop his passing skills. He could also stand to pack on some weight, as he has a thin build, and is not very big.

There aren’t too many quarterbacks out there with the natural gifts McNeal has. He is a legitimate threat to beat you with his arm or his feet. However, he is going to need time and patience at the next level. If a team is willing to give McNeal time, they may have a big time playmaker on their hands. When the post season comes around, McNeal could amaze some people with his physical ability. But with him still being raw at the QB spot, he likely won’t hear his name called until the 3rd round at the earliest.

http://www.footballsfuture.com/2006/prospects/reggie_mcneal.html

This is what makes this guy so appealing....
 

DanTanna

Original Zone Member
Messages
4,025
Reaction score
3,298
The whole national State of Texas, you know that! :)

I'm biased, but Reggie actually is a pass first, hit the WRs in stride type of QB. His OL during his time at A&M was horrid- his receivers were totally average, and the coaches tried to make him an option QB. Some players actually get better in the pros. I'm no Chis Simms fan, but he's doing great IMO now that he's getting some solid coaching and has a good cast around him. There's no reason why Reggie can't do the same.
 

Shawn9

New Member
Messages
70
Reaction score
0
And for those of yall riding VY Jock. He is Full of potential, but potential only gets you so far. Dont get me wrong being a aggie I tip my hat at VY really gifted athlete. but when everyone was like OMG look what he did to USC's Defense is were the went wrong. USC has a Pac 10 defense which is yea...He wont be able to run like he did in college because the first time he does he is going to get popped.
 

The30YardSlant

Benched
Messages
24,287
Reaction score
0
sago1 said:
First time I've seen him play & thought he looked real good. He not as big as most would want, but he showed an arm & athletic ability. Doubt he goes any higher then 3rd but performance in combine could move him up/down. He certainly could be solid backup. Actually more athletic then Romo with better arm.

More athletic than Romo?

McNeal is more athletic than any QB in the NFL today. Whoever drafts him, he will be the best athlete on that team from day 1.
 

Shawn9

New Member
Messages
70
Reaction score
0
DanTanna said:
The whole national State of Texas, you know that! :)

I'm biased, but Reggie actually is a pass first, hit the WRs in stride type of QB. His OL during his time at A&M was horrid- his receivers were totally average, and the coaches tried to make him an option QB. Some players actually get better in the pros. I'm no Chis Simms fan, but he's doing great IMO now that he's getting some solid coaching and has a good cast around him. There's no reason why Reggie can't do the same.
I agree 100%
 

The30YardSlant

Benched
Messages
24,287
Reaction score
0
If Quincy Carter can be picked in the 2nd round and Chrissy Simms can go in the 3rd round, than McNeal sure as Hell can go in the first 3 rounds.
 

Maikeru-sama

Mick Green 58
Messages
14,548
Reaction score
6
Shawn9 said:
And for those of yall riding VY Jock. He is Full of potential, but potential only gets you so far. Dont get me wrong being a aggie I tip my hat at VY really gifted athlete. but when everyone was like OMG look what he did to USC's Defense is were the went wrong. USC has a Pac 10 defense which is yea...He wont be able to run like he did in college because the first time he does he is going to get popped.

Right....

He was 30-40 with 267 Passing Yards against them also.....

I never understand for the life of me why people have to tear one guy down to lift another guy up.

Merriman cant get props unless Ware is being slammed

Mcneal cant get props unless Young is getting slammed

All these guys are great players....

I am partial to all players from the state of texas

but...

Right now at 7:31 PM CST, Young > Mcneal
 

Shawn9

New Member
Messages
70
Reaction score
0
mickgreen58 said:
Right....

He was 30-40 with 267 Passing Yards against them also.....

I never understand for the life of me why people have to tear one guy down to lift another guy up.

Merriman cant get props unless Ware is being slammed

Mcneal cant get props unless Young is getting slammed

All these guys are great players....

I am partial to all players from the state of texas

but...

Right now at 7:31 PM CST, Young > Mcneal
Yes against a PAC-10 DEFENSE
and i wasnt tearing him down
I said VY is a great gifted athlete
and i think he will do good in the NFL
 

Fla Cowpoke

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,025
Reaction score
12,046
You can't say something good about one guy and let it be left at that. You have to tear down another player in the process.

McNeal is a very good athlete...and I think guys like him are better prepared for an all-star game than some of the more polished players. He chunked up two deep balls that the receivers made good plays on, not a big deal.

The thing that was nice is that he seemed to pick the entire team up when he came in.
 

lane

The Chairman
Messages
13,178
Reaction score
5,557
reggie mcneal has a much better chance of being a successful nfl qb than vince young does.
 

Shawn9

New Member
Messages
70
Reaction score
0
Fla Cowpoke said:
You can't say something good about one guy and let it be left at that. You have to tear down another player in the process.

McNeal is a very good athlete...and I think guys like him are better prepared for an all-star game than some of the more polished players. He chunked up two deep balls that the receivers made good plays on, not a big deal.

The thing that was nice is that he seemed to pick the entire team up when he came in.
I hope your not talking about the one to Jason carter as one of the deep balls
 

Maikeru-sama

Mick Green 58
Messages
14,548
Reaction score
6
Fla Cowpoke said:
You can't say something good about one guy and let it be left at that. You have to tear down another player in the process.

McNeal is a very good athlete...and I think guys like him are better prepared for an all-star game than some of the more polished players. He chunked up two deep balls that the receivers made good plays on, not a big deal.

The thing that was nice is that he seemed to pick the entire team up when he came in.

Yep, Mcneal is a very blessed and talented passer and scrambler. His passing skills are alot further along than Vince Young's passing, that is just an observation and a layman's eye.

I dont think we draft the guy if he is available, heck I dont think we would draft Matt Leinhart if he was available, but Mcneal would provide alot for this offense.

Here is some of the things he could contribute while being groomed for the QB position.

-His speed would help on special teams
-Put him at Wideout on occassion for Reverses, Wide Receiver Passes and Hitch Routes.

This guy could be a steal. Has the talent of a bonafide 1st Rounder imo, but could possibly be had in the 3rd round or so.

Oh and yeah, I dont understand why one guy has to get a good kick in the teeth so another guy can be promoted.

- Mike G.
 

Fla Cowpoke

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,025
Reaction score
12,046
I hope your not talking about the one to Jason carter as one of the deep balls

And what if I am? The fact that he was throwing to a guy he has played with for how many years certainly worked in his favor didn't it? All star games are exactly where a Vince Young or Reggie McNeal can be at their best...because they are the best athletes on the field and they are playing against basic defenses.

His work during the regular season means much, much more to me than stats in an all star game.

I am not slamming McNeal. He had a nice game. He will put up nice numbers at the combine. He could be a good developmental project.

But there have been thousands of great athletes that never became great pros. The reasons aren't always the same, but things happen. I'd love to see him become a Steve Young or John Elway type. Good passer and good scrambler.

BTW, was Parcells at any of the workouts? Anyone know? I want him to be as involved in the draft this year as he was last year.
 

hh8604

New Member
Messages
95
Reaction score
0
as an A&M fan I have watched Reggie the last several years play some amazing football and manage to put up some good numbers with not so great teams...he has shown the ability to make any throw on the field with his rocket arm and pick apart a secondary, most of the time while he was doing this he was on the run due to lack of a good o-line...if he has no one open downfield he can take off and out run anyone (and I mean anyone) the only time I ever saw someone catch up to him was in this years game against Clemson and the guy who ran him down happened to be CB Tye Hill the ACC 100 meter champion...but as someone stated above, the interesting thing about Reggie is that he doesn't look to run first even though he has the unbelievable ability to...anyways this guy is an amazing QB and will play QB in the NFL not WR, not with his arm strength, accuracy, shiftiness in the pocket, and due to the fact that he doesn't look to run first like most dual threat QB'...in the NFL I think he will gain some muscle weight and eventually will be a similar QB to Donovan McNabb...if you want to see some highlights from this year check out agclips.com
 

Tio

Armchair QB
Messages
5,344
Reaction score
339
HeavyHitta31 said:
The guy did far more in college than half the starting QBs in the NFL right now. What an ignorant statement. :rolleyes:
List the half...
 

parchy

Active Member
Messages
2,256
Reaction score
3
HeavyHitta31 said:
Well hell, I guess we should never draft colleg eplayers again, seeing as how they are forced to play against such pathetic collegiate compitition. :rolleyes:

I swear some of you have never sat through a football game in your lives.

Way to put words in my mouth and overreact. But I guess you kind of have to to support your flimsy argument.

So you're saying that one game defines him as NFL-ready despite an entire season (and career, really) of underachieving? The NFL is very different from college, if you haven't noticed, and in the grand scheme one game doesn't mean much.
 

Tio

Armchair QB
Messages
5,344
Reaction score
339
HeavyHitta31 said:
More athletic than Romo?

McNeal is more athletic than any QB in the NFL today. Whoever drafts him, he will be the best athlete on that team from day 1.
I see you are back on his jock...
 
Top