Best QB Game

[MCowboys]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 54
John Elway 33
Otto Graham 34 +
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 19
Brett Favre 9 -
Tom Brady 5

 

[Eskimo]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 54
John Elway 34+
Otto Graham 34
Troy Aikman 31-
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 19
Brett Favre 9
Tom Brady 5

 

[jackrussell]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 54
John Elway 34
Otto Graham 35+
Troy Aikman 31
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 19
Brett Favre 8-
Tom Brady 5

 

[Rackat]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 54
John Elway 34
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 32 +
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 19
Brett Favre 7 -
Tom Brady 5

 

[boba5555]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 55+
John Elway 34
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 19
Brett Favre 7
Tom Brady 4-

 

[pancakeman]

Roger Staubach 56-
Joe Montana 55
John Elway 34
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 20+
Brett Favre 7
Tom Brady 4

 

[cowboyuptx]

The homerism here is ridiculous! AND GET BRETT FAVRE THE HELL OUTTA HERE!

There's no way in hell, that Tom Brady should be eliminated before Brett Favre! You're heading into the playoffs, who do you want at QB, Tom Brady, or Brett Favre? Anyone who doesn't say Tom Brady is a football moron!

And it should be close between Brady, Aikman, and Young! Y'all eliminated Steve Young a little too quick, imo... Young didn't have as near the overall career that Favre did, but Favre even in his prime, never scared me, I was always more worried about Young and the '9ers, he was the real deal!

Brett Favre, has single-handedly lost a lot more big games than he's won! He's always been waaayy overrated! Time and again, late 4th quarter, Favre throws an interception! And never just an unfortunate interception, but the kind of interception that leaves you wondering, WHAT THE HELL WAS HE THINKING?!?! Or maybe you'll get real lucky, and he'll just have one of his patented 4 interception games. He's a great ambassador for the game, but overrated as a QB! Never should have won 3 MVPs! That's like Roy Williams being a perenial Pro Bowler...

Joe Montana 55
John Elway 34
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 19
Brett Favre 6-
Tom Brady 5+

 

[Carl23]

Ditto what ^he^ said. Cept I'd rather see Marino pick up one.

Aikman better than Young? come on people, get real.

Joe Montana 55
John Elway 34
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 20+
Brett Favre 5-
Tom Brady 5

 

[adamknite]

The homerism here is ridiculous! AND GET BRETT FAVRE THE HELL OUTTA HERE!

There's no way in hell, that Tom Brady should be eliminated before Brett Favre! You're heading into the playoffs, who do you want at QB, Tom Brady, or Brett Favre? Anyone who doesn't say Tom Brady is a football moron!

And it should be close between Brady, Aikman, and Young! Y'all eliminated Steve Young a little too quick, imo... Young didn't have as near the overall career that Favre did, but Favre even in his prime, never scared me, I was always more worried about Young and the '9ers, he was the real deal!

Brett Favre, has single-handedly lost a lot more big games than he's won! He's always been waaayy overrated! Time and again, late 4th quarter, Favre throws an interception! And never just an unfortunate interception, but the kind of interception that leaves you wondering, WHAT THE HELL WAS HE THINKING?!?! Or maybe you'll get real lucky, and he'll just have one of his patented 4 interception games. He's a great ambassador for the game, but overrated as a QB! Never should have won 3 MVPs! That's like Roy Williams being a perenial Pro Bowler...

Joe Montana 55
John Elway 34
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 19
Brett Favre 6-
Tom Brady 5+

............ it's just a game.

Joe Montana 55
John Elway 35+
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 20
Brett Favre 5
Tom Brady 4-

 

[THUMPER]

Roger Staubach 56
Joe Montana 55
John Elway 35
Otto Graham 36+
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 20
Brett Favre 4-
Tom Brady 4

 

[Hostile]

Roger Staubach got dropped accidentally. I put him back in.

Roger Staubach 56
Joe Montana 55
John Elway 36 +
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 31 -
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 20
Brett Favre 5
Tom Brady 4

 

[THUMPER]

Roger Staubach got dropped accidentally. I put him back in.

Roger Staubach 56
Joe Montana 55
John Elway 36
Otto Graham 36
Troy Aikman 31
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 20
Brett Favre 4
Tom Brady 4

Updated...

 

[adamknite]

Roger Staubach 56
Joe Montana 55
John Elway 36
Otto Graham 36
Troy Aikman 31
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 20
Brett Favre 4
Tom Brady 4

Updated...

I think Dan Marino should be at 21 points he got 20+'ed twice.

 

[Royal Laegotti]

Joe Montana 55
John Elway 35
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 27-
Dan Marino 20
Brett Favre 5
Tom Brady 5+

 

[rcaldw]

Joe Montana 55
John Elway 34-
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 33 +
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 27
Dan Marino 20
Brett Favre 5
Tom Brady 5

 

[cowboyfreak]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 55
John Elway 34
Otto Graham 35
Troy Aikman 33
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 27
Dan Marino 20
Brett Favre 5
Tom Brady 4

Why was Roger kicked off the last couple times?

 

[THUMPER]

Updated again...

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 55
John Elway 35
Otto Graham 36
Troy Aikman 33
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 27
Dan Marino 21
Brett Favre 4
Tom Brady 4

 

[rcaldw]

Updated again...

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 55
John Elway 35
Otto Graham 36
Troy Aikman 33
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 27
Dan Marino 21
Brett Favre 4
Tom Brady 4

Hey Thump, I thought we could only vote once per day?

 

[THUMPER]

Hey Thump, I thought we could only vote once per day?

I did, I was just making adjustments to the list because some folks had copied it incorrectly or posted at the same time.

 

[rcaldw]

I did, I was just making adjustments to the list because some folks had copied it incorrectly or posted at the same time.

Gotcha. How did Elway go from 34 (after my vote) to 35 again?