bbgun said:
Yes, they are fallible, but here are four biggies they supposedly got wrong:
1) TO telling them he was depressed
The report never said that. According to the report, Etheredge said Owens told her that he was depressed.
2) TO telling them he tried to harm himself
He also told them he took the rest of his hydrocodone -- 35 pills. From everything I've read, if he HAD taken 35 hydrocodone pills, he wouldn't have been able to respond coherently to any questions then, let alone get out of the hospital the next morning without any apparent adverse effects. If he had taken 35 hydrocodone, he's a medical miracle. If not, then both of his answers would have to be regarded as unfactual.
3) publicist telling them TO was depressed
Like I said, that's the same as No. 1. Remember, at the time, she thought he had taken 35 hydrocodone pills. If he had mentioned anything about being sad that he couldn't celebrate his son's birthday with him, or about his breakup, she might have interpreted that as being "depressed," when the officers asked her about him. The officers might have even been paraphrasing her comments. They might have asked her something like, "Did he seem depressed, or did he have any emotional issues recently?" And she reasonably could have told them that he has said he was feeling down because of the situations with his son and fiancee, and the officer could have simply written "RP stated that comp stated that he was depressed." There's no direct quote there, so we don't know if "depressed" was the officer's word, her word or Owens' word. At any rate, that doesn't mean he was clinically depressed or suicidal.
4) publicist telling them she removed extra pills from his mouth
First of all, the report doesn't say that, either. It says she "attempted to put her fingers in comp's mouth to retrieve the pills." And she didn't deny attempting to do it, she just said she didn't take anything out of his mouth. That doesn't contradict the report. But I don't even see this part as an issue. Whether she did or didn't doesn't affect whether he intentionally took 35 hydrocodone pills or simply had a bad reaction to four or five.
They got every one of these wrong?? Why would they tell so many serial lies?
Nobody said the police were lying. They could have misinterpreted or paraphrased what was said, or they could have been given incorrect information. If you think an initial police report of a 911 call is going to be completely accurate when one of the two people questioned was in a state of decreased consciousness and the other thought he had taken 35 pain pills, you're mistaken.
The bottom line is that there's no evidence that he took 35 pills, and all of the known evidence indicates that he did not.