Best QB Game

[Pukindog]

Roger Staubach 69 +
Joe Montana 61 -
Otto Graham 48
Troy Aikman 37
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 33
Peyton Manning 11
Dan Marino 5

 

[kTXe]

Roger Staubach 69
Joe Montana 62 +
Otto Graham 48
Troy Aikman 36 -
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 33
Peyton Manning 11
Dan Marino 5

 

[mmillman]

Roger Staubach 69
Joe Montana 62 -
Otto Graham 48
Troy Aikman 36 -
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 33+
Peyton Manning 11
Dan Marino 5

 

[LeonDixson]

Roger Staubach 69
Joe Montana 62
Otto Graham 49+
Troy Aikman 36
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 33
Peyton Manning 10-
Dan Marino 5


edit: I still can't imagine how Steve Young made it onto the original list and Bart Starr did not. Crazy.

 

[jackrussell]

edit: I still can't imagine how Steve Young made it onto the original list and Bart Starr did not. Crazy.

I can't figure how you've voted for about 3 different guys as the best QB on the list either.

 

[Echo9]

Roger Staubach 686540
Joe Montana 61
Otto Graham 47
Troy Aikman 38
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 33
Peyton Manning 13
Dan Marino -10

I'm a superdelegate, it's ok....

Now that was actually quite funny!

 

[dmoore]

Roger Staubach 69
Joe Montana 62
Otto Graham 49
Troy Aikman 36
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 34+
Peyton Manning 9-
Dan Marino 5

 

[Skinsmaniac]

Roger Staubach 69
Joe Montana 63+
Otto Graham 49
Troy Aikman 36
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 34
Peyton Manning 9
Dan Marino 4-

 

[DallasFanSince86]

Roger Staubach 69
Joe Montana 64+
Otto Graham 49
Troy Aikman 36
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 33-
Peyton Manning 9
Dan Marino 4

 

[nathanlt]

Now that was actually quite funny!

And for a while there, it seemed no one would notice! Thanks, I'm glad you had a chuckle.

 

[Eskimo]

Roger Staubach 69
Joe Montana 64
Otto Graham 49
Troy Aikman 35-
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 34+
Peyton Manning 9
Dan Marino 4



I have been fairly silent for the most part here but I find it hard to believe that many of us believe Troy Aikman was better than Tom Brady, Peyton Manning and Dan Marino.

The one thing he did do better than anyone was accuracy on medium depth passes - probably the best ever. The other parts of his game don't compare favourably with the others on the list.

 

[DT101]

Roger Staubach 70+
Joe Montana 64
Otto Graham 49
Troy Aikman 35
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 34
Peyton Manning 8-
Dan Marino 4

Lets get Roger 70

 

[LeonDixson]

I can't figure how you've voted for about 3 different guys as the best QB on the list either.

Did I hit a nerve? Sorry. I've voted for different QBs to try to keep the list balanced in my opinion only. It would be inconsistent if I voted for a QB I've already given a minus to or vice versa. If I'm messing up your game, I'll drop out.

 

[Pukindog]

Roger Staubach 71 +
Joe Montana 63 -
Otto Graham 49
Troy Aikman 35
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 34
Peyton Manning 8
Dan Marino 4

 

[Zaxor]

Roger Staubach 71
Joe Montana 63
Otto Graham 50+
Troy Aikman 34-
Johnny Unitas 36
John Elway 34
Peyton Manning 8
Dan Marino 4

 

[AdamJT13]

Roger Staubach 71
Joe Montana 63
Otto Graham 50
Johnny Unitas 37+
Troy Aikman 34
John Elway 33-
Peyton Manning 8
Dan Marino 4

 

[jackrussell]

Did I hit a nerve? Sorry. I've voted for different QBs to try to keep the list balanced in my opinion only. It would be inconsistent if I voted for a QB I've already given a minus to or vice versa. If I'm messing up your game, I'll drop out.

Hit a nerve? Good grief dude I just asked you a question. Relax...just couldn't figure how one day you'd think one QB was best then the next you'd think another would be the best...and then another.

I was curious...that's why I asked. Geez.

(and no...I don't want you to drop...and no, I don't think it's inconsistant to vote for the same guy each time, but rather the opposite. It's an elimination game, not a balancing act))

 

[jackrussell]

Roger Staubach 71
Joe Montana 63
Otto Graham 51+
Johnny Unitas 37
Troy Aikman 34
John Elway 33
Peyton Manning 7-
Dan Marino 4

 

[Wolfpack]

Roger Staubach 71
Joe Montana 64 +
Otto Graham 51
Johnny Unitas 37
Troy Aikman 34
John Elway 33
Peyton Manning 6-
Dan Marino 4

 

[DallasEast]

Roger Staubach 72+
Joe Montana 64
Otto Graham 51
Johnny Unitas 37
Troy Aikman 34
John Elway 33
Peyton Manning 5-
Dan Marino 4