As of right now in the NFL is Tony Romo a Top Five qb?

[Cover 2]

1. Peyton
2. Brady
3. Big Ben
4. Romo
5. Rivers

End of thread.

Would you trade Romo for Big Ben?

 

[SharutoX]

#1 Peyton Manning
#2 Drew Brees
#3 Tom Brady
#4 Tony Romo
#5 Favre/Warner

 

[NextGenBoys]

My list is the following..



1. Peyton Manning, he's clutch and he's won alot of big games, he has 1 super bowl and his numbers are unreal. On top of that he rarely throws int's or takes sacks. He's one of the most accurate qb's of all time. Not to mention he's basically another coach on the field. a great leader , I Really think there is no question he's number one.

2. Tom brady, 3 super bowls , a great leader, great numbers.

3. Big Ben, The thing I like about him is he's so very clutch, when it matter's most he finds a way to win.

4. Phillip Rivers ... River's just has that it factor, he's going to be a great player for years to come.


5. Tony Romo, I put him ahead right now as we speak ahead of bree's , warner, mcnabb, favre . The reason being to me there's not another guy in the league who's the playmaker Romo is . Even when a play totally breaks down he can sometimes find a way to make it a conversion or even a touchdown. Hes really growing right now as a qb and is learning to cut down on his bad throws. I really like him going forward from here on out .

You have to put Drew Brees on that list.

It's not even a debate.

1. Peyton
2. Brady
3. Brees
4. Romo
5. Rivers/Ben cant decide

 

[THUMPER]

They say quarterbacks are judged by championships,nothing else matters.I don't think Romo is a top 5 player at his position,I also think that he is better than Warner who has won a championship.

Craig

Well, "they" are wrong.

 

[VietCowboy]

I HATE the steelers. I also really hate Big Ben. If he was not a Steeler QB, he would be at best Orton.

Top 5 active QBs would be:

1) Peyton
2) Brady
3) Favre
4) Brees
5) Romo

 

[DallasEast]

1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Drew Brees
4. Ben Roethlisberger
5. Philip Rivers
6. Kurt Warner
7. Brett Favre
8. Aaron Rodgers
9. Eli Manning
10. Carson Palmer.


Nope. Not even top 10.

20. Mark Sanchez
21. Matt Hasselbeck
22. Matthew Stafford
23. Matt Cassel
24. Marc Bulger
25. Trent Edwards
26. Chad Henne
27. Kerry Collins
28. JaMarcus Russell
29. Shaun Hill
30. Derek Anderson
31. Jason Campbell
32. Josh Freeman

Nope. Not even top 30.

 

[terrifNick21]

give me that defense and i'll win 8 games with that team. 1 of those superbowls he had the worst qb rating ever by a qb who's team won. the 2nd was the refs stopped calling the Stealers for holding. go back and watch some Stealer games from last year. they couldn't pass protect for **** than all of a sudden they can protect for 10 seconds while ben runs back and forth till one of his crappy wrs gets open. they also all of a sudden stopped commiting any penalties. Trent Dilfer,Brad Johnson and Eli Manning also won superbowls. that doesn't make them top 5 qbs.

Worst rating or not, fact is he won.

Stopped calling the Steelers for holding? Where's the proof? You're just reaching for bogus things now.

I watched a ton of Steelers games last season. The fact that he got his team so far with such a "bad" o-line is remarkable.

Crappy receivers? The one that was Super Bowl MVP? The one that's better than any receiver Dallas fields? You talking about Santonio Holmes? Haha. I wonder how you feel about the Cowboys receivers if you think Holmes is crappy.

Did Dilfer win 2? Check no.
Has Eli won 2? Uhhhmm, no.
How bout Brad Johnson? He won only won one also.

Ben is a top 5 QB no matter how much you dislike him.

 

[terrifNick21]

20. Mark Sanchez
21. Matt Hasselbeck
22. Matthew Stafford
23. Matt Cassel
24. Marc Bulger
25. Trent Edwards
26. Chad Henne
27. Kerry Collins
28. JaMarcus Russell
29. Shaun Hill
30. Derek Anderson
31. Jason Campbell
32. Josh Freeman

Nope. Not even top 30.

What?

 

[Rampage]

Worst rating or not, fact is he won.

Stopped calling the Steelers for holding? Where's the proof? You're just reaching for bogus things now.

I watched a ton of Steelers games last season. The fact that he got his team so far with such a "bad" o-line is remarkable.

Crappy receivers? The one that was Super Bowl MVP? The one that's better than any receiver Dallas fields? You talking about Santonio Holmes? Haha. I wonder how you feel about the Cowboys receivers if you think Holmes is crappy.

Did Dilfer win 2? Check no.
Has Eli won 2? Uhhhmm, no.
How bout Brad Johnson? He won only won one also.

Ben is a top 5 QB no matter how much you dislike him.

what was remarkable was how his o-line went from crap to gold in a 2 week span. i'm not gonna go through all the games just to prove a point to you. and those wrs couldn't get open last season unless Ben was running back and forth behind his o-line that all of a sudden could pass protect. just go watch some games next time you have some free time or are just bored. you'll see what i'm saying I guarantee it.

 

[Skinsmaniac]

I love these threads, and I don't care if they appear every three weeks.

1. Manning
2. Brees
3. Rivers
4. Brady (based on the last three games, he'd be #2, but I'm still not convinced he's the Brady of old)
5. Rodgers
6. Ben
7. Favre (the thowing injury is coming folks just be patient)
8. Romo
9. Schaub
10. Warner

 

[Jenky]

20. Mark Sanchez
21. Matt Hasselbeck
22. Matthew Stafford
23. Matt Cassel
24. Marc Bulger
25. Trent Edwards
26. Chad Henne
27. Kerry Collins
28. JaMarcus Russell
29. Shaun Hill
30. Derek Anderson
31. Jason Campbell
32. Josh Freeman

Nope. Not even top 30.

No way dude. Hes better than Jamarcus. At least give them that!

 

[DallasEast]

No way dude. Hes better than Jamarcus. At least give them that!

Sure thing.



Nah.

 

[terrifNick21]

what was remarkable was how his o-line went from crap to gold in a 2 week span. i'm not gonna go through all the games just to prove a point to you. and those wrs couldn't get open last season unless Ben was running back and forth behind his o-line that all of a sudden could pass protect. just go watch some games next time you have some free time or are just bored. you'll see what i'm saying I guarantee it.

Who said they were gold?

And you don't have to go through the games because as I said, you're reaching for points.

And you're one to talk about Ben running behind his line. That's pretty much all Romo does, and although he does, he's top 5. Lmao. Whew. Hilarity borderline ingnorant.

 

[Rampage]

Who said they were gold?

And you don't have to go through the games because as I said, you're reaching for points.

And you're one to talk about Ben running behind his line. That's pretty much all Romo does, and although he does, he's top 5. Lmao. Whew. Hilarity borderline ingnorant.

i'm not reaching. if you really want to get to the bottom of this watch the games. Romo has to run because our o-line isn't as good as people think. now Ben was running around BEHIND his o-line while protected atleast he did last season after they all of a sudden could protect and all of a sudden no longer committed penalties. Romo runs around because the protection breaks down.

 

[Joe Realist]

Not sure. If Pro Bowl was not voted by fans, he would be 4th in NFC behind Brees, Farve and Rodgers

 

[terrifNick21]

i'm not reaching. if you really want to get to the bottom of this watch the games. Romo has to run because our o-line isn't as good as people think. now Ben was running around BEHIND his o-line while protected atleast he did last season after they all of a sudden could protect and all of a sudden no longer committed penalties. Romo runs around because the protection breaks down.

I do watch the games. Ben stands in the pocket until the protection breaks down and then he has no choice but to scramble and make plays. And hypothetically let's say he DOES run behind his o-line, how does that make him not top 5?

 

[Clarkson]

1.Peyton Manning
2.Brady
3.Brees
4.Rivers
5.Favre
6.Romo

How can someone say Palmer is better than Romo? Romo is having a better season and has for last like 3 years. Big Ben isn't better than Romo.

 

[terrifNick21]

Big Ben isn't better than Romo.

Yes, he is.

 

[JBond]

1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Drew Brees
4. Ben Roethlisberger
5. Philip Rivers
6. Kurt Warner
7. Brett Favre
8. Aaron Rodgers
9. Eli Manning
10. Carson Palmer.


Nope. Not even top 10.

You know you are going to be crucified for this.

I do not agree with your list. Romo should be between 4 and 7 in my opinion. Not the very best in the league but good enough to win the big one if everything else is in place.

 

[Skinsmaniac]

You know you are going to be crucified for this.

I do not agree with your list. Romo should be between 4 and 7 in my opinion. Not the very best in the league but good enough to win the big one if everything else is in place.

The thing is, do you think he can go three or four games in a row, against the NFL's best, without an implosion? I made a bet with my friend seven or eight years ago that McNabb would never win a SB. In that case, I knew that McNabb couldn't go 3 or 4 games in a row without his accuracy issues surfacing. With Romo it's more about the giveaways, but same idea.