Best QB Game

[THUMPER]

Gotcha. How did Elway go from 34 (after my vote) to 35 again?

Because he was at 36 after Hostile's vote. You had copied a previous list when he was at 35.

 

[rcaldw]

Because he was at 36 after Hostile's vote. You had copied a previous list when he was at 35.

Ah, I can see that now. Thanks.

 

[LeonDixson]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 55
John Elway 35
Otto Graham 37+
Troy Aikman 33
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 27
Dan Marino 21
Brett Favre 3-
Tom Brady 4

 

[THUMPER]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 55
John Elway 35
Otto Graham 37+
Troy Aikman 33
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 27
Dan Marino 21
Brett Favre 3-
Tom Brady 4

Looks like the guy with all the stats is almost gone.

 

[rguido]

Gotcha. How did Elway go from 34 (after my vote) to 35 again?

Thats it!!! This game is rigged.... Who is paying you Thumper???

I think we need to have congress look into your dealings and hire an independant council....

 

[Skinsmaniac]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 56+
John Elway 35
Otto Graham 37
Troy Aikman 33
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 27
Dan Marino 21
Brett Favre 2-
Tom Brady 4

 

[AdamJT13]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 56
Otto Graham 37
John Elway 34-
Troy Aikman 33
Johnny Unitas 31+
Peyton Manning 27
Dan Marino 21
Tom Brady 4
Brett Favre 2

 

[dboyz]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 56
Otto Graham 37
John Elway 34
Troy Aikman 33
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 27
Dan Marino 22+
Tom Brady 4
Brett Favre 1-

My position on Favre is that although he had a great career, if I'm lining up to win one game, Favre is at the bottom of the list. He would make great plays out of nothing in his prime could carry and average team. But if you have a championship caliber team, I'd rather have someone who didn't make so many key mistakes.

 

[DallasFanSince86]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 56
Otto Graham 37
John Elway 34
Troy Aikman 33
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28 +
Dan Marino 22
Tom Brady 3 -
Brett Favre 1

 

[Chuck 54]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 56
Otto Graham 37
John Elway 35+
Troy Aikman 32-
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 22
Tom Brady 3
Brett Favre 1[/QUOTE]

 

[rojan]

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 56
Otto Graham 37
John Elway 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 31
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 21-
Tom Brady 4+
Brett Favre 1

 

[jackrussell]

Adjustment made....adam voted for Unitas...but didn't add the one point.

Roger Staubach 57
Joe Montana 56
Otto Graham 37
John Elway 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 32
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 21
Tom Brady 4
Brett Favre 1

 

[DT101]

Roger Staubach 58+
Joe Montana 56
Otto Graham 37
John Elway 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 32
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 21
Tom Brady 3-
Brett Favre 1

Brady=Most overrated quarterback in the NFL by far. People say he may be the best of all time and I call BS. Put him on another team and I doubt he does as well. By all means, a good quarterback, but a pro-bowl at BEST, and not deserving of this list.

 

[Pukindog]

Roger Staubach 59 +
Joe Montana 55 -
Otto Graham 37
John Elway 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 32
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 21
Tom Brady 3
Brett Favre 1

 

[Wolfpack]

Roger Staubach 59
Joe Montana 55
Otto Graham 38 +
John Elway 35
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 32
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 20 -
Tom Brady 3
Brett Favre 1

 

[Echo9]

Roger Staubach 59
Joe Montana 55
Otto Graham 38
John Elway 36 +
Troy Aikman 32
Johnny Unitas 32
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 20
Tom Brady 2-
Brett Favre 1

 

[ABQcowboyJR]

Roger Staubach 59
Joe Montana 55
Otto Graham 38
John Elway 36
Troy Aikman 33 PLUS!!
Johnny Unitas 32
Peyton Manning 28
Dan Marino 20
Tom Brady 1-
Brett Favre 1

 

[THUMPER]

Come on people, we need to get rid of Favre already!

 

[peplaw06]

I'm all for homering it up every now and then, and part of that includes hating all things Pats...

But IMO there's no explanation for Manning being so high and Brady in danger of dropping off the list.

 

[dalboy]

Roger Staubach 59
Joe Montana 55
Otto Graham 38
John Elway 36
Troy Aikman 34
Johnny Unitas 32
Peyton Manning 27
Dan Marino 20
Tom Brady 1-
Brett Favre 1