Best QB Game

[DallasDomination]

Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21 +1
John Elway 21
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 22
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 25
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 15
Jim Kelly 10
Warren Moon 7 -1
Dan Fouts 18

 

[THUMPER]

Somehow Unitas got dropped off a while back. This is current...

Johnny Unitas 21
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 21
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 22
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 25
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 15
Jim Kelly 10
Warren Moon 7
Dan Fouts 18

 

[jackrussell]

Somehow Unitas got dropped off a while back. This is current...

Good find..thanks.

Good time to point out that once a player hits 0.....he is to get no other considerations and is out. Obviously, Moon is heading there fast...so once he gets 0, his name will be removed.

 

[Wolfpack]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 21
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 22
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 25
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 15
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 7
Dan Fouts 18

 

[cowboyfreak]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 22
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 22
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 25
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 15
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 6
Dan Fouts 18

 

[ABQcowboyJR]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 22
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 25
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 15
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 6
Dan Fouts 18


As much as I wanted to throw Aikman up there. Elway was something else

 

[kTXe]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 19
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 22
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 25
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 15
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 5
Dan Fouts 18

 

[pancakeman]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 23 +1
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 25
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 15
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 5 -1
Dan Fouts 18

 

[Echo9]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 19
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 22
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 25
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 15
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 5
Dan Fouts 18

You picked Steve Young as the best on that whole list?

Really?

Hey everyone! Steve Young's Mom posts on our Board!

 

[kTXe]

You picked Steve Young as the best on that whole list?

Really?

Hey everyone! Steve Young's Mom posts on our Board!

LOL, I knew my post was going to get that kind of reaction.

Consider it more of a statement vote than anything. Do I think that he is the best QB of all time? Probably not. But I do think that his greatness has been undervalued since he retired. He was a remarkably efficient runner and passer (admittedly facilitated by his play in the WCO).

I've seen him badmouthed enough on this board, especially around the time of his HoF induction, and I can't really understand it.

 

[kmd24]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 26
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 14
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 5
Dan Fouts 18

 

[ABQcowboyJR]

LOL, I knew my post was going to get that kind of reaction.

Consider it more of a statement vote than anything. Do I think that he is the best QB of all time? Probably not. But I do think that his greatness has been undervalued since he retired. He was a remarkably efficient runner and passer (admittedly facilitated by his play in the WCO).

I've seen him badmouthed enough on this board, especially around the time of his HoF induction, and I can't really understand it.

He is a sword fighter thats why. Maybe we are bitter about the NFC championship game still. We shoulda won.

 

[EveryoneElse]

I am shocked that Moon has recieved the most negative hits.

Moon would have shattered every passing record if he would have played his entire career in the NFL.

This was a cool thread idea though.

 

[Dodger]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 27+
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 13-
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 5
Dan Fouts 18

 

[jmac]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 22 -1
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 20+1
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 27+
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 13-
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 5
Dan Fouts 18

 

[Skinsmaniac]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 22
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 25
Roger Staubach 27
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 13
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 4
Dan Fouts 18

This is not another vote. It looked to me like pancakeman forgot to subtract one for warren moon, so I updated it.

 

[The Panch]

I am shocked that Moon has recieved the most negative hits.

Moon would have shattered every passing record if he would have played his entire career in the NFL.

This was a cool thread idea though.

I agree. Maybe it's a Houston/Dallas thing, but that's pretty lame so many people have him at the bottom. He was a great quarterback.

 

[ajk23az]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 22
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 29
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 26 +1
Roger Staubach 27
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 13
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 3 -1
Dan Fouts 18

 

[The Panch]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 22
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 30 +
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 26
Roger Staubach 27
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 12 -1
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 3
Dan Fouts 18

 

[jackrussell]

Johnny Unitas 22
Otto Graham 22
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 23
Joe Montana 31+
Steve Young 18
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 26
Roger Staubach 27
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 12
Jim Kelly 9
Warren Moon 2-
Dan Fouts 18

Once a day votes folks.

And if I can ask whenever Moon hits 0 that the NEXT poster remove his name from their list.

We will also be running it down to the top 2...so we have our starter and 2nd team guy.