Best QB Game

[dmoore]

I wouldn't until it got to be Elway vs. Montana and then only to be consistent. I think Elway is the best QB ever to play the game. I respect other opinions though. That's why I haven't questioned anyone's opinions. Staubach is my all time favorite player and if he had not had to give 5 years to the US Navy I might rank him above Elway and Montana. But as it stands I have always had him as 3rd behind them.

That's pretty much my thinking. I'm not sure if we'll ever see another QB as physically gifted as Elway. It wasn't all about his ability either, he knew how to translate his skills into success on the football field.


Roger Staubach 73
Joe Montana 64
Otto Graham 51
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 33
John Elway 37+
Peyton Manning 2-
Dan Marino 3

 

[TellerMorrow34]

Roger Staubach 73
Joe Montana 64
Otto Graham 51
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 33
John Elway 37
Peyton Manning 3+
Dan Marino 2-

 

[Skinsmaniac]

Roger Staubach 73
Joe Montana 65+
Otto Graham 51
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 32-
John Elway 37
Peyton Manning 3
Dan Marino 2

 

[Cowboy Bill Watts]

Everyone can have his own opinion, of course, but I'd be curious to know why people would give Joe Montana a minus.

chocolate, i don't deny montana his place in NFL history. i do think he was the epitome of a system quarterback. whether or not he could accomplish the things he accomplished elsewhere is at least debateable (in my opinion).

montana is deserving of the 64 votes he has here. however, having watched all of the dodger's career i personally don't think anyone else is close to him (even when th 5-yr military stint is accounted for).

i start an expansion franchise today, i put roger under center. i want to win one game, i win or lose with the dodger.

and you're right, it is just an opinion...


p.s. while aikman was very good, i'm not sure i see him in this lofty company...

 

[jackrussell]

I know Hos, I even contemplated sending you a private message negotiating a different AGAINST vote until we get further along in the process so we could help our guys out!!!!

Negotiations...I love it!

 

[DallasFanSince86]

Roger Staubach 73
Joe Montana 66+
Otto Graham 51
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 32
John Elway 37
Peyton Manning 3
Dan Marino 1-

 

[Eskimo]

Roger Staubach 73
Joe Montana 66
Otto Graham 51
John Elway 38+
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 31-
Peyton Manning 3
Dan Marino 1

 

[Luther]

Roger Staubach 72-
Joe Montana 67+
Otto Graham 51
John Elway 38+
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 31-
Peyton Manning 3
Dan Marino 1

 

[ajk23az]

Roger Staubach 72
Joe Montana 68+
Otto Graham 51
John Elway 38
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 31
Peyton Manning 2-
Dan Marino 1

 

[Jimz31]

Roger Staubach 72
Joe Montana 67-
Otto Graham 52+
John Elway 38
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 31
Peyton Manning 2
Dan Marino 1

 

[nathanlt]

Roger Staubach 73
Joe Montana 67
Otto Graham 52
John Elway 38
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 31
Peyton Manning 2

See ya ! Dan Marino -0

 

[Zaxor]

Roger Staubach 73
Joe Montana 67
Otto Graham 53 +
John Elway 38
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 30 -
Peyton Manning 2

 

[Achozen]

Roger Staubach 72 -
Joe Montana 67
Otto Graham 54 +
John Elway 38
Johnny Unitas 36
Troy Aikman 30
Peyton Manning 2

 

[AdamJT13]

Roger Staubach 72
Joe Montana 67
Otto Graham 54
Johnny Unitas 37+
John Elway 37-
Troy Aikman 30
Peyton Manning 2

 

[THUMPER]

Roger Staubach 72
Joe Montana 67
Otto Graham 55 +
Johnny Unitas 37
John Elway 37
Troy Aikman 30
Peyton Manning 1 -

 

[jackrussell]

Roger Staubach 72
Joe Montana 67
Otto Graham 56 +
Johnny Unitas 37
John Elway 37
Troy Aikman 30
Peyton Manning 0 -

And then there was 6.

 

[jackrussell]

Correct list as of 6am EST Tues.

Roger Staubach 72
Joe Montana 67
Otto Graham 56
Johnny Unitas 37
John Elway 37
Troy Aikman 30

 

[THUMPER]

Correct list as of 6am EST Tues.

Roger Staubach 72
Joe Montana 67
Otto Graham 56
Johnny Unitas 37
John Elway 37
Troy Aikman 30

The top 4 here are all in my top-5: 1. Graham, 2. Unitas, 3. Staubach, 4. Baugh, 5. Montana (only Sammy Baugh is missing and he wasn't a contestant in this game).

 

[Wolfpack]

Roger Staubach 72
Joe Montana 68+
Otto Graham 56
Johnny Unitas 37
John Elway 36 -
Troy Aikman 30

 

[Cowboy Bill Watts]

Roger Staubach 73+
Joe Montana 67-
Otto Graham 56
Johnny Unitas 37
John Elway 36
Troy Aikman 30