Best QB Game

gollum · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 24
Joe Montana 34+
Steve Young 17
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29
Roger Staubach 32
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 8-
Jim Kelly 4
Dan Fouts 17

I'm glad there are not any homers here

cowboyfreak · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 25
Joe Montana 33
Steve Young 17
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29
Roger Staubach 32
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 8
Jim Kelly 4
Dan Fouts 17

____________________________

Explanation: It is 99.99% impossible to have the best QB and the Best WR on the same team- I think everyone here will agree that Rice is the greatest WR ever. I think Joey benefitted more from Rice than Jerry did from Montana.
I mean, who can't throw a 3 yard pass and let Jerry take it the other 67!

The Panch · Mar 6, 2008

cowboyfreak;1987776 said:
Explanation: It is 99.99% impossible to have the best QB and the Best WR on the same team- I think everyone here will agree that Rice is the greatest WR ever. I think Joey benefitted more from Rice than Jerry did from Montana.
I mean, who can't throw a 3 yard pass and let Jerry take it the other 67!

And yet Joe won half his rings, two SB MVPs and three All-Pros without him. Your theory is flawed. Montana was already a 1st ballad HOF before he had Rice.

kmd24 · Mar 6, 2008

gollum;1987673 said:
I'm glad there are not any homers here

Did you ever actually watch Staubach play? I won't defend Aikman, but Roger could almost single-handedly change the outcome of games. Best of his era, hands down.

Seven · Mar 6, 2008

eman721;1987154 said:
LOL, I knew my post was going to get that kind of reaction.

Consider it more of a statement vote than anything. Do I think that he is the best QB of all time? Probably not. But I do think that his greatness has been undervalued since he retired. He was a remarkably efficient runner and passer (admittedly facilitated by his play in the WCO).

I've seen him badmouthed enough on this board, especially around the time of his HoF induction, and I can't really understand it.

You obviuosly didn't read the bad mouthing posts thoroughly.......

BehindEnemyLinez · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 25
Joe Montana 33
Steve Young 17
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29
Roger Staubach 33 - no homerism, just loved his game!

Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 7 - avg QB who rode the coattails of plenty of HOFs
Jim Kelly 4
Dan Fouts 17

I cannot believe Moon isn't still on this list! I hope it's not a race issue...

gollum · Mar 6, 2008

kmd24;1988009 said:
Did you ever actually watch Staubach play? I won't defend Aikman, but Roger could almost single-handedly change the outcome of games. Best of his era, hands down.

He is my favorite player of all time, but that doesn't make him the best to ever play the position.

cowboyfreak · Mar 6, 2008

The Panch;1987792 said:
And yet Joe won half his rings, two SB MVPs and three All-Pros without him. Your theory is flawed. Montana was already a 1st ballad HOF before he had Rice.

Point conceded - So if Montana is the best ever, is Rice the best ever...That's just unfathomable to me. One has to cancel the other out or at least lessen his greatness!

The Panch · Mar 6, 2008

cowboyfreak;1988142 said:
Point conceded - So if Montana is the best ever, is Rice the best ever...That's just unfathomable to me. One has to cancel the other out or at least lessen his greatness!

Why? Some people may have a hard time admitting they're the best at their position, especially Montana with the QB competition of Elway, Unitas, Brady, Manning, etc. but sometimes you just have to look at the achievements and Montana won 2 rings without Rice and Rice won a ring without Montana. Montana 4-0 in the SB with no interceptions and Rice's numbers in the SB were great, even with a Raider team that was forced to go against a Tampa team coached by a guy who knew their playbook.

TwentyOne · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 25
Joe Montana 34 + simply the best ever to play the game at qb
Steve Young 16 - never seen a much more overrated qb. just look at the nfc championship game 94.
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29
Roger Staubach 33
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 7
Jim Kelly 4
Dan Fouts 17

kojak · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 25
Joe Montana 35 +1
Steve Young 16
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29
Roger Staubach 33
Dan Marino 24 -1
Terry Bradshaw 7
Jim Kelly 4
Dan Fouts 17

ROMOSAPIEN9 · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 26+ Singlehandedly took 3 teams to the SB.
Joe Montana 35
Steve Young 16
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29
Roger Staubach 33
Dan Marino 24
Terry Bradshaw 6- Career Passer Rating 70.9 STATS
Jim Kelly 4
Dan Fouts 17

THUMPER · Mar 6, 2008

kojak;1988183 said:
Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 25
Joe Montana 35 +1
Steve Young 16
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29
Roger Staubach 33
Dan Marino 24 -1
Terry Bradshaw 7
Jim Kelly 4
Dan Fouts 17

Do you really believe that Dan Marino is the worst QB out of this group?

Skinsmaniac · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 26
Joe Montana 36 +1
Steve Young 16
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29
Roger Staubach 33
Dan Marino 24
Terry Bradshaw 6
Jim Kelly 3 -1
Dan Fouts 17

My second vote. I don't know why but I really like this game.

Pukindog · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 26
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 16
Tom Brady 20
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29
Roger Staubach 34 +
Dan Marino 24
Terry Bradshaw 5 -
Jim Kelly 3
Dan Fouts 17

DT101 · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 26
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 16
Tom Brady 19 -1
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29
Roger Staubach 35 +1
Dan Marino 24
Terry Bradshaw 5
Jim Kelly 3
Dan Fouts 17

jackrussell · Mar 6, 2008

Just a reminder....

Bradshaw and Kelly are dangerously close to elimination. Once someone selects a player that makes him hit 0...it's the NEXT poster that removes them from the list.

Once a day voting...should start to get more difficult with each elimination.

And thanks to those that have made the appropriate corrections...you know who you are.

VietCowboy · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 26
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 16 -1 = 15 (can't count, lol)
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 29 + 1 = 30
Roger Staubach 35
Dan Marino 24
Terry Bradshaw 5
Jim Kelly 3
Dan Fouts 17

can we keep the symbols the same? I get confused with the differing systems everyone is using

MCowboys · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 26
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31 +
Roger Staubach 35
Dan Marino 24
Terry Bradshaw 5
Jim Kelly 3
Dan Fouts 16 -

the kid 05 · Mar 6, 2008

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21 +
John Elway 26
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18 -
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 35
Dan Marino 24
Terry Bradshaw 5
Jim Kelly 3
Dan Fouts 16

Best QB Game

Member

Member

New Member

Active Member

Messenger to the football Gods

Optimist Prime

Member

Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Who Loves Ya Baby?

Proud Grandpa

Papa

Boycotting Snyder since 2009

Member

Member

Last of the Duke Street Kings

Be Realistic. Demand the Impossible.

New Member

Individuals play the game, but teams beat the odds